Hiphopper Posted September 8 Posted September 8 I really don't get it. What's wrong with that video she shared? That video didn't say anything against Palestine, so Hamas is acceptable now? Hamas is the victim now? Don't get me wrong, I also think Israel is way too overreacting, and two wrongs don't make a right, but still, what Hamas did to Israel in Re'im was too brutal to be let go.
Gabriel Guedes Posted September 8 Posted September 8 2 hours ago, Hiphopper said: I really don't get it. What's wrong with that video she shared? That video didn't say anything against Palestine, so Hamas is acceptable now? Hamas is the victim now? Don't get me wrong, I also think Israel is way too overreacting, and two wrongs don't make a right, but still, what Hamas did to Israel in Re'im was too brutal to be let go. The video overall is quits problematic, it starts by saying that artists who support the "artists for ceasefire" movement are either "anti jew" (Sara Ramirez) or "dumb enough" to no understand what they're saying (J.Lo and Channing Tatum), among other things... However, I think the internet as a whole has already decided who's the bad guy and who's the nice guy in this war (like there's anyone nice in a F***ing war), but 99% of all people, including P!nk herself, don't know Geopolitics enough to be making such harsh statements about this, so it is better to stay quiet.
Braz Posted September 8 Posted September 8 That video is super dumb but she's never been smart to stay out of **** like this. She deserves to get cancelled again. 2
Liafen Posted September 8 Posted September 8 I hope the 5 people who bought tickets for her LA show won't see it 1
BrokenMachine Posted September 8 Posted September 8 10 hours ago, Hiphopper said: https://www.algemeiner.com/2023/10/30/singer-pink-condemns-hamas-and-violence-at-hate-filled-protests-around-the-world/ This is not the first time she speaks out against Hamas, no? That was still keeping a 'neutral' point of view tho, with the 'Protecting innocent civilian life must remain of utmost priority. No one should celebrate the murder of women and children.'
BrokenMachine Posted September 8 Posted September 8 5 hours ago, Hiphopper said: I really don't get it. What's wrong with that video she shared? That video didn't say anything against Palestine, so Hamas is acceptable now? Hamas is the victim now? Context is very important. She could have posted a video condemning Hamas whenever she wanted and no one would have cared aside from some extremists. But the video is not just about Hamas, the video also is saying how 'wrong' a movement asking for a ceasefire is, coming from the same singer who once sang how 'hardwork is rebuilding your house after bombs took them away', but seems like she couldn't care less about it nowadays.
Hiphopper Posted September 8 Posted September 8 5 minutes ago, BrokenMachine said: Context is very important. She could have posted a video condemning Hamas whenever she wanted and no one would have cared aside from some extremists. But the video is not just about Hamas, the video also is saying how 'wrong' a movement asking for a ceasefire is, coming from the same singer who once sang how 'hardwork is rebuilding your house after bombs took them away', but seems like she couldn't care less about it nowadays. I don't think the whole point is how wrong asking for a ceasefire, but it takes both sides to do it. And that statement is kind of ignoring the other side, and maybe that's the reason why you don't see so many big names on it.
Braz Posted September 8 Posted September 8 I'm just glad I don't have Twitter anymore to see the lashings. 1
Underdogs Posted September 8 Posted September 8 This is the first time she's been on the wrong side of history (in my view). It's giving highly out of touch, misinformed and foot in mouth. Sometimes you should stay silent if you don't have all the information. 6
BrokenMachine Posted September 8 Posted September 8 (edited) 1 hour ago, Hiphopper said: I don't think the whole point is how wrong asking for a ceasefire, but it takes both sides to do it. And that statement is kind of ignoring the other side, and maybe that's the reason why you don't see so many big names on it. I watched the video once again in case I missed something, but the video is pure bias and propaganda... while 'callling out bias an propaganda'. It even says 'PALESTINIANS perpetuated the worst mass4.cre on the Jewish people since the Holocaust', he didn't even say 'Hamas' in there, he is blatantly demonizing Palestinians while also crying on 'don't demonize Israel', and he is also leaving out the attonishing body count Israel has on Palestinians. The whole video is trying with passion to discredit an open letter that even asks for the release of the hostages, and he's just doing mental gymnastics the whole video into how a letter like that is wrong, starting by only namedropping controversial artists and saying 'they're ignorant', then he goes into the 'they don't mention Hamas' as if the US was openly funding Hamas and not Israel, and after that whole rant, saying that a 'letter won't change anything' as the final nail to try to discredit the movement. The whole video is controversial, line after line, even refutable with basic facts. And yet P!nk shared it as some 'gotcha' moment, and I'm sure she couldn't care less about it and is oblivious into what it means to share something like that. This is the kind of moment when I'm like: Edited September 8 by BrokenMachine 2 1
Hiphopper Posted September 8 Posted September 8 3 minutes ago, BrokenMachine said: I watched the video once again in case I missed something, but the video is pure bias and propaganda... while 'callling out bias an propaganda'. It even says 'PALESTINIANS perpetuated the worst mass4.cre on the Jewish people since the Holocaust', he didn't even say 'Hamas' in there, he is blatantly demonizing Palestinians while also crying on 'don't demonize Israel', and he is also leaving out the attonishing body count Israel has on Palestinians. The whole video is trying with passion to discredit an open letter that even asks for the release of the hostages, and he's just doing mental gymnastics the whole video into how a letter like that is wrong, starting by only namedropping controversial artists and saying 'they're ignorant', then he goes into the 'they don't mention Hamas' as if the US was openly funding Hamas and not Israel, and after that whole rant, saying that a 'letter won't change anything' as the final nail to try to discredit the movement. The whole video is controversial, line after line, even refutable with basic facts. And yet P!nk shared it as some 'gotcha' moment, and I'm sure she couldn't care less about it and is oblivious into what it means to share something like that. This is the kind of moment when I'm like: I see your point now. 1
Hiphopper Posted September 8 Posted September 8 (edited) I miss the good old days when she wrote about her actually feelings and thoughts, instead of just sharing things. Edited September 8 by Hiphopper 2
lyk251 Posted September 8 Posted September 8 3 hours ago, Braz said: That video is super dumb but she's never been smart to stay out of **** like this. She deserves to get cancelled again. Yep USA should cancel her ,force her to find new market in Asian ! 1
Arknex Posted September 8 Posted September 8 Can't believe this is what we got on a 10th birthday of You+Me duo instead of new music 4
LikeAChampion Posted September 8 Posted September 8 Given what happened with Taylor Swift she really shouldn't say anything about this while touring. I was supposed to see her in LA but now I'm nervous af with the large crowds.
pinktennisfreak Posted September 9 Posted September 9 On 9/6/2024 at 11:59 AM, pinktennisfreak said: You + Me single anniversary is in 2 days.
Braz Posted September 9 Posted September 9 After outing herself as a zionist, no new music in the next 2 years.
byzantium Posted September 9 Posted September 9 I wonder if she will have an Amy Schumer or JK Rowling level alt-right meltdown now.
Gabriel Guedes Posted September 9 Posted September 9 Jesus, you guys do the most. She shares one stupid video and now there are comparisons with J.K Rowling....get a grip. And so far we don't know anything about her actually being a Zionist, so let's not get ahead of ourselves and start spreading misinformation cause we all know how stan culture is, and if her own fanbase is being like this... Let's pray someone from her inner circle talks to her and educate her on what's actually happening. 7
Hiphopper Posted September 9 Posted September 9 36 minutes ago, Gabriel Guedes said: Jesus, you guys do the most. She shares one stupid video and now there are comparisons with J.K Rowling....get a grip. And so far we don't know anything about her actually being a Zionist, so let's not get ahead of ourselves and start spreading misinformation cause we all know how stan culture is, and if her own fanbase is being like this... Let's pray someone from her inner circle talks to her and educate her on what's actually happening. Thank you. The other thread was to painful to read. 90% of them didn't even know what kind of person P!nk really is, they just see the bait and can't even wait for one second to try to tear her apart. She said it herself, even if she shared something, doesn't mean she's 100% agree to it. And even tho maybe this time she's on the wrong side, does it make her a public enemy now? JC. Again, I do hope she stops sharing political post from now on, whatever the f she wanna say, WRITE YOUR OWN POST ALAZY BETH.
BrokenMachine Posted September 9 Posted September 9 (edited) 18 hours ago, LikeAChampion said: Given what happened with Taylor Swift she really shouldn't say anything about this while touring. I was supposed to see her in LA but now I'm nervous af with the large crowds. So good that date is flopping so there won't be large crowds in sight Edited September 9 by BrokenMachine 1
BrokenMachine Posted September 9 Posted September 9 19 hours ago, Arknex said: Can't believe this is what we got on a 10th birthday of You+Me duo instead of new music I CAN believe this 1
Liafen Posted September 9 Posted September 9 The way our biggest problem just 2 months ago were some goddamn balloons. 3
Recommended Posts