Jump to content

Gaga transition from music to film going viral | Indiewire weighs in.


Link16
 Share

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 324
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • Blue Rose

    18

  • Ethereaaal

    25

  • Leptine

    18

  • Marry Illusion Glory

    21

Top Posters In This Topic

18 minutes ago, Link16 said:

UPDATE:

 

Harry Styles, Actor: What Would Make Him a Good One?

 

You can’t fault Styles for being green amid the grind of press corps talking points — he’s only made four movies, and that’s if you count his post-credits “Eternals” cameo. He is a pop star trying to mold himself into the image of an actor, as other pop stars have tried, some with more success (Lady Gaga) than others (Madonna). His remarks reflect a misunderstanding of the craft — or at least a less than fully formed appreciation of it —and that’s reflected in his work.

 

https://www.indiewire.com/2022/09/harry-styles-good-actor-1234764798/

 

:clap3:

oh wow:jonny6:

 

also the absolutely deranged replies in this thread from that fanbase when we're just trying to celebrate Gaga's success. Pathetic, unhinged and loser behavior...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

42 minutes ago, Link16 said:

He is a pop star trying to mold himself into the image of an actor, as other pop stars have tried, some with more success (Lady Gaga) than others (Madonna).

8dk.gif

Link to comment
Share on other sites

41 minutes ago, Link16 said:

You can’t fault Styles for being green amid the grind of press corps talking points — he’s only made four movies, and that’s if you count his post-credits “Eternals” cameo. He is a pop star trying to mold himself into the image of an actor, as other pop stars have tried, some with more success (Lady Gaga) than others (Madonna). His remarks reflect a misunderstanding of the craft — or at least a less than fully formed appreciation of it —and that’s reflected in his work.

:mandown: 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 9/21/2022 at 9:48 PM, Fnooky said:

 

 

 

 

Do you not realize that by setting this "she must be nominated for an Oscar every time" standard, you are proving just how massive and spectacular her career as an actress is? :jonny: No other actor has that standard applied to them. She was nominated for every other major award, including the coveted BAFTA, so this miss was just as much a surprise to everyone as it was to Gaga stans. Again, proving what a brilliant position she's in right now. :ahh: 

 

 

On 9/21/2022 at 10:55 PM, Pop Art said:

Academy Awards

Barbra Streisand: 2 Wins / 5 Nominations

Lady Gaga: 1 Win / 3 Nominations

Cher: 1 Win / 2 Nominations

- - - SINGULAR NOMINATION BARRIER - - -

Adele: 1 Win / 1 Nomination

Billie Eilish: 1 Win / 1 Nomination

Jennifer Hudson: 1 Win / 1 Nomination

- - - NO WINS BARRIER - - -

Mary J. Blige: 2 Nominations

Bette Midler: 2 Nominations

Beyoncé: 1 Nomination

Andra Day: 1 Nomination

Queen Latifah: 1 Nomination

 - - - NO NOMINATIONS BARRIER - - -

Christina Aguilera: 0 Nominations

Mariah Carey: 0 Nominations

Miley Cyrus: 0 Nominations

Selena Gomez: 0 Nominations

Ariana Grande: 0 Nominations

Whitney Houston: 0 Nominations

Jennifer Lopez: 0 Nominations

Demi Lovato: 0 Nominations

Madonna: 0 Nominations

Olivia Newton-John: 0 Nominations

Rihanna: 0 Nominations

Britney Spears: 0 Nominations

Taylor Swift: 0 Nominations

 

I can see why some people seem to be upset. :'(

ddddd the way gaga has the chance to tie Babs in both wins and nominations with TG. :ahh:

 

8 hours ago, LosingHimWasBlue said:

Why y’all compared Bey and Gaga??

 

The difference is, Bey didn’t wait to underperform on Music Industry to Join Movie Industry. She is the IT girl on that moment. :clap3:


Meanwhile Gaga hit her low music career with artpop, c2c and joanne Flop, and starting to take offer from Bradley for ASIB remake (the issue is Beyonce declined the role). :sistrens:

No, the difference is Beyonce has tried to successfully transition into acting multiple times and has been rejected by the industry Every. Single. Time. If Gaga was truly at a "music career low" when she starred in ASIB, why did ASIB blow up? Why did people flock to the theaters to see her and to the records stores to buy the ASIB soundtrack? Why was it so easy for the public to fall in love with Gaga if her career was so low? Maybe it has something to do with the fact that her career wasn't at a low and the only people who thought that were OGHs who don't know how to sign off of ATRL. :ahh: 

 

Beyonce was NEVER offered the role because the version that she was rumored to play in was NEVER greenlit. Why? Because ZERO movie studios wanted to invest in a Beyonce-led film like that. ZERO financiers felt comfortable forking over the cash for someone who has zero acting talent. No matter how many times you push this narrative, it's simply untrue. I'm not sure why you Hive members seem to think "Beyonce's version was never made official" is some kind of drag on anyone other than Beyonce. :deadbanana: 

Edited by Bang Up
Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 9/22/2022 at 3:07 AM, Fnooky said:

Did she win for Gucci at the Golden Globes? Critics Choice? SAG? BAFTAs? :gaycat5:

The way you are so incredibly bitter and pressed :ahh:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Link16 said:

UPDATE:

 

Harry Styles, Actor: What Would Make Him a Good One?

 

You can’t fault Styles for being green amid the grind of press corps talking points — he’s only made four movies, and that’s if you count his post-credits “Eternals” cameo. He is a pop star trying to mold himself into the image of an actor, as other pop stars have tried, some with more success (Lady Gaga) than others (Madonna). His remarks reflect a misunderstanding of the craft — or at least a less than fully formed appreciation of it —and that’s reflected in his work.

 

https://www.indiewire.com/2022/09/harry-styles-good-actor-1234764798/

 

:clap3:

:ahh:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

46 minutes ago, Bang Up said:

 

 

No, the difference is Beyonce has tried to successfully transition into acting multiple times and has been rejected by the industry Every. Single. Time. If Gaga was truly at a "music career low" when she starred in ASIB, why did ASIB blow up? Why did people flock to the theaters to see her and to the records stores to buy the ASIB soundtrack? Why was it so easy for the public to fall in love with Gaga if her career was so low? Maybe it has something to do with the fact that her career wasn't at a low and the only people who thought that were OGHs who don't know how to sign off of ATRL. :ahh: 

 

Beyonce was NEVER offered the role because the version that she was rumored to play in was NEVER greenlit. Why? Because ZERO movie studios wanted to invest in a Beyonce-led film like that. ZERO financiers felt comfortable forking over the cash for someone who has zero acting talent. No matter how many times you push this narrative, it's simply untrue. I'm not sure why you Hive members seem to think "Beyonce's version was never made official" is some kind of drag on anyone other than Beyonce. :deadbanana: 

This bizarre frothing at the mouth meltdown when Beyonce has multiple hit movies AND acclaimed roles under her belt AND a music career Lady Gaga can only dream of. Again, Rotten Tomatoes is right there.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Link16 said:

UPDATE:

 

Harry Styles, Actor: What Would Make Him a Good One?

 

You can’t fault Styles for being green amid the grind of press corps talking points — he’s only made four movies, and that’s if you count his post-credits “Eternals” cameo. He is a pop star trying to mold himself into the image of an actor, as other pop stars have tried, some with more success (Lady Gaga) than others (Madonna). His remarks reflect a misunderstanding of the craft — or at least a less than fully formed appreciation of it —and that’s reflected in his work.

 

https://www.indiewire.com/2022/09/harry-styles-good-actor-1234764798/

 

:clap3:

Indiewire, one of the most prestigious and serious media outlet knows the tea contrary to the miserable trolls of this site :clap3:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

11 minutes ago, Jay07 said:

This bizarre frothing at the mouth meltdown when Beyonce has multiple hit movies AND acclaimed roles under her belt AND a music career Lady Gaga can only dream of. Again, Rotten Tomatoes is right there.

Ummm :coffee2:

 

OT: Loving that update! I just know the losers are seething HARD and actually frothing at their mouth.  :bird:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Jay07 said:

This bizarre frothing at the mouth meltdown when Beyonce has multiple hit movies AND acclaimed roles under her belt AND a music career Lady Gaga can only dream of. Again, Rotten Tomatoes is right there.

This bizarre frothing at the mouth meltdown when your fave Brit Spears bombed into Razzieland with Crossroads, desperately chased The Notebook, and made mv's about being a Hollywood girl winning Oscars, proving how badly popstars want and fail to be actors. 

 

Let's not get into Janet collaborating with John Singleton after his history-making Boyz N The Hood on Poetic Justice and flopping critically and commercially (cuz I love Janet). 

Anyway, lmaoo at Indiewire. Poor Madonna catching strays

 

EQ8gLI2UwAAkWTa.jpg 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

14 minutes ago, perfillusion said:

This bizarre frothing at the mouth meltdown when your fave Brit Spears bombed into Razzieland with Crossroads, desperately chased The Notebook, and made mv's about being a Hollywood girl winning Oscars, proving how badly popstars want and fail to be actors. 

 

Let's not get into Janet collaborating with John Singleton after his history-making Boyz N The Hood on Poetic Justice and flopping critically and commercially (cuz I love Janet). 

Anyway, lmaoo at Indiewire. Poor Madonna catching strays

 

EQ8gLI2UwAAkWTa.jpg 

The fact that you know this and I being a stan don't says a lot about your obsession with her and these are literally the lyrics of Lucky: Isn't she lovely?, this Hollywood girl? Of course the video was gonna portrait her as an actress, genius :toofunny3:

 

OT: Gaga made a good transition from pop star to actress which is quite rare, just a handful of ladies have done this, there's no reason to diminish her accolades as some people are doing here.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

21 minutes ago, UnusualBoy said:

The fact that you know this and I being a stan don't says a lot about your obsession with her and these are literally the lyrics of Lucky: Isn't she lovely?, this Hollywood girl? Of course the video was gonna portrait her as an actress, genius :toofunny3:

 

OT: Gaga made a good transition from pop star to actress which is quite rare, just a handful of ladies have done this, there's no reason to diminish her accolades as some people are doing here.

There were literal threads about it on ATRL a few months ago. Anyway, you Brit Spears stans make the most bizarrely specific threads about Gaga stuff I've never heard about, I never see you calling them out.

 

Gaga did something none of her peers could, furthering cementing her legend status.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I knew since her Marry the Night video that she had acting chops. Just needed the right outlet for it. 

 

I honestly don't think it's anything she's had to learn. Her whole Gaga persona was a huge acting challenge in and of itself. It takes a lot of dedication to manipulate yourself to that degree that surrendering yourself to film was just a mirror to that experience. 

 

Seems her acting is eclipsing her music, now, though. Which is a shame but I'm happy for her success. She's produced enough content that I'm not mad. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 hours ago, Bang Up said:

:ahh: 

 

Beyonce was NEVER offered the role because the version that she was rumored to play in was NEVER greenlit. Why? Because ZERO movie studios wanted to invest in a Beyonce-led film like that. ZERO financiers felt comfortable forking over the cash for someone who has zero acting talent. No matter how many times you push this narrative, it's simply untrue. I'm not sure why you Hive members seem to think "Beyonce's version was never made official" is some kind of drag on anyone other than Beyonce. :deadbanana: 

There’s no way you feel that comfortable sitting there and just straight lying. :rip: Warner Bros. had already greenlit the project with Clint Eastwood at the helm directing Beyoncé and Bradley Cooper in the lead role. It had already been in their hands for about two years before the Beyoncé version started development and close to 9 before the Gaga version. Beyoncé got pregnant, which put the process on hold and in that time Eastwood just went on to direct another project, so it was put on ice indefinitely. Bradley Cooper decided to take over and keep the ball rolling after some time had passed, but these elements were all long in place before Gaga came in the fold.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Quote

Heis a pop star trying to mold himself into the image of an actor, as other pop stars have tried, some with more success (Lady Gaga)than others (Madonna).

:deadbanana4:
 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 9/22/2022 at 8:18 AM, Blue Rose said:

The movie is barely fresh. It’s 62. Isn’t 59 rotten? :toofunny2:

doubling the budget is literally the bare minimum too :rip: 

House Of Gucci is closer to “panned flop” than it is to “critical smash”

 

spacer.png

I cant believe someone can post things this stupid..

Link to comment
Share on other sites

8 minutes ago, Take Me Apart said:

70k likes is not viral and Gaga’s second hollywood role barely made any noise

Whew, I’ve seen it all :rip:

 

I don’t understand either side’s need to come for the other tbh, Gaga and Beyoncé are arguably the two most prestigious and respected women in the music industry right now — recognized and revered by both their peers and the public. They’re in their own lanes and have mastered their crafts, the attempts to discredit either of them with delusional, desperate lies are dumb.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Her transition is very impressive and she’s on her way to solidifying herself as a main actress girl like Barbra and Cher did but she’s only done 2 movies so far so we shouldn’t get ahead of ourselves.

 

We’ve seen she can do drama well and was ok at horror in AHS but I’d like to see if she can pull off comedy. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 Share

×
×
  • Create New...