discussion 93 > 79, agreed?

[Johnny Jacobs]

Oh indeed.. 

 

Some just doesn't have that in them 

[John Slayne]

y'all need to go outside more and get a job 

[Bears01]

12 hours ago, Trent W said:

I love both albums

But Rena is way above

 

And honestly it’s good to see karma manifesting

 

The monsters were horrible to Beyonce all this era

[Oceania]

Wait, Renaissance really ended up getting a 93 on MC? 

 

I should be fuming but LocalCritic is so irrelevant it's tragicomic.

Besides, anybody with at least 2 active brain cells knows that Bey and meritocracy are two parallel lines and never intersect.

 

Like, imagine the ratings had Bjork, Erikah Badu, Janet or Kate Bush released an album like that. 

 

[Archetype]

This is not the case for people who read backwards.  39 is in fact NOT better than 97.  

[terrorblade]

13 hours ago, GraceRandolph said:

Who even trusts metacritic? It’s become gentrified and more worthless than rotten tomatoes. 

13 hours ago, HauntinglyHollow said:

Beyonce could release an album filled with recordings of her taking a dump and it would get 90+ ratings and endless praises... on the other hand if any other girl released Renaissance it would most likely get mixed ratings 

[arceus]

Chromatica is only for the gays. Renaissance is made almost entirely for critics. 

[Jude]

What's this for? 

[DenzxShe]

19 hours ago, Zaram said:

She for sure didn't received those 93 for a good album tho 

 

 

you can really see that yt gays have no knowledge of ballroom culture and THAT’S why y’all think Renaissance isn’t good. go educate yourselves PLEASE. y’all are so used to generic dance music you aren’t even aware when something phenomenal is right in front of you 

[Pepo]

7 hours ago, Oceania said:

Wait, Renaissance really ended up getting a 93 on MC? 

 

I should be fuming but LocalCritic is so irrelevant it's tragicomic.

Besides, anybody with at least 2 active brain cells knows that Bey and meritocracy are two parallel lines and never intersect.

 

Like, imagine the ratings had Bjork, Erikah Badu, Janet or Kate Bush released an album like that. 

 

SUFFER! 

[Zaram]

21 minutes ago, DenzxShe said:

you can really see that yt gays have no knowledge of ballroom culture and THAT’S why y’all think Renaissance isn’t good. go educate yourselves PLEASE. y’all are so used to generic dance music you aren’t even aware when something phenomenal is right in front of you 

So when I get education my taste gets worse? Interesting logic 

[MardinBeksloy]

Girl beyonce can burp and fart on a disc, and the critics will still give it 80+

[Bears01]

58 minutes ago, Zaram said:

So when I get education my taste gets worse? Interesting logic 

I just know you’re fuming this week so hard because you rushed to every Beyonce related thread to call her a flop, and this week she is literally outselling, outstreaming, and out acclaiming your fave, and that’s without bundles and features from the 2 biggest streaming acts in the world 

[Zaram]

51 minutes ago, Bears01 said:

I just know you’re fuming this week so hard because you rushed to every Beyonce related thread to call her a flop, and this week she is literally outselling, outstreaming, and out acclaiming your fave, and that’s without bundles and features from the 2 biggest streaming acts in the world 

Or maybe it is because I had covid the past week and I work since yesterday.

But I like your delusional opinion inclusive mini meltdown too 

[Bears01]

36 minutes ago, Zaram said:

Or maybe it is because I had covid the past week and I work since yesterday.

But I like your delusional opinion inclusive mini meltdown too 

1. Hope you’re feeling better 

 

2. I wouldn’t call it a meltdown so much as stating facts 

 

3. Hope you enjoyed Renny while in quarantine 

[mellenthin]

43 minutes ago, Zaram said:

Or maybe it is because I had covid the past week

Explains having no taste!

[Zaram]

1 hour ago, Bears01 said:

1. Hope you’re feeling better 

 

2. I wouldn’t call it a meltdown so much as stating facts 

 

3. Hope you enjoyed Renny while in quarantine 

1. Aww thanks

 

3. Just listened to the first two songs and let me not be an OBH  But BMS is cute. Recommend some dancy bop on that album and I will check it out

[Bears01]

5 minutes ago, Zaram said:

1. Aww thanks

 

3. Just listened to the first two songs and let me not be an OBH  But BMS is cute. Recommend some dancy bop on that album and I will check it out

Summer Renaissance the last song, America has a problem, all up in your mind, cuff it, diso song “Virgos Groove”. If the good sis @Trent Wcan change his ways, you can too 

[Hurem]

19 hours ago, Wizard said:

the fumes in here  renny really did some damage 

Your fave released a studio album y'all waited for six years and you can't stop talking about Chromatica. Talk about damage  

[4Real]

On 8/3/2022 at 2:19 PM, HauntinglyHollow said:

not this you know damn well she contributed NOTHING to that album and that it was created by 5478 other people 

how stupid does one have to be to think this?

[Aethereal]

On 8/3/2022 at 7:05 PM, Zaram said:

She for sure didn't received those 93 for a good album tho 

 

 

What was the Gaga's part supposed to show? 

Both parts sound horrible. 

Edited August 6, 2022 by Aristotle

[zasderfght]

The more we keep giving into threads like these (and I'm part of the problem as I sit here and type), the more they will appear. 

 

I will add this: Beyonce has released projects that were scored lower than Gaga's. That's not to take away from Renaissance's critical acclaim, and I absolutely love the album, but let's be more level-headed/impartial here. 

 

Dangerously in Love scored a 63 on MC while The Fame scored a 71. 

 

B'Day scored a 70 while The Fame Monster AND Born This Way scored a 78 and 71, respectively (whether you consider TFM or BTW Gaga's second album is your call/pick, according to Gaga herself). 

 

It wasn't until B was on her 4th album that she was a critics' darling. 

[Luckitty]

9+3=12

7+9=16

 

16 > 12