Jump to content

Vanishing Letters 10 | WINNER REVEALED (pg. 118) | #ATRL'sNextTopVanisher


Overprotected
 Share

Recommended Posts

16 minutes ago, XO_Life said:

Well... I am too late. :( 

 

You’re not!! You just need to send your song for round one, signups are still open until the deadline

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 2.9k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • wish

    218

  • Touch It

    214

  • Overprotected

    364

  • Julia Fox

    266

On 7/18/2022 at 11:28 AM, thecptz said:

1. diogozsz

2. Julia Fox

3. Legend E

4. K$Ellie

5. wish
6. rotunda 

7. Seffers

8. Element

9. Hikari

10. Lucky#17

11. Noah

12. brycehooha

13. boys

14. luckystrike

15. D e v o n

16. Opulent

17. Technicolor

18. Future Lover
19. ZORBIT 
20. Bicassie 

21. MusicLoverDude

22. selena_lavigne

23. touya kinomoto

24. Moonlightbae

25. Mr. Duff

26. mokitsu

27. fiercE

28. Allday

29. Taylucifer

30. Luckitty

31. 99sandthe2000s

32. Touch It

33. thecptz

 

signed up bc of @Touch It

koco13.thumb.gif.971e1950cc3cb6ea0d3c73e

omg tysm

Link to comment
Share on other sites

RED VELVET, TOVE LO, AND BILLIE EILISH BANNED

Link to comment
Share on other sites

SHAKIRA IS BANNED

Link to comment
Share on other sites

omg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

18 hours ago, Auburn said:

BILLIE EILISH BANNED

how could you :'(

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, wish said:

how could you :'(

it wasn't me :'( 

positions-tanked.thumb.gif.1959401779fbc

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Btw stream emails i can’t send by Sabrina Carpenter 

positions-tanked.thumb.gif.1959401779fbc

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

omg pte 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Posted (edited)

 

ROUND 1: START OF SOMETHING NEW

Rank the entries of the group you're in and send them to me through Discord preferably or ATRL DMs

 

Excluding your own entry, rank from 1-18 (or 19 in group b's case):

 

1. ex: Honey and I [BEST SONG]

2. ex: Don't Save Me [2ND BEST SONG]

18. ex: My Song 5 [WORST SONG]

 

Judges will be ranking and critiquing both groups

 

GROUP A

Quote

kipperskipper

Legend E

XO_Life

minho

Rotunda

99sandthe2000s

Fruity

Future Lover

Touch It

ZORBIT

Noah

mokitsu

brycehooha

K$Ellie

Hug

Lucky#17

wish

Element

Seffers

Quote

Charli XCX - Good Ones

Adele - Hello

Lizzo - About Damn Time

Rihanna - Russian Roulette

Janet Jackson - Feedback

Paramore - Misery Business

TWICE - Fancy

beabadobee - Talk

WJSN - UNNATURAL

Billie Eilish - Ocean Eyes

Red Velvet - Peek-A-Boo

Fei - Fantasy

Tove Lo - Glad He's Gone

Shakira - Whenever Wherever

Sophia Carson - Fool's Gold

Caroline Polachek - Door

Ciara - Goodies

Confidence Man - Holiday

Nadia Oh - My Egyptian Lover

Spotify Playlist

 

GROUP B

 

Quote

thecptz

Luckitty

touya kinomoto

Mr. Duff

selena_lavigne

MusicLoverDude

Taylucifer

Moonlightbae

Pinkbox

Allday

Bicassie

Opulent

Julia Fox

Rence

 

Hikari

boys

Technicolor

fiercE

luckystrike

Quote

Demi Lovato - Here We Go Again

Janelle Monae - Violet Stars Happy Hunting!

Billie Eilish - my future

Dido - Here With Me

Doja Cat - Kiss Me More

Kaoma - Lambada

FLO - Cardboard Box

Apink CHOBOM - Copycat

Linkin Park - What I've Done

Tove Lo - How Long

Rihanna - We Found Love

Foxes - Sister Ray

Kelis - Bossy

Red Velvet - Psycho

Mabel - Let Them Know

Kesha - Praying

Hatchie - This Enchanted

Leona Lewis - Bleeding Love

Céline Dion - I Drove All Night

Shakira - La Tortura

Spotify Playlist

 

DEADLINE: FRIDAY JULY 22ND 1PM EST

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Edited by Overprotected
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yay the spoiler worked 

positions-tanked.thumb.gif.1959401779fbc

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 minutes ago, CBC said:

It already started??? :toofunny2:

Girl you better rank then because I’m sure you stole my first choice 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Charli XCX - Good Ones: it's alright

Adele - Hello: pretty song good one

Lizzo - About Damn Time: bop

Rihanna - Russian Roulette: one of the best songs of all time fr what a classic

Janet Jackson - Feedback: bop

Paramore - Misery Business: amazing classic

TWICE - Fancy: best song of all time

beabadobee - Talk: best song of all time but even more best

WJSN - UNNATURAL: best kpop song of 2021 besides for savage and next level

Billie Eilish - Ocean Eyes: snooze

Red Velvet - Peek-A-Boo: bop

Fei - Fantasy: cute

Tove Lo - Glad He's Gone: love

Shakira - Whenever Wherever: fun classic

Sophia Carson - Fool's Gold: cute

Caroline Polachek - Door: beautiful song

Ciara - Goodies: it's nice

Confidence Man - Holiday: I like this

Nadia Oh - My Egyptian Lover: this was interesting

Link to comment
Share on other sites

IXk1cX1.png

zkQgoIn.png "only correct opinions!"

 

Charli XCX - Good Ones
A LOT of Charli songs would've got tanked to the ground by me, but this isn't one of them. LOVE this song.

 

Adele - Hello
Iconic because it's Adele but nobody would care if it wasn't her.

 

Lizzo - About Damn Time
I can appreciate she's trying to have fun, at least!

 

Rihanna - Russian Roulette
Slay actually? I loved Edgihanna.

 

Janet Jackson - Feedback
I don't really think about this song but it's good yeah.

 

Paramore - Misery Business
I hate pop rock, but this is kinda one of my all time favorites of the genre.

 

TWICE - FANCY
TBH TWICE have better...but they have worse too. This is alright.

 

beabadoobee - Talk
This is winning the round probably. Gross. I mentioned I hated pop rock and this isn't an exception.

 

WJSN - UNNATURAL
I wish I liked this more, but alas it's one of the weakest on this mini to me. If only New Me was the title.

 

Billie Eilish - ocean eyes
This is fine. I think it's pretty!

 

Red Velvet - Peek-A-Boo
If only I liked their Red music, but alas...

 

Fei - Fantasy
This is so criminally underrated and was done horrendously wrong due to circumstances that had absolutely nothing to do with the song itself.

 

Tove Lo - Glad He's Gone
The MV for this is great, but I kinda don't like this song. :(

 

Shakira - Whenever, Wherever
I loathe this woman I'm so sorry to whoever sent this. I'm sure you'll have others that like the song.

 

Sofia Carson - Fool's Gold
The chorus on this is kinda great idk...

 

Caroline Polachek - Door
This kinda drones...5 and a half minutes??? I am NOT here for the art.

 

Ciara - Goodies
I feel like this is gonna underperform but I'm rating this well at least! Big classic.

 

Confidence Man - Holiday
I really like the production here!

 

Nadia Oh - My Egyptian Lover
I think she invented PC music?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

52 minutes ago, Julia Fox said:

Girl you better rank then because I’m sure you stole my first choice 

I didn't send anything :toofunny2:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

24 minutes ago, CBC said:

I didn't send anything :toofunny2:

******

Link to comment
Share on other sites

oCtQpvu.gif

 

GROUP A

Charli XCX - Good Ones: It’s okay until that cheap drop comes in and ruins the whole song. Does sound better on headphones cuz there’s some light quirks in the production throughout but I kinda hate it sorry ffff


Adele - Hello: For the record I’m an OAH but this has a grand feeling and makes me a bit nostalgic now, won't rank high cuz of her nasal ass voice but won’t be last!


Lizzo - About Damn Time: Somewhat cute, was obviously nothing new for her but works for what it is ig


Rihanna - Russian Roulette: I’m glad you decided to go with this one!! It’s my fave of the Rihanna singles that were still available, that thumping Massive Attack-ish beat slaps


Janet Jackson - Feedback: I’M HEAVY LIKE A FIRST DAY PERIODDDD ubTZ1mT.gif Loveeee, such a banger


Paramore - Misery Business: She came on this ***** mad as hell… fr because this is so angsty sjhg but in a way I adore, good choice


TWICE - Fancy: Fun and carefree energy, near their peak for sure


beabadoobee - Talk: YES WINNER!!!! One of my favorite songs of the year, just the perfect balance between distortion and lucidity, the riffs are INCREDIBLE, every line is memorable and it works so well as a short track. My #1!


WJSN - UNNATURAL: Enjoyable, pretty euphoric chorus, but probably middle of the pack at best here


Billie Eilish - Ocean Eyes: Still her best tbh! Something about her vocal here just HITS, and I do get an aquatic feel from it


Red Velvet - Peek-A-Boo: The handclaps and snaps make all the difference and are my favorite part of the song. It’s cute enough overall


Fei - Fantasy: Only song I didn't know before the round so I listened twice - at first I felt like it wandered around aimlessly at some points but it definitely went more from pleasant to pretty on second listen. Super easy on the ears in all aspects!


Tove Lo - Glad He's Gone: This was a grower for me, but I do unfortunately think it’s among the weaker songs here. Not really anything special imo


Shakira - Whenever Wherever: Nostalgic classic… amazing, almost too catchy


Sofia Carson - Fool's Gold: Ah this Rayeject, really loved it when it came out but stopped listening quick. Still very good!


Caroline Polachek - Door: Another one where I’m normally not a fan of the artist but have to praise the song choice. She captured the vibe of the concept remarkably well


Ciara - Goodies: Classic again! That synth is god-tier (though I feel like I would hate it if I ever spammed this nn, but great in moderation)


Confidence Man - Holiday: Um so I listened to Tilt once and found her delivery grating, it’s a little better to me now but I dunno sounds like something that would play during a middle school dance scene in a movie. Can’t really say I’m huge on that lol but it’s almost endearing I suppose


Nadia Oh - My Egyptian Lover: SLAPS! Another example of quality not quantity (in terms of length), she really makes those two minutes work and the production is so hard and gritty

 

@kipperskipper @Legend E @XO_Life @minho @Rotunda @99sandthe2000s @Fruity @Future Lover @Touch It @ZORBIT @Noah @mokitsu @brycehooha @K$Ellie @Hug @Lucky#17 @wish @Element @Seffers

 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

not someone using a song i was planning on using the next round

positions-tanked.thumb.gif.1959401779fbc

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Quote

Paramore - Misery Business

Ciara - Goodies

Rihanna - We Found Love

Demi Lovato - Here We Go Again

Foxes - Sister Ray

Kesha - Praying

:jonny:

 

Quote

Charli XCX - Good Ones

Adele - Hello

Janet Jackson - Feedback

Tove Lo - Glad He's Gone

Caroline Polachek - Door

FLO - Cardboard Box

Linkin Park - What I've Done

Tove Lo - How Long

Hatchie - This Enchanted

Leona Lewis - Bleeding Love

:smitten::smitten:

 

Quote

Lizzo - About Damn Time

Rihanna - Russian Roulette

Billie Eilish - Ocean Eyes

Shakira - Whenever Wherever

Billie Eilish - my future

Kelis - Bossy

Céline Dion - I Drove All Night

Shakira - La Tortura

:jamming:

 

Quote

Confidence Man - Holiday

A cute grower! But good luck to you

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Good Ones: spammed it over 100 times but realistically it’s just an infectious semi cheap bop and definitely not something I’d consider a career highlight. However I’ll likely rank decently anyway, maybe middling!

 

Hello: it’s a big song but I’m kind of over it and even kind of eye rolled when I saw this on the submission list? Like it’s a very uninspired choice. Probably going to tank this.

 

About Damn Time: it’s cute fun and harmless nothing more. She wasn’t annoying on this song so that’s something!

 

Russian Roulette: like god damn. She gave us DRAMA. It’s overloaded with tension and lyrically + also vocally it’s one of her best. Always been obsessed always will be.

 

Feedback: really cool song. This is how you do a banger but keep it fresh, like it’s so rhythmically interesting. I love all the experimental elements that make it so inexplicably Janet and work to all her strengths.

 

Misery Business: you knew you snatched a classic. Probably the only bad thing about this song is that it invented Olivia Rodrigo.

 

Fancy: :jonny: they snapped so hard. An explosion of infectious fun.

 

Talk: I like it! Kind of!
 

Unnatural: yup yup!!

 

Ocean Eyes: it’s pretty. Idk I don’t really care for it though? One of her less interesting songs for sure. I never really connected with its simplicity like everyone else did. 

Peek-A-Boo: bop yeh… but well to be honest the instrumental is kind of annoying. 
 

Fantasy: vibing hard! Really nice.

 

Glad He’s Gone: the main hook was always so lifeless and annoying to me and there’s barely anything interesting here. Like the energy is just FLAT. Kinda mad a Tove Lo spot was used on this tbh. Maybe I’m exaggerating a little but in the context of the group this ain’t cutting it.

 

Whenever, Wherever: absolutely colossal and majorly nostalgic SMASH! I miss being like 5 and shaking my booty to this song.

 

Fool’s Gold: really random choice, I minorly applaud the risk though. It’s nothing special but cute enough. Probably will struggle so good luck!

 

Door: this song has a really gorgeous feel, Caroline’s voice and music in general has this quite magical quality and this might just be her best. I’ve actually never noticed the length on this track until someone mentioned it just now, and I guess that speaks volumes about the journey it takes me on.

 

Goodies: it’s a classic, no doubt. That instrumental is so memorable and well, unmistakable :skull: Never was obsessed with this but it’s definitely a cool song. 

Holiday: never heard this. It’s relatively interesting, I like the vibe. 

 

Nadia Oh: thanks for making my last place an easy decision.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Good ones - it's ok

Hello - :zzz:

About damn time - :zzz:

Russian roulette - good choice

Feedback - Never liked this

Misery business - classic

Fancy - classic

Talk - beyond overrated

Unnatural - good one!

ocean eyes - it's good

Peek-a-boo - kinda a masterpiece yeah..

Fantasy - that's herstory

Glad he's gone - haven't heard this one in a while. pretty good still

Whenever wherever - not for me

Fool's gold - pretty cute actually

Door - masterpiece

Goodies - nah

Holiday - hated this

My egyptian lover - :katie2:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Demi Lovato - Here We Go Again

whew it was so long till I heard this song and surprisingly it’s better than I remembered lol it’s very relatable to me since I’m going through the same **** that Demi is in this song so extra points for that… 

Janelle Monae - Violet Stars Happy Hunting!

I like the raw and real vocals here… it adds something special to the song… I think the song and the vocal performance by queen carries a lot of personality but i think song goes nowhere because it’s very like one line but gladly is very theatrical and dramatic so it doesn’t make the song that boring or bad but that’s it x very middle on the road for me… it would have been cute if that last part instrumental where more longer and it didn’t lasted three seconds lol 

Billie Eilish - my future

Thee American Amy Winehouse did that… this is good and I’m very hit or miss with miss Billie Eyelash 

Dido - Here With Me

i thought on send this but I didn’t wanted to be too obvious but I love how dramatic and climatic this song is… how it start and then how it ends… just an explosion that you don’t want it to end x 

Doja Cat - Kiss Me More

Very cute and catchy for sure… don’t know how this will rank but i know it won’t be on the bottom at least 

Kaoma - Lambada

never liked this… just too monotone and how the song has been sampled doesn’t help 

FLO - Cardboard Box

This is so playful and catchy… they are like the modern TLC and I live for it x 

Apink CHOBOM - Copycat

ok but this is like a Korean Kiss Me More and it made me scream :bibliahh: well it’s very meh for me but it’s not bad by any means… it’s catchy and very carefree but that’s it… this can be sung and made by anyone and better

Linkin Park - What I've Done

i miss Chester so much and I miss the emo era of the early 2000's… this obviously gonna benefit from the nostalgia factor for me

Tove Lo - How Long

Didn't knew this was a lead single :coffee: it’s good… I love Tove and she can do no wrong… 

Rihanna - We Found Love

ah the nostalgia! It’s very repetitive and from its time but it’s still an euphoric bop that will remind me of that depressing summer 

Foxes - Sister Ray

love this… one of the few songs from that foxes album that I liked and still play often… it’s just magic

Kelis - Bossy

That intro is so infectious :jamming: well it’s sexy and very of it’s time and it becomes of tiring because of how repetitive its… well…

Red Velvet - Psycho

umm… at the start it seemed like a Julia penned track with that Issues violins lol well this songs sounds dated and I don’t like it but at least it doesn’t sound like the typical k pop songs from prompts for that x

Mabel - Let Them Know

Never liked her music sans Thinking Of You… that’s a pass for me 

Kesha - Praying

queen of whistle notes… she’s just one of the best female musicians of all time and we are not giving her the credit she deserves… #FreeKesha #JailToDrPuke

Hatchie - This Enchanted

I love her and love this song… queen of noise dream pop
Leona Lewis - Bleeding Love

Girl had me shook with her vocals… and what a classic! Keep eating a lot and you call me a banana and maybe the best lines ever written by Ryan Tedder :clap3:

Céline Dion - I Drove All Night

wait I kind of dig this… I hate or don’t care about her ballads but this is like if she made her own Ray Of Light… it’s cool x 

Shakira - La Tortura

a hot classic! Love how the song mixes that Spanish guitar with reggaeton and is basically a interchange of excuses from both Shak and Alejandro… maybe the best reggaeton song of all time :clap3:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

group B reviews - luckyfork

 

demi lovato - here we go again: absolute classic, she was mega pissed and this still remains fresh and relevant to this day, current girls are studying this formula trying to revive pop rock but they just will never do it like she used to (not even her)

janelle monáe - violet stars happy hunting!: when this started playing the first thing that came to my mind were those super early Gaga demos from back when she went by Stefani Germanotta and had that EP called Red and Blue... truly horrendous :rip: but this got better as it progressed, I ended up not disliking it that much!

billie eilish - my future: it's a very cute song, although it's in the lower half of HTE for me and I used to not really care for it when it came out, it has grown on me quite a bit!

dido - here with me: oh this is actually quite a classic, it's a very lovely song and I really like it, my mom used to have this in her playlist when I was younger ddd

doja cat - kiss me more (feat. sza):  a modern day classic, this song is just SOOO infectious it's crazy, I actually didn't like this the first time I heard it but it truly grew into one of my favorite songs from last year, they ate down

kaoma - lambada: you are NOT for real 😭 this is like the most random choice I have ever seen in any ATRL song submission game like ever... if you're not trolling... why? lsakfhaskljdfgsdhjk

flo - cardboard box: they're very good yeah! I think I'm kinda not too overly crazy about this song like everyone else is but it is good indeed and I will be ranking it decently, maybe I need more time with it for it to grow on me

apink chobom - copycat: ehhh I don't really like this, it's like okay yeah nice whatever but it has absolutely nothing captivating my attention, it's just a random standard uninteresting k-pop song

linkin park - what I've done: I am very respectfully gonna pass on this one love x

tove lo - how long: she is just too good at making delicious pop songs, this is an absolute slay... THAT being said, I see the loophole and I don't think this is considered a lead single so I'll tank you a few spots idc!

rihanna - we found love: she just HAS the classics, maybe this is a bit dated now so it's not my fave Rih lead but it's still great nonetheless (SOS, Umbrella and Only Girl were right there) [jk idk if they are banned]

foxes - sister ray: you know this just slayed in ASC mhm... another immaculate pop song, it feels so euphoric and big and full, whew 

kelis - bossy: it's not bad but this will probably end up towards the bottom of my ranks, it's not relevant enough to me at all and made no impact on me, sorry

red velvet - psycho: this is a very good song, they need to eat like this again because their recent stuff is not it

mabel - let them know: no you don't understand I am OBSESSED!!!!!!!!! this is such a good pop song she has me in shambles actually, here's your prize in my rankings  :1stplace:

kesha - praying: was literally any other Kesha lead (other than Raising Hell) banned? this is a nice song and I love Kesha but it's gonna suffer in my ranks because there are many songs I like way more than this, sorry 

hatchie - this enchanted: oh EXACTLY! this is one of the best songs of this year (and best albums too), the vibes are just immaculate and no one is doing it like her

leona lewis - bleeding love: I was never a fan of this, it's just dated and basic and not interesting at all to me, sorry!

céline dion - I drove all night: in all honesty I really like this song only because of that slayful lipsync in Canada's drag race, but it's still a mega bop unironically

shakira - la tortura: and THAT'S how you end a round and clear a *****. this is a masterpiece as we all know already, thank you for your service

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 Share

×
×
  • Create New...