Jump to content

who has better longevity? Kelly Clarkson or Christina Aguilera?


supertiffany
 Share

who has better longevity? Kelly Clarkson or Xtina?   

78 members have voted

  1. 1. who has better longevity? Kelly Clarkson or Xtina?

    • kelly Clarkson
      61
    • Christina Aguilera
      17


Recommended Posts

Kelly Clarkson or Christina Aguilera? 

 

both are the biggest pop vocalist of the 2000's 

 

who has better longevity in 2020's and beyond?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 58
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • feelslikeadream

    3

  • KCFan2014

    5

  • Erreur2 La Nature

    2

  • BionicWooHoo

    5

Popular Days

Top Posters In This Topic

Well, I know Christina. So that one

 

Auq8KAw.gif

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Not you trying to take the heat off Gaga by making this :rip:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Kelly is bigger in 2022 and has been for several years but the other is more remembered(mainly for her first 2 eras that were Britney inspired)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

i will go ahead and say xtina cause shes still headlining events, constatly releasing music, has somewhat better stats (which is not exactly hard to do but she does it nonetheless)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Kelly had a solo smash hit 10 years after her debut. Christina was tanking like no other 10 years after her debut.

 

Also Kelly is a relevant celebrity today, Christina isn't.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Who’s the better singer and seller Xtina

 

Who have the most nostalgic songs and bops imo Kelly. Behind These Hazel Eyes what xtina song fighting against that one,  All I Have? I think not 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Kelly in…. Every metric. She’s a celebrity darling that even people who didn’t listen to her music religiously respect and love 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Kelly Clarkson is bigger in Billboard charts, and more successful overall and has longevity. Xtina has more iconic moments tho.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Kelly is more relevant. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The one who can still chart, Kelly

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Christina will always have the bigger overall career but Kelly has lasted longer on the Billboard Hot 100. Christina was the MUCH bigger celebrity in the 2000s, and now Kelly is the bigger celebrity due to her talk show. So...

 

Bigger peak = Xtina

More longevity = Kelly

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Christina has a way bigger career thanks to her much larger peak. But Kelly is going to end up outlasting her, though.

 

It’ll be interesting to see who ends up with the larger career.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The resident local rancher, Kelly Clarkson.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

After Stronger Kelly gave up, Christina had Feel this moment and Say something years after.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Kelly sweetie...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Legitimately can't understand how anyone is saying Xtina re: longevity :rip:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just now, feelslikeadream said:

Legitimately can't understand how anyone is saying Xtina re: longevity :rip:

Liberation at least got a few Grammy noms, not a total failure of an era. Kelly was getting noms while sort of failing commercially in the back half of the 10s as well… they’re kinda even but Xtina had an imperial 3-5 years before Kelly existed.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

9 minutes ago, collin said:

Liberation at least got a few Grammy noms, not a total failure of an era. Kelly was getting noms while sort of failing commercially in the back half of the 10s as well… they’re kinda even but Xtina had an imperial 3-5 years before Kelly existed.

Ok but even if we're talking about their most recent (English) studio albums:

 

Meaning of Life (2017)

#3 debut, 79,000

Certified Gold

Lead single peaked #47 on Hot 100

2 GRAMMY nominations (one for Pop Vocal Album)

 

Liberation (2018)

#8 debut, 68,000

Only charted on Billboard 200 for 2 weeks

Lead single didn't debut on Hot 100

2 GRAMMY nominations (both for individual songs)

 

I still don't see how Xtina is winning this one. In the ~5 years since those albums, Kelly's celebrity has grown even more (including racking up Emmys) while Xtina's hasn't. I'm not hating on X and I'm not saying Kelly is doing amazing with her music right now, I just don't understand how in 2022 anyone could see Xtina as thriving more than Kelly.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Y’all have literally done this thread four times in the last year jfc 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

39 minutes ago, feelslikeadream said:

Ok but even if we're talking about their most recent (English) studio albums:

 

Meaning of Life (2017)

#3 debut, 79,000

Certified Gold

Lead single peaked #47 on Hot 100

2 GRAMMY nominations (one for Pop Vocal Album)

 

Liberation (2018)

#8 debut, 68,000

Only charted on Billboard 200 for 2 weeks

Lead single didn't debut on Hot 100

2 GRAMMY nominations (both for individual songs)

 

I still don't see how Xtina is winning this one. In the ~5 years since those albums, Kelly's celebrity has grown even more (including racking up Emmys) while Xtina's hasn't. I'm not hating on X and I'm not saying Kelly is doing amazing with her music right now, I just don't understand how in 2022 anyone could see Xtina as thriving more than Kelly.

MOL actually peaked at #2. The last time Xtina had a top 2 album Bush was still president.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

53 minutes ago, feelslikeadream said:

Ok but even if we're talking about their most recent (English) studio albums:

 

Meaning of Life (2017)

#3 debut, 79,000

Certified Gold

Lead single peaked #47 on Hot 100

2 GRAMMY nominations (one for Pop Vocal Album)

 

Liberation (2018)

#8 debut, 68,000

Only charted on Billboard 200 for 2 weeks

Lead single didn't debut on Hot 100

2 GRAMMY nominations (both for individual songs)

 

You're forgetting the fact "Liberation" came out when Xtina was 20 years into her career after a 6 year break after a flop album

 

In contrast, "Meaning of Life" came out when Kelly was just 14 years into her career, and was a huge underperformance when compared to "Piece By Piece" released just two years prior. The singles also underperformed (Piece one top 10 and one top 25 single). And all the other singles from "Meaning of Life" failed to chart.

 

When everything is taken into account, Christina's "Liberation" did objectively better, even if it didn't produce any hits. 

 

Edited by NausAllien
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, tshwark said:

After Stronger Kelly gave up, Christina had Feel this moment and Say something years after.

This. Christina has the last real hit between the two of them, with Say Something coming 2 years after Stronger and she has 3 years of hits before Kelly even came out, so Christina wins this. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Kelly and it's not even close 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 Share

×
×
  • Create New...