Jump to content

Best and worst first Vogue covers by pop girls?


Recommended Posts

Posted

Which of these 19 female acts who at some point in time covered the American issue of Vogue do you think served the best debut cover? And who instead served the worst?

 

1989

 

01-madonna-birthday.jpg

 

1998

 

19980101.jpg

 

2001

 

img-tbtbritneyspearsherbrittsvoguejuly4_104148673885.jpg

 

2004

 

WD3_0ee2f7b9-42cb-4f86-8e7a-14203e7fd69f_1024x1024.jpg?v=1516874337

 

2005

 

1.jpg

 

2009

 

cc2405e35663a641b1f4fadbaec47666.jpg

 

2011

 

img-gagacover_084919706215.jpgcover-rihanna_171905334259.jpg

 

2012

 

taylor-swift-cover_110417507722.jpgadele-0312-1-Marchcover_20072229135.jpg

 

2013

 

katy-perry-cover-story-06_135650925749.jpg

 

2017

 

08-selena-gomez-vogue-april-2017.jpg

 

2019

 

VO0819_COVER_without_coverlines.jpg

 

2020

 

VO0120_Cover_Cardi.jpgVO0320_Cover_1.jpgVO1120_Cover_logoonly.jpg

 

2021

 

VO0121_Cover_Rosalia.jpgVO1021_Cover_logo.jpg

 

2022

 

VO0622_Cover_Logo.jpg

  • Replies 72
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • supertiffany

    3

  • Abracadabra

    2

  • #Beautiful

    2

  • Godly

    2

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted

Worst is Britney; it was also the lowest selling Vogue cover ever!

Posted
2 minutes ago, D.M.F said:

Worst is Britney; it was also the lowest selling Vogue cover ever!

At least she has one

Posted

lorde cardi and dua are awful 

 

what have they done to jlos face... ive never seen that one before

Posted

Best:

Gaga

Selena

 

Worst:

Ariana (the hat and the dog :deadbanana2:)

Cardi 

 

I don't mind Britney's, but it looks more like a People cover than Vogue

Posted (edited)

Best: Gaga, Rihanna, Katy, Lizzo, Lorde

 

Worst: Whoever the last photo is (is that Dua?) , Beyoncé (the photo is pretty but she has a gross green cast to her skin that wasn’t edited properly, looks bad) , Madonna (it doesn’t feel “Vogue” to me), Gwen (that pose looks really stiff) 

 

edit: that Ariana photo didn’t load for me, that one is also in the worst pile 

Edited by Somnambulist
Edit
Posted

Best: Gaga & Rih

Worst: Cardi which is unfortunate cause her editorial spreads are always a serve 

Posted

oh and whoever that is above lorde, someone give her a good shake and wake her up. she looks like they snatched her out of bed mid nap and took a picture of her as part of a high schoolers prank

Posted

I like Gwen and Rihanna’s, I actually really like Lorde’s too

 

Dua’s is horrible but Ariana’s is even worse, looks like an iPhone pic

Posted

Wow, seeing these now, a lot of them are actually not great, relative to how good we know they can look :rip: 

Posted

The way I was scrolling and the 2011 girls just popped out serving EDITORIAL :jonny5:

 

Worst is probably Katy or Cardi.

Posted

I'm shocked Xtina was never on the cover of Vogue (and now she probably never will...) :omg:

 

Best: Selena & Lorde

Worst: Jlo, Ariana, Cardi

Posted
1 minute ago, Bimbo said:

The way I was scrolling and the 2011 girls just popped out serving EDITORIAL :jonny5:

 

Worst is probably Katy or Cardi.

Worst for Katy!? She looks gorgeous and it’s very “Vogue” - I do agree the 2011 girls understood the assignment the most though. 

Posted

jlo, cardi and ariana's look awkward.

 

best are probably lorde, selena's and gaga's

Posted

Madonna looks stunning and is effortlessly beautiful. Just a simple glamour shot. Britain got this version which I think I might prefer. original

Posted

May 1989: Madonna became the first celebrity or non-model to be pictured on the cover of Vogue

 

History was made i'm afraid :jonny4:

Posted

selena for the best :WAP:

 

cardi or ariana for worst

Posted

Worst: Cardi and Dua

Best: everyone else

Posted

selena’s is by far the best. literally stunning :jonny5:

Posted

Best:

Britney - Patriotic Queen

Rihanna - Serving Mermaid and I'm here for it

Taylor - Candid from her garden

Adele - 60s glamor queen

Selena - ******* hot

Lorde - I like the flowers

 

Worst:

J Lo - Whose face did they edit on top of hers :deadbanana2:

Gaga - Someone please confiscate that cheap and dry pink pageboy wig and burn it ASAP

Katy - Idk, something about the exposed shoulder makes her neck look really long and it's disconcerting

Ariana - no comment :bibliahh:

Cardi - WHY DID THEY PICK THAT FACIAL EXPRESSION

Lizzo - Girl you aren't posing for prom pics 

Dua - Did she roll out of bed with a bad back for this pic? 

 

Posted

Why are they all so bad? :rip: 

 

Lorde’s is the best

Posted (edited)

I came here expecting the song :noparty:

 

 

Dua's looking like an IKEA ad :priceless:

Edited by ddddynamite
Posted

Rihanna's and Gwen's are easily the best. Most of the others are simply ugly or basic imo

Posted

img-gagacover_084919706215.jpg

 

The ABSOLUTE best one out of all in the op. One of her best covers, argue with a wall.

Posted

i love Adele and Billie's

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.