Jump to content

Wicked | Cynthia Erivo & Ariana Grande | Positive early reviews


Recommended Posts

Posted
2 hours ago, Lille said:

Musicals are already dying at the box office, this director's last musical was a massive bomb and this led them to think "We should do TWO"?

 

Another (two) flops in the basket.

mte :toofunny3:

we'll see though 

  • Replies 771
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • Aristocrat

    49

  • Jude

    35

  • Lovett

    30

  • Gerardo

    27

Posted
6 hours ago, Lost In Paradise said:

I just thought it was uneven. some amazing bright spots, and a lot of numbers and scenes that fell flat.

 

but I respect you as one of the only other theatre queens on this site so I'll give it a rewatch and hopefully I'll be more optimistic :chick1:

I think that's more of a problem with the musical itself, personally. I've always felt the musical was a bit uneven and was never a particularly big fan when I saw it on stage. However I thought the way it was adapted to film was just so beautiful and many of the musical numbers were just staged perfectly. I completely respect your opinion on it.

 

I'm intrigued to see what he does with the numbers in this though. God knows how they're going to stage "Defying Gravity". It works so well on stage, but could be laughable on film.

Posted

Two movies is definitely an interesting choice, but I think it gives them a lot of opportunity to take from the book series and also just their own interpretations and new, original content and music. I know Broadway stans want a copy and paste of the stage production, but clearly this isn't going to be that, otherwise, they easily could've done it in one 2 and a half hour+ movie. I think this is a combo of wanting to attempt to make it more of a cultural moment like Marvel or something, and also wanting more space to extend the story that they couldn't do with one movie. Universal clearly has a lot of faith in this movie to greenlight TWO movies, especially considering how some of their recent musical movies have gone. 

 

My only real complaint is the date... why 2024 for the first one? That's a little ridiculous. If they are still set to begin production in July, they would easily have the filming portion done by the end of 2022, I'd think? And that would give them almost a year of post production time. Christmas 2023 and Christmas 2024 would be a lot more exciting. The release dates just feel ridiculously far away to me. 

Posted

So... who do y'all want/think will be cast in the remaining roles?

 

My personal choices would be Hannah Waddingham from Ted Lasso and Game of Thrones as Madame Morrible. She has the look, the aura, and the vocal ability and theater past. And Jonathan Bailey from Bridgerton as Fiyero. I think Jordan Fisher could possibly get that role though, he seems to be a fan favorite choice. Hoping casting news is coming soon, seeing as rehearsals begin in less than 3 months. 

Posted (edited)
21 hours ago, MrLovett said:

I'm intrigued to see what he does with the numbers in this though. God knows how they're going to stage "Defying Gravity". It works so well on stage, but could be laughable on film.

The CGI of her flying away could be a kii.

Edited by Tusk
Posted

I'm sorry but both of this girlies aren't topping Kristen and Idina :rip:

Posted
1 hour ago, Aristocrat said:

Two movies is definitely an interesting choice, but I think it gives them a lot of opportunity to take from the book series 

the book is awful.

 

i'm surprised the writer of the musical was able to make something good out of it

Posted
3 hours ago, Bethenny Frankel said:

I'm sorry but both of this girlies aren't topping Kristen and Idina :rip:

Cynthia fully acts and sings Idina out of the water, so that's really not an issue. :rip:

Posted
On 4/26/2022 at 6:52 PM, Lost In Paradise said:

This is so dumb. why would anyone see Part 2? The best songs are all in Act 1.
 

The musical is 2 hours and 40 minutes and has some stuff they could’ve cut for the movie.

 

We didn’t ask for a Wicked extended universe. Just a ******* good Wicked movie.

especially when you consider that there are songs they can easily cut. everybody hates the Wizard’s songs and Something Bad

 

it makes absolutely no sense that they need two movies to tell this story

Posted

I agree it’s an interesting choice to split the movies in two, at the same time tho Act 2 has No Good Deed and For Good and if they can absolutely nail them then that’s enough of a draw to go see Part 2 tbh. 

Posted

Have they begun absolutely no work on this so far? That date for part 1 is pretty far out tbh...

Posted
11 hours ago, BNF91 said:

Have they begun absolutely no work on this so far? That date for part 1 is pretty far out tbh...

Nope. They're still in pre-production. Cyntha Erivo said rehearsals are supposed to being in July. 

Posted
15 hours ago, Aristocrat said:

Nope. They're still in pre-production. Cyntha Erivo said rehearsals are supposed to being in July. 

Oh wow okay. Thanks

  • 2 weeks later...
Posted

Cynthia said on Ellen that they still haven't even finished casting :rip: and she said something in another interview about how she has "plenty of time" to prepare for Elpbaba or something like that, so the 2024 date makes a lot more sense now. It seems like they're in no rush. Last we heard, rehearsals were set to begin in July, but that's approaching very quickly. If that's still even the plan, I predict they're going to give themselves a very long rehearsal period, seeing as they're now going to be basically filming two movies at once. I bet cameras won't even being rolling until September or October at this rate. And production will likely go into 2023.

  • 4 weeks later...
Posted

Collider wrote a little bit about the movie(s) and revealed the new movie logo at The Licensing Expo recently: 

Quote

The Licensing Expo, hosted at the Mandalay Center in Las Vegas, is the largest licensing expo in the world bringing the top brands together under one roof. This year the expo had a ton to offer with a bit of everything for everyone, no matter the fandom or interest. In all the excitement, Collider's own Steven Weintraub captured a few photos of what's in store for franchises like Godzilla, Wicked, and DC.

licensing-expo-image-(31).JPG?q=50&fit=c

With only a black backdrop and a solitary 'W' outlined in Elphaba-green, the upcoming two-parter Wicked films were teased to the fans at Licensing Expo. Though not much of the cast has been announced yet, director John Chu's (Crazy Rich Asians) adaptation of Broadway's enormously successful play is already getting buzz in its pre-production phase. With stars Cynthia Erivo playing the infamous Wicked Witch of the West, Elphaba and Grammy-winner Ariana Grande playing her opposite, Galinda, fans can't wait to see their favorite Broadway numbers brought to the big screen. In order to keep as much of Gregory Maguire's novel details and Broadway's iconic duets such as "For Good" and "Defying Gravity" in the films, Chu has opted to split the story into two feature-length films. Both are said to be released on Christmas day of 2024 and 2025. The film is set to begin production in June.

 

Posted

I'm thinking this could do well during Awards season if the movie was excellent. The play did well with Tony Awards.

Roman Holiday
Posted
4 minutes ago, Donquizote said:

I'm thinking this could do well during Awards season if the movie was excellent. The play did well with Tony Awards.

Maybe, but it’ll be competing with The Color Purple

Posted (edited)
3 minutes ago, Roman Holiday said:

Maybe, but it’ll be competing with The Color Purple

People will be hyped for The Color Purple, but I'm expecting disappointment especially when comparison with the original one is made...

Edit: never mind. These two movies will be released on separate years.

Edited by Donquizote
edit
Posted (edited)
23 minutes ago, Donquizote said:

I'm thinking this could do well during Awards season if the movie was excellent. The play did well with Tony Awards.

not super well.

it lost musical, and book, and score. was ignored for directing. the two leads were the only acting nominees. 

it's considered more populist than awards bait. 

 

compare to, say, two musicals that competed against each other:

phantom of the opera - musical winner, direction winner amongst 7 wins

into the woods - book winner, score winner

and neither did great with the oscars.

 

or rent which won musical/book/score. 

or producers which won TWELVE tonys.

Edited by fridayteenage
Posted
22 minutes ago, Donquizote said:

I'm thinking this could do well during Awards season if the movie was excellent. The play did well with Tony Awards.

It didn't.

 

It lost Best Musical, Book, AND Original Score.

Posted
4 minutes ago, fridayteenage said:

not super well.

it lost musical, and book, and score. was ignored for directing. the two leads were the only acting nominees. 

it's considered more populist than awards bait. 

 

compare to, say, two musicals that competed against each other:

phantom of the opera - musical winner, direction winner amongst 7 wins

into the woods - book winner, score winner

and neither did great with the oscars.

 

3 minutes ago, Tusk said:

It didn't.

 

It lost Best Musical, Book, AND Original Score.

I mean the nominations :cm: A lot of surprises happen at Academy nominations lately especially when they get rid of old members from the body. I'm expecting this could surprise at the Oscar

Posted

TXMmBES.jpg

oB1kOBl.jpg

Since we're likely going to get more casting new soon (I hope) since production is just a few weeks away, I thought I'd share my fan casting for a few more of the major roles.

 

Madame Morrible- I think Hannah Waddingham would be quite literally the perfect choice. She has the stature, build, and look to pull off such a regal and villainous character. She also has lots of experience in the musical theater world and has an incredible voice. She's also fresh off wins at the Emmys, Screen Actors Guild, and Critics Choice Awards wins for her role in Ted Lasso. 

 

Fiyero- Jonathan Bailey, fresh off of huge success leading Bridgerton season two would be great for the overly confident and hot male lead. He's conventionally handsome, is a great actor, and like Hannah, he also has experience on stage and in the musical theater world, and has a wonderful voice. Age wise, he's in between Ariana and Cynthia, so it could work.

 

Dr Dillamond- Woody Harrelson 

 

The Wizard- Forest Whitaker

 

I left Boq and Nessarose off because I feel like they should be newcomers/unknown talents. 

Posted

Somebody on Reddit is claiming (in posts from 20 days ago) that Charlie Puth and Andre De Shields have booked the roles of Fiyero and The Wizard.

 

Interestingly enough, just a few days ago, it was announced that Cynthia will be doing an event with Andre De Shields tomorrow, ahead of the Tonys.

Posted
On 6/10/2022 at 10:54 PM, Aristocrat said:

Somebody on Reddit is claiming (in posts from 20 days ago) that Charlie Puth and Andre De Shields have booked the roles of Fiyero and The Wizard.

 

Interestingly enough, just a few days ago, it was announced that Cynthia will be doing an event with Andre De Shields tomorrow, ahead of the Tonys.

I don’t have anything against Charlie but more than one pop star in this is going to make it look super gimmicky, would much rather have another Broadway seasoned singer as Fiyero.

Posted

Charlie Puth? :deadvision:  

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.