Rino Posted April 21, 2022 Posted April 21, 2022 So I've noticed quite a handful of users here on ATRL claiming they used to be Lady Gaga fans but stopped being one for some reason. Surprisingly these people appear to be some of her most vocal haters on the website not missing their chance to drag their past fave at every opportunity. Why do you think these ex-Gaga fans are so full of hate towards her these days? What happened to these people?
BGXKB Posted April 21, 2022 Posted April 21, 2022 (edited) We know best what’s wrong with her and the fanbase because we were on the inside when it all fell. Edited April 21, 2022 by BGXKB
Mariano Posted April 21, 2022 Posted April 21, 2022 (edited) One of the d#mbest and most inaccurate things ever said on this website. The most prominant example of this is the Jj user and he was never a liddo, he was always a madonna stan first and foremost, who had just bandwagoned Gaga for a year (I mean.. who didn't stan Gaga in 2009-2010?) until she became too powerful and important and a threat. Stop saying that, it's literally not true Edited April 21, 2022 by Mariano
Mr. Stratus Posted April 21, 2022 Posted April 21, 2022 (edited) 14 minutes ago, Hurem said: They’re mad she dropped dArK-pOp i dont believe this is the reason nor do i believe all haters are ex stans. i think its all katy/madonna/britney loyalists. there is no such thing as a taylor or rihanna OGH. Anyways... She would have xtina impact/streams had she continued to do what they wanted. she solidified her base and did the artistry thing whilst still having GP from Alejandro. ARTPOP could've got GP back, but it further isolated them more. She lost them forever in a way at that album. She HAD to do acting/jazz/ballads to stay relevant and expose talent, and it was the best thing for her. Note that she has no dance/edm song aside from ROM after her debut era over 400m on Spotifty, she has very little tiktok boosts. it aged and is only used by gays. New Gaga with acting and ballads is the tea! Edited April 21, 2022 by Mr. Stratus
BGXKB Posted April 21, 2022 Posted April 21, 2022 (edited) LMs are always running around stamping out fires it honestly just gets tiring after a while. I suspect most of her fans these days are actually new ones. No one would stick around through four nuclear wars. Edited April 21, 2022 by BGXKB
Rino Posted April 21, 2022 Author Posted April 21, 2022 13 minutes ago, Mariano said: One of the d#mbest and most inaccurate things ever said on this website. The most prominant example of this is the Jj user and he was never a liddo, he was always a madonna stan first and foremost, who had just bandwagoned Gaga for a year (I mean.. who didn't stan Gaga in 2009-2010?) until she became too powerful and important and a threat. Stop saying that, it's literally not true but it literally is? I saw a couple of usernames here from GGD who were perched over there for years but now are hating on her here like it's their full time job
jordanjm Posted April 21, 2022 Posted April 21, 2022 I’ll be the first to admit that this fan base draws a lot of people with mental illness. The kindness queen is so accepting, they just flock to her. Once they grow tied of her, or the fan base, for really any number of reasons they become obsessive. Almost like a dog with a bone. They can’t stop talking or thinking about her, and how she took so much of their lives. They also seem to distort reality in weird ways. Like for example, suggesting she has no long time fans due to the climate online when most people who are well wouldn’t even notice what they are talking about. It’s quite sad and I hope they receive the help they need. Many of us monsters are pretty successful, maybe we can start an online therapy fund for them?
Mariano Posted April 21, 2022 Posted April 21, 2022 Just now, Rino said: but it literally is? I saw a couple of usernames here from GGD who were perched over there for years but now are hating on her here like it's their full time job You mean 3 people, one of which was always a Madonna stan first and foremost? Okay sis, that definitely required a thread
Mariano Posted April 21, 2022 Posted April 21, 2022 Just now, jordanjm said: I’ll be the first to admit that this fan base draws a lot of people with mental illness. You mean ATRL and the stan world in general.
Rino Posted April 21, 2022 Author Posted April 21, 2022 Just now, Mariano said: You mean 3 people, one of which was always a Madonna stan first and foremost? Okay sis, that definitely required a thread I don't mean the Masonna stan, I don't remember ever seeing that person on GGD I can PM their usernames if you want
halcyonday Posted April 21, 2022 Posted April 21, 2022 She's a musical disappointment. Imagine growing up with TFM and BTW and then witnessing her embarrassing meltdowns during the artpop era, forcing yourself to like either outdated-on-arrival EDM or boring jazz and country songs. Sometimes enough is enough. Especially considering a fanbase so mental like LM. I was one of them. I know the tea sweetie.
Rino Posted April 21, 2022 Author Posted April 21, 2022 (edited) 3 minutes ago, halcyonday said: She's a musical disappointment. Imagine growing up with TFM and BTW and then witnessing her embarrassing meltdowns during the artpop era, forcing yourself to like either outdated-on-arrival EDM or boring jazz and country songs. Sometimes enough is enough. Especially considering a fanbase so mental like LM. I was one of them. I know the tea sweetie. albums come and go, but talent is forever! that's my personal stance on being a Gaga stan but you do you sweetie Edited April 21, 2022 by Rino
Rino Posted April 21, 2022 Author Posted April 21, 2022 10 minutes ago, jordanjm said: I’ll be the first to admit that this fan base draws a lot of people with mental illness. The kindness queen is so accepting, they just flock to her. Once they grow tied of her, or the fan base, for really any number of reasons they become obsessive. Almost like a dog with a bone. They can’t stop talking or thinking about her, and how she took so much of their lives. They also seem to distort reality in weird ways. Like for example, suggesting she has no long time fans due to the climate online when most people who are well wouldn’t even notice what they are talking about. It’s quite sad and I hope they receive the help they need. Many of us monsters are pretty successful, maybe we can start an online therapy fund for them? a lot of what you wrote makes sense, thanks but no I'm no charity, start a therapy fund for these individuals without me
Mariano Posted April 21, 2022 Posted April 21, 2022 (edited) 12 minutes ago, halcyonday said: She's a musical disappointment. Imagine growing up with TFM and BTW and then witnessing her embarrassing meltdowns during the artpop era, forcing yourself to like either outdated-on-arrival EDM or boring jazz and country songs. Sometimes enough is enough. Especially considering a fanbase so mental like LM. I was one of them. I know the tea sweetie. That makes 0 sense and here's why: Lady Gaga still has one of the biggest fanbases by a pop girl. In comparison - there are certain other artists that completely LOST their entire fanbase. I am pretty sure what you're saying will apply much more to these artists that went from having one of the biggest fanbases to now having 10 users that are all perched in Lady Gaga threads. It was a good attempt though sis, but you forgot the fact that Lady Gaga is currently selling out stadiums globally and that her lowest first week sales are on par with most other pop girls biggest first week sales - which means her fanbase is still quite intact hihi You gave me a really good drag for your fav though and I can actually use and apply it and it would make a lot of sense Don't worry though, I don't run around desperately trying to drag your fav down! Edited April 21, 2022 by Mariano
Achilles. Posted April 21, 2022 Posted April 21, 2022 Can’t cope with the fact that a former fave failed to live up to their expectations either artistically or commercially, depending on the person.
halcyonday Posted April 21, 2022 Posted April 21, 2022 3 minutes ago, Mariano said: That makes 0 sense and here's why: Lady Gaga still has one of the biggest fanbases by a pop girl. In comparison - there are certain other artists that completely LOST their entire fanbase. I am pretty sure what you're saying will apply much more to these artists that went from having one of the biggest fanbases to now having 10 users that are all perched in Lady Gaga threads. It was a good attempt though sis, but you forgot the fact that Lady Gaga is currently selling out stadiums globally and that her lowest first week sales are on par with most other pop girls biggest first week sales - which means her fanbase is still quite intact hihi You gave me a really good drag for your fav though and I can actually use and apply it and it would make a lot of sense You're just proving her stans are closer to the ones of BTS than normal and healthy fanbases
Bang Up Posted April 21, 2022 Posted April 21, 2022 They're misogynists who are mad that Lady Gaga dared to defy them and stopped catering to them. Literally. They're mad they can't control her or that she isn't controlled by her label or manager. These Monsters will drag Katy Perry and Rihanna for being "industry puppets" and then cry that Gaga's label won't control her. They're hypocrites and idiots who make no sense. Most of them are also stuck in the past because their current lives are so miserable that if they live in 2022 they won't be happy. They have to constantly try and relive the past in order to be happy. Lady Gaga is arguably one of the most successful and famous entertainers on the planet and they're still not happy because she's not doing things the way they want her to do them. The career Gaga has had post-ARTPOP has been phenomenal and has set her up to be a successful entertainer for the rest of her life, yet that's not good enough because she doesn't make "dark pop" or collab with random artists who are blowing up on TikTok. It just doesn't make sense.
Rino Posted April 21, 2022 Author Posted April 21, 2022 2 minutes ago, Achilles. said: Can’t cope with the fact that a former fave failed to live up to their expectations either artistically or commercially, depending on the person. but how would that lead to obsessive hatred? I don't get it
BGXKB Posted April 21, 2022 Posted April 21, 2022 20 minutes ago, jordanjm said: I’ll be the first to admit that this fan base draws a lot of people with mental illness. The kindness queen is so accepting, they just flock to her. Once they grow tied of her, or the fan base, for really any number of reasons they become obsessive. Almost like a dog with a bone. They can’t stop talking or thinking about her, and how she took so much of their lives. They also seem to distort reality in weird ways. Like for example, suggesting she has no long time fans due to the climate online when most people who are well wouldn’t even notice what they are talking about. It’s quite sad and I hope they receive the help they need. Many of us monsters are pretty successful, maybe we can start an online therapy fund for them? Making these kind of sick jokes is exactly what I was talking about. Don’t reply to me without actually replying to me.
jordanjm Posted April 21, 2022 Posted April 21, 2022 7 minutes ago, Rino said: a lot of what you wrote makes sense, thanks but no I'm no charity, start a therapy fund for these individuals without me so clearly I was referencing one of the posts above mine but when I clicked on the notifications when I got responses to this comment, I saw their picture. They sent me a dm yesterday warning me to delete a comment in an anti Gaga thread that mods were cracking down on yesterday. Like there is some weird solidarity between the OGH. People on here are so weird these days, like it’s much much worse than the 2010-2014 stan wars and less entertaining.
jordanjm Posted April 21, 2022 Posted April 21, 2022 Just now, BGXKB said: Making these kind of sick jokes is exactly what I was talking about. Don’t reply to me without actually replying to me. The fact that you keep returning to this thread really proves my point. It’s sad.
Recommended Posts