Jump to content

Vanishing Letters 9 | WINNER REVEALED (p.187)| #WinterComing


Recommended Posts

Posted

oh wow coming for safe/high 

  • Replies 4.7k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • ughgabriel

    409

  • Kavish

    322

  • Dessy

    288

  • Overprotected

    269

Posted

Im coming for BOTTOM/OUT

 

How many people will be eliminated?

Posted

Maybe dweebz will debut his award winning vocaroo CRITICAL CRITIQUES.

Spoiler

so the judge's can deem him valuable for ratings and save him

 

Posted
24 minutes ago, dweebz said:

Im coming for BOTTOM/OUT

 

How many people will be eliminated?

2 from each group for a total of 4! :gaynetcat3:

Posted
Just now, Overprotected said:

2 from each group for a total of 4! :gaynetcat3:

Let me make my exit

TngLb3G.gif

 

Posted
2 minutes ago, dweebz said:

Let me make my exit

TngLb3G.gif

 

8ae538a4c73895fa3e0e6607f7a498b1.gif

Posted

minho also serving taste, we stan!

Posted

Black Dresses - Peacesign!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

:tsk:

 

Charlie Puth - The Way I Am

His voice SUCKS, but the song is cute

 

Doja Cat - Cyber Sex

It's okay, kinda fun

 

Doja Cat - Woman

Not a fan of the chorus

 

Erika de Casier - Drama

Cute. Bit of a snooze though

 

L Devine - Priorities

The production is cool but the song isn't really clicking with me. Might be a grower

 

Madonna - Survival

Not one of my favorite Madonna songs but it's a nice jam

 

Mitski - Happy

A lot better than I remember it being. One of her few listenable songs

 

Pat Benatar - Heartbreaker

I prefer her other classics but this is still a cute bop

 

Rihanna - Phresh Out the Runway

I always liked this. A messy bop

 

Rihanna - SOS

Yuppp a classic. I still use this

 

Sade - Smooth Operator

It's no No Ordinary Love but it's cute

 

Sara Bareilles - Brave

Ehmmm this is really annoying, I'm gonna pass

 

Shakira - She Wolf

Yuppp another classic. I prefer the Spanish version though

 

St. Vincent - Pay Your Way in Pain

Just horrible :rip: One of the worst songs of the year

 

SZA - Supermodel

It's not horrible or anything, but it's not my cup of tea

 

TeaMarrr - Chasing Amy

Just a really ugly song. Didn't enjoy this at all

 

Wolf Alice - The Beach

Doesn't do anything for me

 

Zara Larsson - Love Me Land

I like the production but I always found her vocals really annoying here

Posted (edited)

LcZ6mIR.png 

 

 

~ Group 1 ~

 

Spoiler

Apink - Dumhdurum

Not us kicking off with this bop. The instrumentation is kind of/very annoying in that admittedly very catchy refrain, but somehow it mostly gets away with it.

 

BANKS - Gemini Feed

You knew you snatched a classic.

 

Bjork - Army of Me

Kind of legendary.. yeh..

 

BLACKPINK - How You Like That

Brash but in the absolute best way. They rightly get clocked as unnecessarily noisy sometimes, but it just works here.

 

Celine Dion - It's All Coming Back To Me Now

Did somebody say emotional rollercoaster? ? Honestly this song is one of the finest examples of a magnus opus. A feature length drama encapsulated in an 8 minute song. The use of instrumentation, tempo and dynamic variation is on another level... The piano is consistently gorgeous and the outpouring of emotion she conveys in this song is pretty much unparalleled. She really takes us on a journey.

 

Charli XCX - Vroom Vroom

Omg... let me ascend. It's been a while!

 

Doja Cat - Go To Town

It's alright, definitely an interesting song. It could struggle given the high quality of this group so far.

 

Hole - Celebrity Skin

Hmmm. I kinda like this!

 

Jessie Ware - Spotlight

11/10.

 

Kari Faux - MEDICATED

Cute.

 

Kelela - A Message

Yeh... this is dark and sultry electric gorgeousness, everything I want + crave + expect from a Kelela song.

 

Kesha - Your Love Is My Drug

I mean it's tacky. Can't say I hugely enjoyed sitting through this. I wish you an ounce of luck.

 

Liz Phair - 6'1''

This was a risk. It didn't hugely pay off me for me but I respect the song.

 

Lorde - Tennis Court

I'm surprised this isn't banned honestly. Great song and most definitely an ATRL crowd pleaser.

 

P!nk - Stupid Girls

Pass.

 

Rita Ora - Anywhere

Super solid pop song.

 

Sam Smith - Young

This is short but somehow dragged anyway. It very much feels like an intro that could've been 90 seconds long. A bit eye roll for me also. They definitely think they're sooo deep ? It's a hard pass for me.

 

The Knife - Heartbeats

Interesting choice. I dig it. It got better and better. I feel like I recognise this but I'm not sure where from. Super interesting production.

 

TWICE - I Can't Stop Me

Bop.

 

WILLOW - t r a n s p a r e n t s o u l

Wasn't sure about this one a few months ago and I'm afraid to report that it hasn't grown on me.

 

~ Group 2 ~

 

Spoiler

Blackdresses - PEACESIGN!!!!!!!

Certainly interesting!

 

Charlie Puth - The Way I Am

Certainly better than I expected! But like actually! I like it.

 

Doja Cat - Cyber Sex

Certainly amazing!

 

Woman - Doja Cat

Middle of the pack in this group, or even low. Like it's decent and has some cute quirks but overall it's nothing special. She's not giving what she thought she was (kind of describes the entire album..)

 

Erika de Casier - Drama

Lovely.

 

L Devine - Prioritiess

Oh wow this kind of HITS in a slap to the face kind of way?! Let me put a goddamn mark to this one.

 

Madonna - Survival

It's nice. The production elements come together very nicely. It's never been something I was obsessed with, though.

 

Mitski - Happy

Okay miss thing. Serve me chaotic-jazz-grunge queen.

 

Pat Benatar - Heartbreaker

It goes off a bit.

 

Rihanna - Phresh Out The Runway

Always thought this was garbage. On my reworked Unapologetic this is NOT included. Literally why is she talking gibberish through half the song? Why is it so obnoxiously noisy and not necessarily in an interesting way? Having said that... maybe I'm bopping... idk...

 

Rihanna - SOS

oprah-surprise.gif

Let me watch the video right now for the nostalgia!

 

Sade - Smooth Operator

Hmmmmmm. It's a big, big classic... yeh.

 

Sara Bareilles - Brave

It's a bit lame and corny.

 

Shakira - She Wolf

I know I'm in the minority but this never did it for me and it still doesn't now.

 

St. Vincent - Pay Your Way In Pain

It got kinda fashionable to like this since it's original dire reception, huh? Anyways it's good, actually it's very good, yeh it's definitely not immediate but there's something uniquely groovey and attractively jarring about this. I dig it a lot.

 

SZA - Supermodel
This choice was incredibly predictable nn. It's solid! Love the album!

 

TeaMarr - Chasing Amy

It's nice.. A little unfortunate that this song got put right after SZA since when in direct comparison, her style kinda feels like an inferior knock off.

 

Wolf Alice - The Beach

Literally gorgeous..

 

Zara Larsson - Love Me Land

Ughhh this is kinda experimental pop perfection huh? I wanna ****ing hear this in a club right now.

 

~ Faglist ~

 

Edited by Fruity
Posted

VL8 winner fruity also serving taste, we stan!

Posted

loved this critique :clap3:

Posted

Judges serving taste but why does everyone hate Brave?

Posted

Winner for a reason

 

Fruity

Posted
8 hours ago, clue said:

DOJA CAT is our first banned artist for the rest of the season

 

Do not attempt to send her as a lead artist at any point, thank you!

Why?

Posted
8 hours ago, clue said:

Everyone: discuss your song, too! But ofc don't reveal which song is yours

How do u discuss ur song without revealing it haha

Posted

After an artist is used 3 times they're "banned" to give the game another element of difficulty and more variety

Posted

so true bestie

 

ezgif-6-01b720b92366.thumb.gif.f78c907ec

Posted
8 hours ago, Hikari said:

Jessie Ware - Spotlight


Legendary song from a legendary album x

The way I wanted to send this but it was already taken :deadbanana4:

Posted
2 minutes ago, Insanity said:

How do u discuss ur song without revealing it haha

you can say 'my song is being panned, my song is being acclaimed, my song is getting mixed reviews' - that is a way to discuss your song but not blatantly reveal your song. 

Posted

I think Clue just meant to give your song a critique (as you would the rest of them), just don’t make it obvious it’s yours… 

Posted
1 minute ago, mokitsu said:

I think Clue just meant to give your song a critique (as you would the rest of them), just don’t make it obvious it’s yours… 

This! @Insanity

Posted

realistically very few people will go hunting through your reviews to see if they can determine what you sent, especially this early in the game jfjlf. just say "I like this" rather than "Best song ever, you snapped by sending this bestie" or w/e

Posted
10 minutes ago, Insanity said:

How do u discuss ur song without revealing it haha

Basically say it's good (or bad) and don't say it's yours

Posted
2 hours ago, Jai said:

I only know 15% of whats going on in this game BUT just know that I will make it to round 2 when the competition really starts. 

Oh period

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.