Jump to content

Bigger hitmaker: Miley Cyrus vs Selena Gomez


biblicalmonster

Vote  

210 members have voted

  1. 1. Who's the bigger hitmaker?



Recommended Posts

biblicalmonster
2 minutes ago, MonsterNavy said:

Miley - disney days to 2013

Selena - 2013 - 2021

 

:tongue: 

 

both legends though

With The Scene, Selena's had "Love You Like A Love Song" which was a hit and "Naturally" + "Who Says" are mini hits as well, they did some stats.

 

The first two are 4X platinum in the US. 

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • Replies 267
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • Virtual_Insanity

    27

  • AccioMiley

    22

  • My Tears Ricochet

    19

  • biblicalmonster

    19

Selegend
Posted (edited)

for exemple only the fact that Malibu is listed on the first post already makes clear how Selena has way more hits than miley

 

back to you is bigger than malibu and no one would list it as one of selenas biggests hit since the catalogue COMPETITION is here. 
And even when we’re talking about solo songs. 

Edited by Selegend
Link to post
Share on other sites
MonsterNavy
14 minutes ago, biblicalmonster said:

With The Scene, Selena's had "Love You Like A Love Song" which was a hit and "Naturally" + "Who Says" are mini hits as well, they did some stats.

 

The first two are 4X platinum in the US. 

True but I just wanna give credits to miley too.

 

From 2013 - now selena owns it so I gave miley the disney days even though selena had huge hits back then too

Link to post
Share on other sites
alfonso12

Not Selena's biggest hits being collabs. :rip: 

 

Party in the USA and Wrecking ball are bigger than Selena's singles from her albums so I'll go with Miley.

Link to post
Share on other sites
MonsterNavy
Just now, alfonso12 said:

Not Selena's biggest hits being collabs. :rip: 

 

Party in the USA and Wrecking ball are bigger than Selena's singles from her albums so I'll go with Miley.

Lets not act as if ms gomez doesnt have huge solo hits

 

- Love You Like a Love Song

- Who Says

- Naturally

- The Heart Wants What It Wants

- Come & Get It

- Same Old Love

- Hands to Myself

- Lose You to Love Me

- Back to You

 

It Aint Me & Wolves are also just her singing alone but okay i'll give yall that

 

:tongue: 

Link to post
Share on other sites
alfonso12
1 minute ago, MonsterNavy said:

Lets not act as if ms gomez doesnt have huge solo hits

 

- Love You Like a Love Song

- Who Says

- Naturally

- The Heart Wants What It Wants

- Come & Get It

- Same Old Love

- Hands to Myself

- Lose You to Love Me

- Back to You

 

It Aint Me & Wolves are also just her singing alone but okay i'll give yall that

 

:tongue: 

Can we really call all of those hits though? like, Who Says, for example, failed to go top 10 in any market, failed to go top 40 in big markets such as the UK, Australia, Germany, France and more. The heart wants what it wants and Same old love were local af, etc.

Link to post
Share on other sites
MonsterNavy
Posted (edited)
3 minutes ago, alfonso12 said:

Can we really call all of those hits though? like, Who Says, for example, failed to go top 10 in any market, failed to go top 40 in big markets such as the UK, Australia, Germany, France and more. The heart wants what it wants and Same old love were local af, etc.

If they're not hits then what do we call them? More than half of those are top 10 hits, multiplatinum records that sold a lot and are extremely recognizable by the public. Not to mention their youtube and especially spotify streams are huge :tongue: 

 

selena's huge hits doesnt have to hit #1 or top 10 to be called hits. It Aint Me, Wolves, Back to You etc never hit top 10 but has billion streams on spotify alone :tongue: 

Edited by MonsterNavy
Link to post
Share on other sites
selena_lavigne
Posted (edited)

2008-2014 - Miley

 

2014-present - Selena

 

overall i think Selena has caught up with Miley since Back To You/Taki Taki in 2018.

Edited by selena_lavigne
Link to post
Share on other sites
My Tears Ricochet

Selena literally stomps on Miley when it comes to hits:deadbanana2:

Naturally 

A year without rain

Who says

Love u like a love song

The heart want what it wants

Come & get it

Slow down

Good for you

Hands to myself 

Kill'em with kindness 

Same old love

We don't talk anymore 

It ain't me

Wolves

Taki Taki

Back to you 

Lose you to love me

Baila Conmigo

 

A year without rain, fetish, round and round, hit the lights, Look at her now, I want u to know, Ican't get enough & Ice cream were cute hits too.

 

Miley has like 6 hits and that's it:deadbanana2:

 

Link to post
Share on other sites
Popboi.

Miley overall, Selena’s hits before Revival were extremely local, even more than Miley’s earlier singles. Since 2015 it’s been Selena.

Link to post
Share on other sites
My Tears Ricochet
15 minutes ago, alfonso12 said:

Can we really call all of those hits though? like, Who Says, for example, failed to go top 10 in any market, failed to go top 40 in big markets such as the UK, Australia, Germany, France and more. The heart wants what it wants and Same old love were local af, etc.

You guys calls Million reasons a hit despite bombing everywhere except US.

Who says in 3x platinum in US, the same certification as Million reasons 

Link to post
Share on other sites
SelenaGomez<3

SELENA and you all know it :gaycat5:

Link to post
Share on other sites
monster_enriquer
Posted (edited)
19 minutes ago, My Tears Ricochet said:

You guys calls Million reasons a hit despite bombing everywhere except US.

Who says in 3x platinum in US, the same certification as Million reasons 

MR 
Certifications
[edit]

 
Region Certification Certified units/sales
Australia (ARIA)[128] Platinum 70,000double-dagger
Brazil (Pro-Música Brasil)[129] Gold 20,000double-dagger
Canada (Music Canada)[130] Gold 40,000double-dagger
Denmark (IFPI Denmark)[131] Gold 45,000double-dagger
France (SNEP)[132] Gold 66,666double-dagger
Italy (FIMI)[133] 3× Platinum 150,000double-dagger
Norway (IFPI Norway)[134] Platinum 60,000double-dagger
Poland (ZPAV)[135] 2× Platinum 40,000double-dagger
United Kingdom (BPI)[136] Gold 400,000double-dagger
United States (RIAA)[42] 3× Platinum 1,100,000[43]

 

V/S

 

 

WHO SAYS

Certifications[edit]

 
Region Certification Certified units/sales
Australia (ARIA)[44] Platinum 70,000^
Norway (IFPI Norway)[45] Platinum 10,000*
United States (RIAA)[46] 3× Platinum 3,000,000^

 

 

- who says charted in 11 countries ( MR charted in 20+ countries)

- MR is actually 4x platinum eligible in the US source

-MR collected more(higher) certifications thanks to it's recurrent streams 


they are NOT in the same league :cm:

 

Edited by monster_enriquer
Link to post
Share on other sites
Selegend
25 minutes ago, My Tears Ricochet said:

Selena literally stomps on Miley when it comes to hits:deadbanana2:

Naturally 

A year without rain

Who says

Love u like a love song

The heart want what it wants

Come & get it

Slow down

Good for you

Hands to myself 

Kill'em with kindness 

Same old love

We don't talk anymore 

It ain't me

Wolves

Taki Taki

Back to you 

Lose you to love me

Baila Conmigo

 

A year without rain, fetish, round and round, hit the lights, Look at her now, I want u to know, Ican't get enough & Ice cream were cute hits too.

 

Miley has like 6 hits and that's it:deadbanana2:

 

Even Bad liar was a cute hit 

She literally has way more 

Link to post
Share on other sites
Champagne
1 hour ago, Alaska. said:

I absolutely forgot Selena was in that Charlie Puth song :deadbanana4:

 

I'd say Miley. Selena has some hits but I feel like they will be less remembered as time goes by.

Right? Didn't Selena and Charlie play up that they might have been dating around the time of release to gain more buzz? :rip: That is clearly Selena's go-to promo tactic for most releases. 

 

OT: Miley by far, remembered solo pop classics. 

Link to post
Share on other sites
biblicalmonster
Posted (edited)
20 minutes ago, monster_enriquer said:

MR 
Certifications
[edit]

 
Region Certification Certified units/sales
Australia (ARIA)[128] Platinum 70,000double-dagger
Brazil (Pro-Música Brasil)[129] Gold 20,000double-dagger
Canada (Music Canada)[130] Gold 40,000double-dagger
Denmark (IFPI Denmark)[131] Gold 45,000double-dagger
France (SNEP)[132] Gold 66,666double-dagger
Italy (FIMI)[133] 3× Platinum 150,000double-dagger
Norway (IFPI Norway)[134] Platinum 60,000double-dagger
Poland (ZPAV)[135] 2× Platinum 40,000double-dagger
United Kingdom (BPI)[136] Gold 400,000double-dagger
United States (RIAA)[42] 3× Platinum 1,100,000[43]

 

V/S

 

 

WHO SAYS

Certifications[edit]

 
Region Certification Certified units/sales
Australia (ARIA)[44] Platinum 70,000^
Norway (IFPI Norway)[45] Platinum 10,000*
United States (RIAA)[46] 3× Platinum 3,000,000^

 

 

- who says charted in 11 countries ( MR charted in 20+ countries)

- MR is actually 4x platinum eligible in the US source

-MR collected more(higher) certifications thanks to it's recurrent streams 


they are NOT in the same league :cm:

 

Yes and MR sold the same units as "Same Old Love" and "Hands To Myself", which were quite big hits from Revival. That says a lot about MR. 

Edited by biblicalmonster
Link to post
Share on other sites
My Tears Ricochet
6 minutes ago, monster_enriquer said:

MR 
Certifications
[edit]

 
Region Certification Certified units/sales
Australia (ARIA)[128] Platinum 70,000double-dagger
Brazil (Pro-Música Brasil)[129] Gold 20,000double-dagger
Canada (Music Canada)[130] Gold 40,000double-dagger
Denmark (IFPI Denmark)[131] Gold 45,000double-dagger
France (SNEP)[132] Gold 66,666double-dagger
Italy (FIMI)[133] 3× Platinum 150,000double-dagger
Norway (IFPI Norway)[134] Platinum 60,000double-dagger
Poland (ZPAV)[135] 2× Platinum 40,000double-dagger
United Kingdom (BPI)[136] Gold 400,000double-dagger
United States (RIAA)[42] 3× Platinum 1,100,000[43]

 

V/S

 

 

WHO SAYS

Certifications[edit]

 
Region Certification Certified units/sales
Australia (ARIA)[44] Platinum 70,000^
Norway (IFPI Norway)[45] Platinum 10,000*
United States (RIAA)[46] 3× Platinum 3,000,000^

 

 

- who says charted in 11 countries ( MR charted in 20+ countries)

- MR is actually 4x platinum eligible in the US source

-MR collected more(higher) certifications thanks to it's recurrent streams 


they are NOT in the same league :cm:

 

 

Who says was last certified (3x platinum) in 2013:deadbanana2:  It is atleast 4-5M platinum eligible by now

 

And who cares about all those gold certifications of Million reasons and charting at the bottom of the charts in irrelevant European counties.

 

Both Million reasons & Who says were local hits. If MR is a hit, then so is Who says

Link to post
Share on other sites
monster_enriquer

Selena has more no of hits than Miley. Miley has like what? 6 hits :rip:
Selena is the more consistent hit maker overall . Selena is in a more comfortable position from a commercial aspect and that says a LOT.

Link to post
Share on other sites
Billionaire
Posted (edited)

Let's compare SOLO song certifications.

 

Miley:

Wrecking Ball:

 
Region Certification Certified units/sales
Australia (ARIA)[165] 6× Platinum 420,000double-dagger
Austria (IFPI Austria)[166] Gold 15,000*
Belgium (BEA)[30] Gold 15,000*
Canada (Music Canada)[25] 4× Platinum 320,000*
Denmark (IFPI Denmark)[167] Gold 15,000^
Denmark (IFPI Denmark)[168] Platinum 1,800,000dagger
Germany (BVMI)[31] Platinum 300,000^
Italy (FIMI)[32] 2× Platinum 60,000*
Mexico (AMPROFON)[169] Platinum+Gold 90,000*
New Zealand (RMNZ)[170] Platinum 15,000*
Netherlands (NVPI)[171] Platinum 20,000^
Norway (IFPI Norway)[172] 5× Platinum 300,000double-dagger
Portugal (AFP)[173] Gold 10,000double-dagger
Spain (PROMUSICAE)[174] Gold 20,000^
Sweden (GLF)[175] 3× Platinum 120,000double-dagger
Switzerland (IFPI Switzerland)[176] Platinum 30,000^
United Kingdom (BPI)[28] Platinum 600,000double-dagger
United States (RIAA)[177] 5× Platinum 5,000,000double-dagger

 

We Can't Stop:

Region Certification Certified units/sales
Australia (ARIA)[41] 5× Platinum 350,000double-dagger
Austria (IFPI Austria)[148] Gold 15,000*
Canada (Music Canada)[33] 4× Platinum 320,000*
Denmark (IFPI Denmark)[149]
Streaming
Platinum 1,800,000dagger
Germany (BVMI)[150] Gold 150,000^
Italy (FIMI)[151] Platinum 50,000double-dagger
Mexico (AMPROFON)[152] Platinum 60,000*
New Zealand (RMNZ)[42] Platinum 15,000*
Norway (IFPI Norway)[153] 7× Platinum 420,000double-dagger
Sweden (GLF)[154] Platinum 40,000double-dagger
Switzerland (IFPI Switzerland)[155] Gold 15,000^
United Kingdom (BPI)[156] Platinum 600,000double-dagger
United States (RIAA)[157] 5× Platinum 5,000,000double-dagger

 

Party In The USA:

 
Region Certification Certified units/sales
Australia (ARIA)[132] 8× Platinum 560,000double-dagger
Canada (Music Canada)[133] 4× Platinum 160,000*
Denmark (IFPI Denmark)[134] Platinum 90,000double-dagger
Italy (FIMI)[135] Gold 25,000double-dagger
Japan (RIAJ)[136] Platinum 250,000^
New Zealand (RMNZ)[137] Platinum 15,000*
Norway (IFPI Norway)[138] 3× Platinum 180,000double-dagger
United Kingdom (BPI)[139] Platinum 600,000double-dagger
United States (RIAA)[140] Diamond

10,000,000double-dagger

 

 

Malibu: 

Region Certification Certified units/sales
Australia (ARIA)[118] 3× Platinum 210,000double-dagger
Austria (IFPI Austria)[119] Platinum 30,000double-dagger
Belgium (BEA)[120] Gold 15,000*
Canada (Music Canada)[121] 3× Platinum 240,000double-dagger
Denmark (IFPI Denmark)[122] Platinum 90,000double-dagger
Germany (BVMI)[123] Gold 200,000double-dagger
Italy (FIMI)[124] Platinum 50,000double-dagger
Mexico (AMPROFON)[125] 2× Platinum 120,000double-dagger
New Zealand (RMNZ)[126] Gold 15,000double-dagger
Norway (IFPI Norway)[127] Platinum 60,000double-dagger
Poland (ZPAV)[128] Platinum 20,000double-dagger
Portugal (AFP)[129] Gold 5,000double-dagger
Sweden (GLF)[130] Gold 20,000double-dagger
Switzerland (IFPI Switzerland)[131] Platinum 20,000double-dagger
United Kingdom (BPI)[132] Platinum 600,000double-dagger
United States (RIAA)[133] 2× Platinum 2,000,000double-dagger

 

 

 

Selena:

Same Old Love

 
Region Certification Certified units/sales
Brazil (Pro-Música Brasil)[128] 2× Platinum 120,000double-dagger
Canada (Music Canada)[53] 2× Platinum 160,000*
Denmark (IFPI Denmark)[129] Platinum 60,000^
Germany (BVMI)[130] Gold 200,000double-dagger
Italy (FIMI)[131] Platinum 50,000double-dagger
New Zealand (RMNZ)[132] Gold 7,500*
Norway (IFPI Norway)[133] Gold 30,000double-dagger
Poland (ZPAV)[134] 2× Platinum 40,000double-dagger
Sweden (GLF)[135] Platinum 40,000double-dagger
United Kingdom (BPI)[136] Silver 200,000double-dagger
United States (RIAA)[138] 3× Platinum

3,000,000[137]

 

Hands To Myself:

 
Region Certification Certified units/sales
Australia (ARIA)[121] 2× Platinum 140,000double-dagger
Canada (Music Canada)[122] Platinum 80,000*
Denmark (IFPI Denmark)[123] Platinum 90,000double-dagger
Italy (FIMI)[124] Platinum 50,000double-dagger
New Zealand (RMNZ)[125] Platinum 15,000*
Norway (IFPI Norway)[126] Gold 30,000double-dagger
Sweden (GLF)[127] 2× Platinum 80,000double-dagger
United Kingdom (BPI)[128] Platinum 600,000double-dagger
United States (RIAA)[130] 2× Platinum 2,000,000[129]

 

Back To You:

Region Certification Certified units/sales
Australia (ARIA)[85] 2× Platinum 140,000double-dagger
Belgium (BEA)[86] Gold 20,000double-dagger
Brazil (Pro-Música Brasil)[87] Platinum 40,000double-dagger
Denmark (IFPI Denmark)[88] Platinum 90,000double-dagger
Germany (BVMI)[89] Gold 200,000double-dagger
Italy (FIMI)[90] Gold 25,000double-dagger
Mexico (AMPROFON)[91] Platinum 60,000double-dagger
New Zealand (RMNZ)[92] Gold 15,000double-dagger
Norway (IFPI Norway)[93] 2× Platinum 120,000double-dagger
Poland (ZPAV)[94] 3× Platinum 60,000double-dagger
Portugal (AFP)[95] Gold 5,000double-dagger
Sweden (GLF)[96] Platinum 8,000,000dagger
United Kingdom (BPI)[97] Platinum 600,000double-dagger
United States (RIAA)[98] 2× Platinum

2,000,000double-dagger

 

 

LYTLM:

 
Region Certification Certified units/sales
Australia (ARIA)[96] 2× Platinum 140,000double-dagger
Austria (IFPI Austria)[97] Gold 15,000double-dagger
Belgium (BEA)[98] Gold 20,000double-dagger
Canada (Music Canada)[99] 2× Platinum 160,000double-dagger
Denmark (IFPI Denmark)[100] Gold 45,000double-dagger
France (SNEP)[101] Gold 100,000double-dagger
Italy (FIMI)[102] Gold 35,000double-dagger
New Zealand (RMNZ)[103] Gold 15,000double-dagger
Norway (IFPI Norway)[104] Platinum 60,000double-dagger
Poland (ZPAV)[105] Platinum 20,000double-dagger
Portugal (AFP)[106] Platinum 10,000double-dagger
Spain (PROMUSICAE)[107] Gold 20,000double-dagger
United Kingdom (BPI)[108] Platinum 600,000double-dagger
United States (RIAA)[109] 2× Platinum 2,000,000double-dagger

 

 

Take them as you will. :cm:

Edited by Billionaire
Link to post
Share on other sites
MonsterNavy

The "solo" hits comments :deadbanana2:

they're all selena songs like it or not :tongue: 

Link to post
Share on other sites
Sharapov

people thinking it aint me isnt solo because kygo produced it? are you ****ing stupid? :rip:

Link to post
Share on other sites
Ivan_brit

Miley hits are more organic & iconic

 

Selena trying with everything Pop, EDM, Latin, KPop etc.  A million droplets :deadbanana2:

Link to post
Share on other sites
Billionaire

Anyway Miley has the bigger hits, while Selena is more consistent. Really depends on what you think is more important. 

Link to post
Share on other sites
Selena’s Bad Liar
7 minutes ago, MonsterNavy said:

The "solo" hits comments :deadbanana2:

they're all selena songs like it or not :tongue: 

Maybe their favs should pick better collaborators :deadbanana2:

 

tsJGaepxAuo1d9aeAJLaYIi68Jcxlt6nbeeGDbS2

Link to post
Share on other sites
×
×
  • Create New...