Jump to content

Which of these Pop Girls Has the Biggest Lead for 6th album?


Bigger Hit  

293 members have voted

  1. 1. bigger hit?

    • Womanizer (Released by Britney Spears in 2008)
      124
    • Formation (Released by Beyoncé in 2016)
      30
    • Look What You Made Me Do (Released by Taylor Swift in 2017)
      72
    • Stupid Love (Released by Lady Gaga in 2020)
      9
    • Positions (Released by Ariana Grande in 2020)
      49


Recommended Posts

  • Replies 118
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • Soobin

    7

  • cancer

    7

  • Ghiles

    5

  • abrahamjmr

    4

2 hours ago, abrahamjmr said:

Not Mujerizador. :rip:

 

Stop acting like you would be any different when you finally hit 40! 

We're not even 30 years old (some of us), yet you're acting almighty here because you're 14. :skull:

Oh and we love Taylor.

I would hope that by the time I turn 22, I won't have to embarrass myself by engaging in stan wars on some gutter forum.. let alone 40.

 

OT: Look was the only true event among these singles.

Link to post
Share on other sites
9 hours ago, Soobin said:

Look, I've never heard Womanizer in my life

That is no one’s fault, but your own :cm:

 

OT: Womanizer > Positions > Formation > Look > Stupid Love 

Link to post
Share on other sites
abrahamjmr
1 minute ago, Soobin said:

I would hope that by the time I turn 22, I won't have to embarrass myself by engaging in stan wars on some gutter forum.. let alone 40.

 

OT: Look was the only true event among these singles.

Most people say that yet you see them fighting in here. What makes you think you would be any different? :fan:

Link to post
Share on other sites
scenekiller
17 hours ago, cancer said:

Darn! I forgot to include the lead single off of Xtina's 6th album, accelerate. I'm sure it would have swept. 

 

:bibliahh:

Link to post
Share on other sites
2 minutes ago, Soobin said:

 

OT: Look was the only true event among these singles.

Womanizer and Formation were definitely events. :rip: You obviously were too young to experience the Womanizer era, but to pretend like Formation (a 4 year old song) wasn’t an event is just....:toofunny2: perhaps, you’d benefit from studying some music history instead of discrediting the older generation of pop stars just to make your younger current fave look better. 

Link to post
Share on other sites
2 minutes ago, crf13 said:

Womanizer and Formation were definitely events. :rip: You obviously were too young to experience the Womanizer era, but to pretend like Formation (a 4 year old song) wasn’t an event is just....:toofunny2: perhaps, you’d benefit from studying some music history instead of discrediting the older generation of pop stars just to make your younger current fave look better. 

The Womanizer plug.. :rip: Formation might have been an event but it did not make a dent on the charts, even after its digital release. None of these songs can be put on the same pedestal as the gargantuan Look, the first taste of the era following up 1989.

 

What we're not gonna do is discredit an artist from a younger generation who has surpassed her older peers. Taylor has made history with her insurmountable longevity. She broke out in the 2000s as the biggest country artist, crowned herself as the queen of pop in the 2010s and entered the 2020s as an alternative folk legend. Taylor is a once in a lifetime phenomenon.

Link to post
Share on other sites
Chainsmoker

Womanizer 

Positions

 

Look What You Made Me Do

Formation

 

 

 

Stupid Love

Link to post
Share on other sites

Anyways Womanizer

was pretty huge for the time, wasn't it one of the most viewed YT videos at one point?
also top 10 best sold singles of the year I think?

Truly a big comeback single (also one of her most recurrent streamed singles on Spotify)

 

LWYMMD is next

the hype here was also huge (it was either her last of her biggest hype for a mv/song tbh)

even I stayed up to see it

the discussions and theories and looking for easter eggs afterwards :dies:

some ppl say it was her last real hit

 

Formation was another event

but when it dropped. everyone was on it

the only downside was that it was local

but was still a Moment

 

positions next imo

it will surpass F for sure

it also had a big wait for it

but was kind of underwhelming

Still proved itself to be a bop and according to lots of non-fans, one of the saving graces of its album

 

Stupid Love also was being highly anticipated (at least by her fanbase, and a lot of the others were curious on what she will deliver after ASIB)

it was even more underwhelming compared to positions

I feel like even LMs didnt defend it

think it was one of the quickest falls frm top10

Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, Soobin said:

The Womanizer plug.. :rip: Formation might have been an event but it did not make a dent on the charts, even after its digital release. None of these songs can be put on the same pedestal as the gargantuan Look, the first taste of the era following up 1989.

 

What we're not gonna do is discredit an artist from a younger generation who has surpassed her older peers. Taylor has made history with her insurmountable longevity. She broke out in the 2000s as the biggest country artist, crowned herself as the queen of pop in the 2010s and entered the 2020s as an alternative folk legend. Taylor is a once in a lifetime phenomenon.

It's not a random plug :skull: Womanizer was part of Britney's comeback which was a huge event in 2008. The entire world literally watched Britney comeback during this time. Everyone knows Womanizer. It's literally Britney's 2nd or 3rd biggest solo hit...

Link to post
Share on other sites
abrahamjmr
56 minutes ago, cancer said:

It's not a random plug :skull: Womanizer was part of Britney's comeback which was a huge event in 2008. The entire world literally watched Britney comeback during this time. Everyone knows Womanizer. It's literally Britney's 2nd or 3rd biggest solo hit...

He's 14 years old. I was his age when Britney made her huge comeback in 2008, so don't blame him. :fan:

He was just 2 when it happened, he wouldn't remember even if he wanted to.

Link to post
Share on other sites
57 minutes ago, cancer said:

It's not a random plug :skull: Womanizer was part of Britney's comeback which was a huge event in 2008. The entire world literally watched Britney comeback during this time. Everyone knows Womanizer. It's literally Britney's 2nd or 3rd biggest solo hit...

Dude I can't imagine a world where people were perched for a Britney comeback. :rip: It's just not realistic to me. :chick2:

Link to post
Share on other sites
7 minutes ago, Soobin said:

Dude I can't imagine a world where people were perched for a Britney comeback. :rip: It's just not realistic to me. :chick2:

Well it definitely happened. The Britney today is not the same Britney from 1998-2010. Don't let that confuse you.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Let's stick to charts and facts instead of personal attacks.

 

France

Womanizer:04-01-01-01-01-01-04-06-06-06-07-09-13-16-19-21-25-31-34-36-38-42-41-44-46-44-43-38-43-51-48-67-72-73-71-71-66-78-92-OUT

LWYMMD: 26-26-48-61-87-105-99-102-123-140-167-OUT

Positions: 20-21-24-33-35-50-51-50-100-

 

Belgium (Wallonia)

Womanizer: 29-21-16-17-05-04-03-02-02-02-03-02-03-03-03-05-08-10-12-14-21-25-//-40-40-OUT

Look: 47-39-43-47-45-49-//-49-OUT

Positions: 39-26-14-11-10-11-07-13-10-

 

Belgium (Flanders)

Womanizer: 33-28-18-11-03-02-02-02-01-03-02-02-02-04-08-13-22-23-29-34-OUT

Look: 18-08-19-19-23-24-26-28-39-OUT

Positions: 26-17-20-17-14-19-21-25-26-

 

Switzerland

Womanizer: 02-02-03-04-08-10-12-11-15-15-19-22-28-36-43-54-55-60-64-76-62-82-93-82-80-//-94-//-86-OUT

Look: 06-09-13-14-20-25-31-34-48-57-66-65-87-OUT

Positions: 05-08-07-08-10-19-28-39-49

 

Spain

Womanizer: 17-12-13-10-08-09-19-13-13-15-16-26-32-27-29-42-43-48-48-OUT

Look: 17-12-15-18-26-31-35-38-41-51-70-OUT

Positions: 23-33-51-55-55-85-89-93-

 

Portugal

Womanizer: 29-21-13-09-08-10-09-06-12-10-08-08-10-10-21-34-46-OUT

Look: 41-08-06-17-12-13-20-26-31-33-OUT

Positions: 04-04-04-07-07-07-10-10-

 

Germany

Womanizer: 04-09-07-12-20-20-13-15-19-27-31-34-37-41-51-54-OUT

Look: 04-03-05-06-11-16-20-27-33-36-51-55-66-OUT

Positions: 09-12-17-15-22-44-49-66-

 

Austria

Womanizer: 05-10-04-04-06-07-11-10-15-16-16-24-25-24-42-41-32-43-50-72-71-OUT

Look: 02-02-05-05-09-13-17-18-20-30-45-48-66-OUT

Positions: 07-10-13-11-14-36-47-52-

 

Denmark

Womanizer: 06-05-02-01-02-04-04-05-02-03-05-05-08-10-13-17-20-23-33-35-40-OUT

Look: 12-17-25-35-40-OUT

Positions: 11-08-09-04-09-OUT

 

Sweden

Womanizer: 01-03-04-06-10-13-06-10-10-11-07-13-11-14-10-24-23-31-34-44-OUT

Look: 09-07-12-15-26-31-40-42-48-72-OUT

Positions: 10-14-17-18-22-55-67-81-

 

Finland

Womanizer: 07-07-12-10-13-04-02-01-04-05-06-05-10-10-13-//-15-OUT

Look: 08-08-09-15-OUT

Positions: 07-07-17-20-17-20-OUT

 

Norway

Womanizer: 04-01-01-02-02-09-06-08-14-12-14-16-15-12-13-18-OUT

Look: 07-06-10-15-19-29-38-OUT

Positions: 07-08-10-10-13-31-OUT

 

Italy

Womanizer: 10-07-11-13-10-09-09-08-12-16-12-13-OUT (the chart was a Top 20 only)

Look: 10-12-11-12-19-25-33-38-43-OUT

Positions: 18-38-63-51-57-63-96-85-

 

Canada

Womanizer: 97-43-01-01-01-01-01-02-04-04-05-04-06-03-04-09-12-16-18-22-30-34-42-43-47-49-OUT

LWYMMD: 01-01-01-02-03-06-07-13-21-24-23-32-41-50-53-54-65-57-47-62-OUT

Positions: 01-02-02-03-05-04-06-09-19-

 

USA

Womanizer: 96-01-04-05-06-07-07-12-09-10-06-05-07-08-09-12-15-18-25-28-32-40-45-OUT

LWYMMD: 77-01-01-01-03-03-05-04-10-25-34-37-31-44-60-72-70-76-66-55-OUT

Positions: 01-02-02-03-04-03-04-08-14

 

UK

Womanizer: 04-08-09-07-03-04-10-11-09-17-22-27-33-38-42-63-66-86-87-83-71-93-77-80-91-99-OUT

LWYMMD: 01-01-03-04-09-12-14-20-24-51-OUT-78-OUT-79-OUT

Positions: 01-01-01-01-01-01-03-04-19

 

Ireland

Womanizer: 02-10-13-04-04-03-07-04-09-15-15-21-23-30-34-37-44-OUT

Look: 01-02-03-04-10-17-17-20-30-35-47-57-70-78-57-84-//-90-OUT

Positions: 01-01-01-02-02-03-04-08-09-

 

Australia

Womanizer: 16-07-07-05-06-07-07-08-09-09-12-11-16-20-25-30-38-OUT

LWYMMD: 01-01-02-03-09-14-19-22-26-32-42-43-49-60-OUT

Positions: 01-01-02-02-02-02-02-06-09-

 

Womanizer charted better and longer than LWYMMD everywhere.

 

Positions is doing better than Womanizer in a select few countries but it's bombing really bad in several of them whereas that didn't happen to Womanizer anywhere.

 

Voujkhs.gif

Edited by Ghiles
Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, Soobin said:

Dude I can't imagine a world where people were perched for a Britney comeback. :rip: It's just not realistic to me. :chick2:

Considering she had the most infamous and public celebrity breakdown ever just months prior, that's like the least surprising thing ever lol

 

Obviously people were curious to see how things would pan out after that chaotic period in her life.

 

Her triple win at the 2008 VMAs (they were still huge then), the MTV documentary which broke rating records and the news of her being naked in the video generated tons of anticipation and headlines.

 

I was 10 y.o. but I still remember all of it. Womanizer aired non-stop on French music channels like M6 and NRJ. The song was #1 for 4 weeks and stayed top 10 in digital sales for 19 weeks straight.

 

The video was one of the most viewed on Youtube before it was deleted at 80M when VEVO channels were introduced and BritneyTV was one of the biggest Youtube channels at the time

 

http://web.archive.org/web/20090428180526/http://www.youtube.com/members?t=a&p=1&s=mv&g=5

http://web.archive.org/web/20090609115000/http://www.youtube.com/user/BritneyTV

 

Voujkhs.gif

Link to post
Share on other sites
5 hours ago, Soobin said:

The Womanizer plug.. :rip: Formation might have been an event but it did not make a dent on the charts, even after its digital release. None of these songs can be put on the same pedestal as the gargantuan Look, the first taste of the era following up 1989.

 

What we're not gonna do is discredit an artist from a younger generation who has surpassed her older peers. Taylor has made history with her insurmountable longevity. She broke out in the 2000s as the biggest country artist, crowned herself as the queen of pop in the 2010s and entered the 2020s as an alternative folk legend. Taylor is a once in a lifetime phenomenon.

 

1 hour ago, Ghiles said:

Let's stick to charts and facts instead of personal attacks.

 

France

Womanizer:04-01-01-01-01-01-04-06-06-06-07-09-13-16-19-21-25-31-34-36-38-42-41-44-46-44-43-38-43-51-48-67-72-73-71-71-66-78-92-OUT

LWYMMD: 26-26-48-61-87-105-99-102-123-140-167-OUT

Positions: 20-21-24-33-35-50-51-50-100-

 

Belgium (Wallonia)

Womanizer: 29-21-16-17-05-04-03-02-02-02-03-02-03-03-03-05-08-10-12-14-21-25-//-40-40-OUT

Look: 47-39-43-47-45-49-//-49-OUT

Positions: 39-26-14-11-10-11-07-13-10-

 

Belgium (Flanders)

Womanizer: 33-28-18-11-03-02-02-02-01-03-02-02-02-04-08-13-22-23-29-34-OUT

Look: 18-08-19-19-23-24-26-28-39-OUT

Positions: 26-17-20-17-14-19-21-25-26-

 

Switzerland

Womanizer: 02-02-03-04-08-10-12-11-15-15-19-22-28-36-43-54-55-60-64-76-62-82-93-82-80-//-94-//-86-OUT

Look: 06-09-13-14-20-25-31-34-48-57-66-65-87-OUT

Positions: 05-08-07-08-10-19-28-39-49

 

Spain

Womanizer: 17-12-13-10-08-09-19-13-13-15-16-26-32-27-29-42-43-48-48-OUT

Look: 17-12-15-18-26-31-35-38-41-51-70-OUT

Positions: 23-33-51-55-55-85-89-93-

 

Portugal

Womanizer: 29-21-13-09-08-10-09-06-12-10-08-08-10-10-21-34-46-OUT

Look: 41-08-06-17-12-13-20-26-31-33-OUT

Positions: 04-04-04-07-07-07-10-10-

 

Germany

Womanizer: 04-09-07-12-20-20-13-15-19-27-31-34-37-41-51-54-OUT

Look: 04-03-05-06-11-16-20-27-33-36-51-55-66-OUT

Positions: 09-12-17-15-22-44-49-66-

 

Austria

Womanizer: 05-10-04-04-06-07-11-10-15-16-16-24-25-24-42-41-32-43-50-72-71-OUT

Look: 02-02-05-05-09-13-17-18-20-30-45-48-66-OUT

Positions: 07-10-13-11-14-36-47-52-

 

Denmark

Womanizer: 06-05-02-01-02-04-04-05-02-03-05-05-08-10-13-17-20-23-33-35-40-OUT

Look: 12-17-25-35-40-OUT

Positions: 11-08-09-04-09-OUT

 

Sweden

Womanizer: 01-03-04-06-10-13-06-10-10-11-07-13-11-14-10-24-23-31-34-44-OUT

Look: 09-07-12-15-26-31-40-42-48-72-OUT

Positions: 10-14-17-18-22-55-67-81-

 

Finland

Womanizer: 07-07-12-10-13-04-02-01-04-05-06-05-10-10-13-//-15-OUT

Look: 08-08-09-15-OUT

Positions: 07-07-17-20-17-20-OUT

 

Norway

Womanizer: 04-01-01-02-02-09-06-08-14-12-14-16-15-12-13-18-OUT

Look: 07-06-10-15-19-29-38-OUT

Positions: 07-08-10-10-13-31-OUT

 

Italy

Womanizer: 10-07-11-13-10-09-09-08-12-16-12-13-OUT (the chart was a Top 20 only)

Look: 10-12-11-12-19-25-33-38-43-OUT

Positions: 18-38-63-51-57-63-96-85-

 

Canada

Womanizer: 97-43-01-01-01-01-01-02-04-04-05-04-06-03-04-09-12-16-18-22-30-34-42-43-47-49-OUT

LWYMMD: 01-01-01-02-03-06-07-13-21-24-23-32-41-50-53-54-65-57-47-62-OUT

Positions: 01-02-02-03-05-04-06-09-19-

 

USA

Womanizer: 96-01-04-05-06-07-07-12-09-10-06-05-07-08-09-12-15-18-25-28-32-40-45-OUT

LWYMMD: 77-01-01-01-03-03-05-04-10-25-34-37-31-44-60-72-70-76-66-55-OUT

Positions: 01-02-02-03-04-03-04-08-14

 

UK

Womanizer: 04-08-09-07-03-04-10-11-09-17-22-27-33-38-42-63-66-86-87-83-71-93-77-80-91-99-OUT

LWYMMD: 01-01-03-04-09-12-14-20-24-51-OUT-78-OUT-79-OUT

Positions: 01-01-01-01-01-01-03-04-19

 

Ireland

Womanizer: 02-10-13-04-04-03-07-04-09-15-15-21-23-30-34-37-44-OUT

Look: 01-02-03-04-10-17-17-20-30-35-47-57-70-78-57-84-//-90-OUT

Positions: 01-01-01-02-02-03-04-08-09-

 

Australia

Womanizer: 16-07-07-05-06-07-07-08-09-09-12-11-16-20-25-30-38-OUT

LWYMMD: 01-01-02-03-09-14-19-22-26-32-42-43-49-60-OUT

Positions: 01-01-02-02-02-02-02-06-09-

 

Womanizer charted better and longer than LWYMMD everywhere.

 

Positions is doing better than Womanizer in a select few countries but it's bombing really bad in several of them whereas that didn't happen to Womanizer anywhere.

 

Voujkhs.gif

:bibliahh:

Yall really be entertaining that young Swiftie? :toofunny3:

Obviously either talking out of his ass cuz he has nothing to say, or just trolling.

Leave it alone Ma!

Link to post
Share on other sites
mintpasty
16 hours ago, Soobin said:

Look, I've never heard Womanizer in my life

How old are you :rip:

OT: Womanizer by FAR.

 

Womanizer >>>>>>>>> positions > LWYMMD > Formation >>>>>>>> Stupid Love

Link to post
Share on other sites

Just based on impact only? LWYMMD and Womanizer by far. However, positions has displayed longevity, so it deserves to be included. :clap3:

Link to post
Share on other sites

The charts can't fool anybody cause Look's first week alone eats up the whole Circus Clown era.

Link to post
Share on other sites
Erreur2 La Nature
15 hours ago, Soobin said:

The Womanizer plug.. :rip: Formation might have been an event but it did not make a dent on the charts, even after its digital release. None of these songs can be put on the same pedestal as the gargantuan Look, the first taste of the era following up 1989.

 

What we're not gonna do is discredit an artist from a younger generation who has surpassed her older peers. Taylor has made history with her insurmountable longevity. She broke out in the 2000s as the biggest country artist, crowned herself as the queen of pop in the 2010s and entered the 2020s as an alternative folk legend. Taylor is a once in a lifetime phenomenon.

You have to stop trolling all the time. 

Link to post
Share on other sites
Miichael
On 1/8/2021 at 3:11 AM, D.M.F said:

LWYMMD >>> Formation >>> Positions >>> Stupid Love >>> Womanizer (this song was frontloaded and is forgotten)

:rip: 

Link to post
Share on other sites
×
×
  • Create New...