Jump to content

Madonna Discography Rate (WINNER ANNOUNCED)


madonnas

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 11.9k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • madonnas

    1371

  • Oktober Knight

    667

  • Everest

    533

  • Poxy

    463

I’m scared sh!tless but I just got to a save point on Final Fantasy X so good timing 

Edited by Doogle
Link to post
Share on other sites
1 minute ago, Doogle said:

I’m scared sh!tless but I just got to a save point on Final Fantasy X so good timing 

WHAT PART ARE YOU AT

Link to post
Share on other sites
4 hours ago, Madame X said:

  

36.  Rain

 

74c616ac024500307a5400c6ac37b628.jpg

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

"When you looked into my eyes
And you said goodbye could you see my tears?"

 

 

Average: 8.218

 

Little Lolas:

11: Taemira, bestfiction, T.O.A.D.S., LikeaRebel, 1989, Wildcat, Lithium.

10.5: Moln, Twopac, pisuke

10s: Venus Temple, jdmc219, Invisibility, John Slayne Tremor Christ, Ghost, tiagol88, Alongoria13, Kid A, Dabunique, paulyyyozd, StrangerInTheDark, jacklovesyou1, Poxy, Brando, UnanimousBB16, creativity., TipToe, OktoberKnight, Tusk, noonbob, allforyou, SupremeGoddess, Agenor, GreatestLoveOfAll, DatChickDoe, xxfreshkidx

 

Little Ritchies:

1s: tellem

0.5s: rlj

0s: PopThatCorn, HonourableVomit

 

Kinda hollering at the little hate-club Rain has.  I never knew a song like this could summon so much hatred!  Um, I like it.  I think its at a fairplacement right now though.  It's the climax of the album though and much more sunny and light than the rest of the dark, tortured sound of Erotica.  I guess that's why it sumons so many strong emotions. 

 

 

Comments from the Peanut Gallery

Moln: Her best ballad to date IMHO. The key changes, the spoken part, the gorgeous video, I'm FLOORED. A golden shower anthem if you want! Versatile queen
dabunique: great song, great video, she looked so good with short black hair
Alongoria13: The combo of the synths and the spoken bridge…
T.O.A.D.S.: Heavenly, life changing, euphoric etc. One of her best songs ever
UnanimousBB16: (Everything about this song is so serene, though it’s arguably the most simple lyrically and conceptually. Madonna uses her lower register more in the song, and she’s very optimistic about being in love, though I’ve heard some people make this song dirtier than it really is. Listening to the song feels so fresh due to the new-age and trip hop elements, making it sound less dated than everything else on the album. Madonna isn’t ish for never performing this outside of the Girlie Show tour)
Gateau: its just... missing something
Lithium.: did we, as humans, do enough good to deserve this?
HonourableVomit:  She should've called this Pain. 
GreatestLoveOfAll: . My personal fave off the album.
jdmc219: (Pretty much the ultimate standout of the album.)
PopThatCorn: This song is so basic and bland. One of her worst ballads.

this is so wrong

her best song

the best ballad of all time

the greatest overproduced song of all time

i cant

you bitches are so annoying

Link to post
Share on other sites
Lithium.

There's no way HOLIDAY is winning. we don't live in a Utopia

tumblr_omvz49ocir1rzlfxxo2_250.gif

Link to post
Share on other sites
madonnas

  

30.  Die Another Day

 

06bee4469e1f45eb06f7cb12dee1fefc.jpg

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

"Sigmund Freud
Analyze this"

 

 

Average: 8.325

 

Little Lolas:

11: BlueTimberwolf, Brando, 1989

10.5: Pisuke, Wildcat

10s: V3$$3L, Invisibility, John Slayne, Staryu, Tremor Christ, Auburn, tiagol88, dabunique, Sunset, That Bad Eartha, paulyyyozd, StrangerInTheDark, Gabriel Florin, T.O.A.D.S., Never Ending, LikeaRebel, creativity.,, Gateau, Rev8, OktoberKnight, Psycho, noonbob, Everest, xxfreshkidx, Zayka

 

Little Ritchies:

1s: GreatestLoveOfAll

0.5s: n/a

0s: n/a

 

Honestly?  I know there's a sect of people who despise this song and I just don't understand why?  It's fun, it's a bop, it's something out of the ordinary for pop at the time, it's literally the saving grace of that rotten album, which, BY THE WAY, IS OUT, AND YES, IS BEATEN BY HARD CANDY.

 

 

Comments from the Peanut Gallery

Auburn:  ahhhhhh **** it’s so good
Poxy: . I see so much love for this track, and it’s okay, but I am just waiting for the day it “clicks” a little bit more… 
Moln: This song glued in American Life certainly elevated the album a bit (and has almost nothing to do with the rest of it lmao)
Alongoria13: Probably Madonna's most bizarre top 10? (sound wise, we all know the most bizarre one is GMAYL)
T.O.A.D.S.: One of the best things she’s ever created. My booty pops just thinking about it. 
creativity: when those strings come in… and then the synth comes in… orgasm
UnanimousBB16: (A part of the song is pretty cringe to me, especially with how she executes the lyrics, but I like the concept of fighting to live longer, and the beat is somewhat catchy. Overall, a mixed bag)
Gateau: the LAYERS. the DYANMIC
Rev8:  (another underrated track on this album :jonny:  dont understand why the song is so hated)

Link to post
Share on other sites

still mad about earlier’s results but here

 

Madonna-red-carpet-LA.jpg

Link to post
Share on other sites
1 minute ago, Madame X said:

WHAT PART ARE YOU AT

can’t believe I’m hiding video game spoilers in the Madonna discography rate thread but here we go

 

Spoiler

I’m quite near the beginning  :jonny: I just got off the boat in that new little island with Yuna right near the start after we left Besaid on the boat and Sin destroyed it, La Isla Bonita is shaking

C’mon let’s knock out that Hard Candy song :duca: 

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • #FreeBritney Activist
BlackoutZone

Finally bitch, Take A Bow deserved to make top 30 instead :weeps: 

Link to post
Share on other sites

um finally 

 

5ef92d43421f8e8c.png

Link to post
Share on other sites

I mean this had no business being the top song on AL when the best ones got pinched but I would’ve liked it in the top 25 anyway :weeps:  RIP to a misunderstood album 

Link to post
Share on other sites
paulyyyozd

all the little freuds should be banned immediately

 

jfprwr8.thumb.gif.f95f97b2a61e7ebae77858 

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • #FreeBritney Activist
BlackoutZone

WAIT AMERICAN LIFE IS FULLY OUT :bibliahh: :clap3:

Link to post
Share on other sites
madonnas
Just now, BlackoutZone said:

WAIT AMERICAN LIFE IS FULLY OUT :bibliahh: :clap3:

HARD CANDY BEAT AMERICAN LIFE PARTY

jfprwr8.thumb.gif.f95f97b2a61e7ebae77858

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • #FreeBritney Activist
BlackoutZone
Just now, Madame X said:

HARD CANDY BEAT AMERICAN LIFE PARTY

jfprwr8.thumb.gif.f95f97b2a61e7ebae77858

No American Atrocity in top 20

The WINNING

jfprwr8.thumb.gif.f95f97b2a61e7ebae77858

 

Hard Candy >> AL, we did that RIGHT

Link to post
Share on other sites

Miles Slayway is indeed better than AL in full -- A FACT :clap3:

 

5ef92d43421f8e8c.png

Link to post
Share on other sites
1 minute ago, PiecesOfYou said:

I didn’t expect Hard Candy to beat AL tbh 

 

5ef92d43421f8e8c.png

 

1 minute ago, Madame X said:

HARD CANDY BEAT AMERICAN LIFE PARTY

jfprwr8.thumb.gif.f95f97b2a61e7ebae77858

wait

 

CANCEL THIS RATE

 

jfprwr8.thumb.gif.f95f97b2a61e7ebae77858

Link to post
Share on other sites
×
×
  • Create New...