Jump to content

Madonna Discography Rate (Top 90!)


Madame X

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 8.3k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • Madame X

    1079

  • Oktober Knight

    519

  • Everest

    364

  • Nemo

    338

  • #FreeBritney Activist

This is better than any song on

Music

American Life

Hard Candy

MDNA
Rebel Heart

Madame X

 

y'all ****

giphy.gifgiphy.gifgiphy.gif

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Next Best Thing should have left 160 spots ago

 

Edit: No I don't even know its name it doesn't matter

Edited by Alongoria13
Link to post
Share on other sites

THE WAY SHE USED ORBIT SO MUCH SO HE GAVE HER THIS MASTERPIECE AND THEN STARTED TO REHASH HIS OLD SOUND

6803d85e1e3eabdd4980d87645da6c371c62addd

ONLY FOR YOU BITCHES TO BUTCHER IT ON THIS FLOP RATE

6803d85e1e3eabdd4980d87645da6c371c62addd

 

I'M NOT CRYING

6803d85e1e3eabdd4980d87645da6c371c62addd

Link to post
Share on other sites
On 2/22/2021 at 7:15 PM, Madame X said:

136.  White Heat

 

5ea39f936fb8a2f4d92a5b19828a34d5.jpg

 

 

 

 

 

 

"You think you can have
My love for free
Well, I've got news for you
That's not the way it's gonna be"

 

 

Average: 6.62

 

Little Lolas:

11: Dark Miracles

10.5: dabunique

10s: The7thStranger, Reverie, Melancholy, That Bad Eartha, Katamari, Poxy, TheWayWeWere, T.O.A.D.S., Quicksand, Never Ending, 1989, Abe Hicks, Wildcat, Agenor, Madame X

 

Little Ritchies:

1s: rta1913, Auburn

0.5s: Twopac

0s: jacklovesyou1

 

This is a rush of energy, with ten different amazing pop hooks, a random movie quote in the beginning.  Just all around one of her best experiments and more cutting edge/experimental songs.  

 

 

 

Comments from the Peanut Gallery

Bloodflowers: (When I first read the title, I thought the "Erotica" singer had a song about c*m... guess I was wrong, she just had an album filler)
Melancholy: used to hate it because i couldn’t get past the intro LMAO eventually i did and i stand from that
dabunique:  i kno da sabotage is real but i can't let this song be played like dat, an amazing song. I have a straight friend who would play this on his guitar to cheer me up
Poxy: A BOP. The #1 Grammy-winning international smash that got away…
Alongoria13: This song is like a harsh misplaced penile thrust, turning off the mood set by the PDP and OYH.
T.O.A.D.S.: The sample was such a good idea. Experimental queen.
TheWayWeWere: The fact that this is only album cut always bothers me so much
creativity: got bored so quickly and kept having to relisten
UnanimousBB16: (Just a boring song that meanders seamlessly I guess)
Tusk:  a guilty pleasure for me
Psycho: The mixing ruins this but it's not great to start with

 

I wasn't a 0 for this i gave it a 1 ???

Link to post
Share on other sites

91.  Has To Be

 

 

 

single_ray-of-light.jpg

 

 

 

 

"I know there's someone out there

Waiting for me

I know there's someone out there

There just has to be"

 

 

Average: 7.317

 

Little Lolas:

11:  Poxy, Gateau, HonourableVomit, Bloodflowers

10.5:  n/a

10s: Pecinta, Ghost, Twopac, BlackoutZone, Gateau, Wildcat, SupremeGoddess, Zayka

 

 

Little Ritchies:

1s:  jacklovesyou, Brando, xxfreshkidx

0.5s: n/a

0s: n/a

 

Hurts the way this sufferent from bonus track sabotage, should have been top 50. 

 

 

 

Comments from the Peanut Gallery

bestfiction:  feel like this song is a coda to the album, the true ending. It’s as quiet as Mer Girl (as I recall, M didn’t want to make a bombastic ending to the album) but more meditative and hopeful
Poxy:  UGH WHY IS THIS A BONUS TRACK??
Alongoria13: Wish it was on the standard version of ROL, doesn't do much for me but I just want to stream it without breaking like, 10 laws in 2020.
rlj: A tragedy this wasn't the albums actual close
T.O.A.D.S.: I hope you heauxs don’t overrate it like y’all always do.
UnanimousBB16:  (Honestly, I found this song to be very boring, and it dragged for a bit too long. I like the instrumentation, but the lyrics were also a bit confusing for me)
Bloodflowers: (The Japanese people were blessed to have this back in the day... thank god for the internet to bless the rest of us!)
Gateau: i relate to this the most out of ever madino song </3
Psycho:  This easily could have replaced several songs on the standard album

Link to post
Share on other sites

Noooooooooo :jonny:

 

I am happy with how it performed considering it's a bonus track but it should be so much higher omg

 

To think of some of what's outlasting it... I absolutely love Knee and In The Zone is my fave album of hers but I really think Brit and JT need to pack it up now and go home :deadbanana2:

Link to post
Share on other sites
rihannabiggestfan

Runaway Lover and Amazing out? YIKES

 

23 minutes ago, John Slayne said:

I didn't give Amazing a 10 because I didn't want to look basic, but secretly it is a 10 

 

daf66de05d1aff503d228721e0b7b3dc.jpg

 

You should have given it a 10 anyway, who cares what other people think? be an unapologetic bitch

Edited by rihannabiggestfan
Link to post
Share on other sites

Thoughts:

 

Bye Bye Baby - I have literally no idea why this is so hated. I've always liked this.

Medellin - this is the definition of a grower, but I'm not mad this out.

Rebel Heart - the demo >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

How High - one of two weak tracks on COADF, but I like it nonetheless!

Devil Pray - should've been a single. One of the best on RH.

Devil Wouldn't Recognise You - this is the best song on HC, I said what I said. Deserved T50 at least.

Girl Gone Wild - lowkey should've been the lead from MDN/A. Don't love it, but don't hate it, either. A deserved placing.

The Beat Goes On - ANOTHER one from M, her discog I have a love/hate relationship with. Bye!

Don't Cry for Me Argentina - I've never liked this, so bye! The Miami Mix >

I Don't Search I Find - This is a bop, but we stan the Honey Dijon mix ONLY in this house.

Easy Ride - this is one of the best on AL, and a perfect closer for it.

 

Intervention - I like it, but this should have been out at least 50 spots ago. Bye!

Fever (Edit One Remix) - It's better than the album version, but bye!

Little Star - should've left like 100 spots ago, bye!

In This Life - one of the best on Erotica, but this is a fair placing.

She's Not Me - one of the best on HC! The tour performance >

Causing a Commotion - Into the Groove 2.0, but a bop regardless.

Express Yourself - the only version of this song that matters. The album version is disgusting.

You'll See - this is great, but absolutely an appropriate placing for it.

Runaway Lover - yet ANOTHER song that should have been a single.

Amazing - an acceptable placing.

Time Stood Still - AN UNDERRATED MASTERPIECE.

Has to Be - could easily have replaced Shanti/Ashtangi on the standard.

 

Things are really starting to get going now we've got most of the trash out of the way! Although HOW are 4 Minutes, Masterpiece and Me Against the Music still in?! Looking forward to the next update!

Link to post
Share on other sites

What's left:

Spoiler

Madonna:
Lucky Star
Borderline
Burning Up
Holiday
Physical Attraction

Like a Virgin:
Material Girl
Angel
Like a Virgin
Into the Groove
Dress You Up

True Blue:
Papa Don’t Preach
Open Your Heart
Live to Tell
True Blue
La Isla Bonita

Like a Prayer:
Like a Prayer
Express Yourself - album mix
Till Death Do Us Part
Promise to Try
Cherish
Oh Father
Keep it Together
Pray for Spanish Eyes

I’m Breathless:
Vogue

Erotica:
Erotica
Fever
Deeper and Deeper
Where Life Begins
Bad Girl
Waiting
Thief of Hearts
Rain

Bedtime Stories:
Survival
Secret
Inside of Me
Human Nature
Forbidden Love (BS)
Love Tried to Welcome Me
Sanctuary
Bedtime Story
Take a Bow


  

Ray of Light:
Drowned World / Substitute for Love
Swim
Ray of Light
Skin
Nothing Really Matters
Sky Fits Heaven
Frozen
The Power of Good-bye
To Have and Not to Hold
Mer Girl


Music:
Music
Impressive Instant
I Deserve It
Don’t Tell Me
What it Feels Like for a Girl
Paradise (Not for Me)
Gone

American Life:
Hollywood
Love Profusion
Nothing Fails
X-Static Process
Die Another Day

 

Confessions on a Dance Floor:
Hung Up
Get Together
Sorry
Future Lovers
Let it Will Be
Forbidden Love (COADF)
Jump
Isaac
Like it or Not

 

Hard Candy:
4 Minutes
Give it 2 Me
Miles Away

 

MDNA:
Masterpiece

 

Rebel Heart:
Living For Love
Ghosttown


Madame X:
God Control

Misc (soundtrack, GH, B-sides):

Crazy For You (from Vision Quest Soundtrack)

Who’s That Girl (from Who’s That Girl)

Justify My Love (from The Immaculate Collection)

Rescue Me (from The Immaculate Collection)

I’ll Remember (from With Honors Soundtrack)

I Want You (from Something to Remember)

Beautiful Stranger (from Austin Powers: The Spy who Shagged Me Soundtrack)

Erotica / You Thrill Me (from Confessions Tour)

Celebration (from Celebration)

 

Collaborations:

Me Against the Music (Britney Spears)


Remixes:

Like a Prayer (Immaculate Collection Mix)
 

 

Link to post
Share on other sites
×
×
  • Create New...