Madonna Discography Rate (TOP 40 REVEALED)

[dabunique]

7 hours ago, supaspaz said:

"My All" made top three, so I don't know.

 

And what’s wrong with dat?!?!

 

if I had participated MA would’ve gotten an 11 also Can’t Let Go 

 

one thing is dat da songs r great and another is a great song with a backstory which both have for me 

[dabunique]

On Friday I lost two 11’s - Angel and THANTH 

my other 11 is LAP so I’ll have to endure a few more batches before it pops up 

[Tremor Christ]

My 11s:

-Physical Attraction

-Impressive Instant

-Get Together

 

10.5s:

-Angel

-I Deserve It

-Erotica

 

[Pecinta Mariah]

My 11

LAP

Frozen

Sorry

 

[Nemo]

"look what your love has done to me,

come on baby, set me free"

 

this is what makes borderline go from a 10 to an 11 and deserving to WIN this rate

 

 

i'm so mad most editions of it have that part, the BEST part, cut out. i think only the original 'madonna' album has kept it which isn't even available on streaming (but is thankfully the version i have in my library)

 

 

live performances from 1984, TVT, S&ST, TOAC & jimmy fallon all cutting it out

 

 

borderline is her most neglected classic on her setlists i fear

 

 

the way she finally put it on a setlist for the s&s tour just to replace it with... holiday

 

Edited 3 hours ago by Nemo

[Twopac]

11: Skin / Sanctuary (OUT)  / To Have and to hold (OUT) 

10.5: Rain / Sorry / Burning Up (all are still in) 

 

0.5: Little Star / True Blue / Whos That Girl OUT-OUT-OUT

0: Into the Groove (it needs to leave the rate asap, overrated, not even her best single in the 80s) / Thief of Hearts / White Heat IN-OUT-OUT

 

My two eliminated 11s deserved top 40 at least

 

 

 

 

 

[Tremor Christ]

1 hour ago, Twopac said:

0: Into the Groove (it needs to leave the rate asap, overrated, not even her best single in the 80s)

@Madame X hopefully you didn't include this score 

[Everest]

My 0s and 0.5s have been out for ages 

 

Still have 2 11s and all three 10.5s 

 

Isaac made Top 40 also 

[Madame X]

Yeah imma be late.  My bf is over for the first time in a month so 

[rta1913]

6 minutes ago, Madame X said:

Yeah imma be late.  My bf is over for the first time in a month so 

[TheWayWeWere]

...how late tho?  

[ArtForFreedom]

17 minutes ago, Madame X said:

Yeah imma be late.  My bf is over for the first time in a month so 

[Madame X]

I’m

 

prob an hour or so! @TheWayWeWere

[Alongoria13]

23 hours ago, Alongoria13 said:

Anal

Ahead of time as usual

[TheWayWeWere]

2 minutes ago, Madame X said:

I’m

 

prob an hour or so! @TheWayWeWere

it's ok for me

[Oktober Knight]

24 minutes ago, Madame X said:

Yeah imma be late.  My bf is over for the first time in a month so 

Take your time boo

 

[Everest]

36 minutes ago, Madame X said:

Yeah imma be late.  My bf is over for the first time in a month so