tournament Marvel Mafia | the end!

[Fruity]

19 minutes ago, Fruity said:

I would very much like to read @Daylight's opinions on the current situation. 

Oh sorry missed your post above @Daylight

 

Well I trust your opinion since you, like me, campaigned to lynch Witch (in fact we both tried to convince Gay Rat, to no avail)

I'm happy to switch to Gay Rat also if anyone else has leanings that way

[Overprotected]

10 minutes ago, TeenageDreaming said:

ARE YOU DUMB?  There should be two confirmed townies when you count yourself too... but that's only possible when you're innocent yourself nice way of outing yourself there

[Daylight]

2 minutes ago, Fruity said:

Oh sorry missed your post above @Daylight

 

Well I trust your opinion since you, like me, campaigned to lynch Witch (in fact we both tried to convince Gay Rat, to no avail)

I'm happy to switch to Gay Rat also if anyone else has leanings that way

Was about to answer to you anyway, I think that it’s suspicious of Gay Rat to want to attach himself to what Hug voted (and even call you out for not doing so), even though we know Hug’s power and he can’t have certainty from that on who may or may not be mafia, just for the sake of wanting to side with town. The reasoning behind this day’s lynching from him doesn’t make sense to me just like his lynch vote from D1 didn’t. Like I would understand if he wanted to lynch minho because he tried to save Witch Privilege on D1 but the reason behind it feels to be only to side with Hug and that’s concerning to me. 

Element feels suspicious as well with the fear mongering about the triple kill when using the simplest logic that wouldn’t have been a threat in any way since we were only on day 1 and there was no way mafia could have guessed correctly another two town roles. So either him or Gay Rat, I’m confident to lynch at this moment.
 

On top of that, I don’t even find it that hard to believe that another 3 out of 4 remaining mafias voted to lynch Hug considering how close the vote was and they needed to pull all the weight possible to save Witch, we know that Chiidish was also mafia and he lynched Hug so we have reason to believe the others could have mostly done the same. I agree with you on wanting to investigate further on the people who voted to lynch Hug since chances are higher we get mafia out from them. 

[Fruity]

15 minutes ago, TeenageDreaming said:

ARE YOU DUMB?  There should be two confirmed townies when you count yourself too... but that's only possible when you're innocent yourself nice way of outing yourself there

Now sis   

The way this made me cackle.. but..

I think it's fair to refer to Hug as the only confirmed townie since, even if he knows he's townie... nobody else does.

[Element]

5 minutes ago, Daylight said:

Element feels suspicious as well with the fear mongering about the triple kill when using the simplest logic that wouldn’t have been a threat in any way since we were only on day 1 and there was no way mafia could have guessed correctly another two town roles. So either him or Gay Rat, I’m confident to lynch at this moment.
 

My logic was literally "i didn't know triple kill existed in this game" and i thought the argument made sense once i learned how powerful it could be! you can go back into the previous greek mafia that i played and see that i really do not knows the ins and outs of mafia. the triple kill was a surprise to me

[touya kinomoto]

We're coming for each others' necks now huh?

 

[DougAF]

47 minutes ago, Element said:

Did you want me to respond to you? I don’t have any interest 

The way you respond to RAT when it was clearly intended for another person with RAT in their name.

 

Telling

 

[Daylight]

7 minutes ago, Element said:

My logic was literally "i didn't know triple kill existed in this game" and i thought the argument made sense once i learned how powerful it could be! you can go back into the previous greek mafia that i played and see that i really do not knows the ins and outs of mafia. the triple kill was a surprise to me

I could believe that you were not aware, however we must be wary of anyone who tried to use the triple kill as a reason since that was one of the simplest ways that could be used to convince others to lynch Hug

Also it doesn’t even benefit mafia to try and guess roles for a triple kill every night because as Miguel explained if they don’t guess right they don’t get any kill at all which probably some didn’t realize, so especially on the first day the threat would be nonexistent and if they’re smart they’re not gonna try and guess roles for a while since chances right now are higher that it backfires and they get 0 kills in a night rather than guessing right and getting 3

 

I’m gonna stick with Gay Rat as that’s my main suspect right now, just be more careful in the future if you’re really town not to make others paranoid about the triple kill so early as that might come off as suspicious

 

Gonna go to sleep right now, I will still probably come by before the countdown ends and see if there are new developments 

[DougAF]

34 minutes ago, Fruity said:

Oh sorry missed your post above @Daylight

 

Well I trust your opinion since you, like me, campaigned to lynch Witch (in fact we both tried to convince Gay Rat, to no avail)

I'm happy to switch to Gay Rat also if anyone else has leanings that way

we been had leanings

[Fruity]

28 minutes ago, Daylight said:

Was about to answer to you anyway, I think that it’s suspicious of Gay Rat to want to attach himself to what Hug voted (and even call you out for not doing so), even though we know Hug’s power and he can’t have certainty from that on who may or may not be mafia, just for the sake of wanting to side with town. The reasoning behind this day’s lynching from him doesn’t make sense to me just like his lynch vote from D1 didn’t. Like I would understand if he wanted to lynch minho because he tried to save Witch Privilege on D1 but the reason behind it feels to be only to side with Hug and that’s concerning to me. 

Element feels suspicious as well with the fear mongering about the triple kill when using the simplest logic that wouldn’t have been a threat in any way since we were only on day 1 and there was no way mafia could have guessed correctly another two town roles. So either him or Gay Rat, I’m confident to lynch at this moment.
 

On top of that, I don’t even find it that hard to believe that another 3 out of 4 remaining mafias voted to lynch Hug considering how close the vote was and they needed to pull all the weight possible to save Witch, we know that Chiidish was also mafia and he lynched Hug so we have reason to believe the others could have mostly done the same. I agree with you on wanting to investigate further on the people who voted to lynch Hug since chances are higher we get mafia out from them. 

Whew yup yup the way we are completely on the same wavelength. 

 

4 minutes ago, DougAF said:

we been had leanings

Hmm okay!

 

Well I'm happy to unlynch Element and lynch Gay Rat Divorce for now. Just wary that currently there are more people voting for Element than Gay Rat... and I don't want minho to steal the lynch because other townies fail to check the thread and change their vote.  

[Element]

7 minutes ago, Daylight said:

I could believe that you were not aware, however we must be wary of anyone who tried to use the triple kill as a reason since that was one of the simplest ways that could be used to convince others to lynch Hug

Also it doesn’t even benefit mafia to try and guess roles for a triple kill every night because as Miguel explained if they don’t guess right they don’t get any kill at all which probably some didn’t realize, so especially on the first day the threat would be nonexistent and if they’re smart they’re not gonna try and guess roles for a while since chances right now are higher that it backfires and they get 0 kills in a night rather than guessing right and getting 3

 

I’m gonna stick with Gay Rat as that’s my main suspect right now, just be more careful in the future if you’re really town not to make others paranoid about the triple kill so early as that might come off as suspicious

 

Gonna go to sleep right now, I will still probably come by before the countdown ends and see if there are new developments 

Thank you for the insight! I am still figuring things out so I will definitely be wary of that moving forward

[Element]

unlynch Fruity and lynch Gay Rat Divorce

[miguel]

Vote Tally:

 

Element (4) - minho, Speezy, Overprotected, Gay Rat Divorce

Gay Rat Divorce (4) - DougAF, Daylight, Fruity, Element

minho (4) - Hug, Rotunda, Sexbot., Dylan'

No Lynch (3) - touya kinomoto, TeenageDreaming, Rence

 

 

Countdown

[Speezy]

Just now, disruptive said:

Vote Tally:

 

Element (4) - minho, Speezy, Overprotected, Gay Rat Divorce

Gay Rat Divorce (4) - DougAF, Daylight, Fruity, Element

minho (4) - Hug, Rotunda, Sexbot., Dylan'

No Lynch (3) - touya kinomoto, TeenageDreaming, Rence

 

 

Countdown

chile how many people didnt vote .

im still sus of rotunda/sex and dylan jolting to vote for minho.

Someone must have tea

[Fruity]

Just now, Speezy said:

chile how many people didnt vote .

im still sus of rotunda/sex and dylan jolting to vote for minho.

Someone must have tea

Completely agree and that won't be forgotten

But Rotunda was the first of those 3 before it was truly a bandwagon, and also he unlynched hug and lynched witch at the last hour... so he's way less suspicious than the other two

[miguel]

3 minutes ago, disruptive said:

Vote Tally:

 

Element (4) - minho, Speezy, Overprotected, Gay Rat Divorce

Gay Rat Divorce (4) - DougAF, Daylight, Fruity, Element

minho (4) - Hug, Rotunda, Sexbot., Dylan'

No Lynch (3) - touya kinomoto, TeenageDreaming, Rence

 

 

Countdown

Yet to vote: Hikari, Sanguine, Taylucifer, Not Like The Movies, Prismee

Can't vote: luckystrike

[Kinich]

Thr amount of switching Element did today asdfghjkl idk im still undecided

 

how many hours left @disruptive

[miguel]

Just now, Hikari said:

Thr amount of switching Element did today asdfghjkl idk im still undecided

 

how many hours left @disruptive

Over 14 hours left, love!

[touya kinomoto]

Since we are all being clowns here, let me lynch touya kinomoto.

[Not Like The Movies]

Just read the last few pages and caught up. 

 

Lynch Element

[smholiv]

7 minutes ago, Speezy said:

chile how many people didnt vote .

im still sus of rotunda/sex and dylan jolting to vote for minho.

Someone must have tea

I’m confused about this too because it came out of nowhere and really felt like bandwagon.  There was no support for it... just voting for me because others did?

[Element]

3 minutes ago, Hikari said:

Thr amount of switching Element did today asdfghjkl idk im still undecided

 

how many hours left @disruptive

kii i'm just trying to save myself at this point

[Kelp]

You guys are saying I only originally voted for minho to align with Hug. And honestly, you're right. Because Hug is the only person we can trust. He is the only person who I know has absolutely no ulterior motive. He could be wrong, but there's no way he's trying to trick us on purpose to vote off a townie. I don't think that reasoning is crazy at all.

 

21 hours ago, Hug said:

Huh. Interesting.

 

Lynch minho

 

The reason I'm voting minho is because I know he's new to the game and probably wasn't sure who to vote for. I'm assuming he went with his team mates who urged him to vote for me to protect Witch Privilege.

I also am friends with minho. I know minho hates these types of games. I doubt he was really thinking about playing the 3D chess of evaluating likelihoods of a triple kill, how likely it was that Witch was Mafia, etc. He was probably being fed info by his team.

 

I switched my vote to Element now because not only do I not want to die (obviously), but also I think it will be revealing about Fruity. He's performing this outspoken, deep town role to us, but what if he's lying? He was the first to accuse Element out of pretty much nowhere. If Element turns out to conveniently be a townie, I will be very suspicious. If he's not, then great! We can trust Fruity more and killing the few remaining Mafia left will be a breeze.

[luckystrike]

well I’m jailed for a long while so I’m just gonna say my thoughts. 
 

I don’t completely trust Element nor Gay Rat and a few other people. I don’t really think minho is evil though, I kind of truly think he’s just innocent and new.

 

So if you look at the voting tally from day 1 and exclude Witch, I was the first person who voted for Hug, BUT I did it based on what Element had said which sounded reasonable to me at the time (which I now think was not the best decision and I know it makes me sus, although no one was pointing out, I am because I have nothing to hide). He was the first person who suggested lynching Hug to which I then agreed, and now I feel like it was a setup to make several townies look suspicious on the long run. AND there was also one point in the voting when Witch was leading in the votes and out of nowhere many votes for Hug came in, the first one being Chiidish (confirmed mafia), shortly after, Sexbot (unlynched Witch and lynched Hug, trying to save his mafia teammate?), and then Gay Rat (very suspicious as we all know), then came minho who I personally think was another townie who got dragged into the Hug vote (obviously could still be mafia).
 

I also think Rotunda is townie, I don’t really see why he’d switch like that at the last minute if he was mafia. 
 

And looking at the current tally, my main suspects would be Element, Gay Rat, Sexbot and maybe Dylan’ (who also voted for Hug, weirdly voted for minho right now, and I agree with Speezy’s post above, it’s very sus to just bandwagon on a vote with no reason) But I’m very iffy on the last one, I feel like maybe the 4th mafia could be one of the Witch voters? I don’t really know, but well, that’s what I had to say, lemme just sit on my prison cell. 
 

[Kinich]

Maybe the prisoner made points, contemplating between Element and fka tymps rn