Sabbath Posted March 7, 2017 Posted March 7, 2017 4 hours ago, Fenrir said: Results and Round 6 coming in the morning.
Fenrir Posted March 7, 2017 Posted March 7, 2017 Scores LiMe DivaCup - 7.5/10 - Solid entry – though her skirt looks a little weird, and the March 4 text should be higher. Also something about this entry feels very dated. Rian - 6/10 - This entry doesn’t scream superhero movie to me, feels more like an indie production. I would have liked to have seen a full body shot with a cool superhero suit. Hurem - 7/10 - I don’t know what to think about this entry, on one hand it looks cool, but on the other it feels like not much has been done apart from adding Lady Gaga’s head and some text - nothing else has been altered. Urban - 6/10 - this is really boring to look at – she’s just standing there – an interesting composition is lacking. Everything about it also feels very cheap & tacky. Phoenix - 6/10 - I don’t really like this colouring you’ve got going on – it gives it a vintage vibe, but then you’ve added the text ‘A modern film’, so it’s a bit conflicting. Apart from that, the film title is completely lost in the poster, Leona should have been placed higher (too much space up the top), and lastly the lightning effects are a bit tasteless. Belle - 8.5/10 - Very good entry! I like that you went with an original superhero I think (everyone should have gone with the something original tbh). The colours are nice, composition is nice – only changes I would have made is the text (having the starring… text run along the bottom curve of the hat, and then making the main title larger). Sabbath - 7.5/10 - Very nice! Title font could have been changed to something more exciting. Also the image of Katy could perhaps have been altered, to show more skill than just cutting her out of an image. Flavs - 8.5/10 - Really good work! Even though you used an existing image as a base (which isn’t a bad thing), I feel enough is changed that it feels original – you’ve used what was available to you to the greatest potential. Nothing else to say, everything looks really solid. SaintWest - 6/10 - Feels like you just Photoshopped her face onto a body. You could have added an awesome title behind her – would have shown a little bit more skill. Though I believe you were the one that was incredibly busy this week?? Anyway, her face is perfectly Photoshopped in though. Bad Things - 8/10 - Really cool entry! I think the only thing that would have made this entry a 10/10 would be if you had photoshopped her clothing into an original superhero suit. Also I love that title text. Melon DivaCup - I think you should have cut her out instead of erasing around her. You ended up with a lot of blurry/transparent spots. The edge of the skirt is rough. March 4th should've been higher. It almost looks like the poster has been cut off too short because it's so low. Not a very big fan of the dark red background. Overall it's pretty good. 7.5/10.Rian - I like it. I really do. I just wish you would've listened to me about the things I pointed out. 7.5/10.Hurem - You can do so much better than slapping Gaga's head onto an already existing poster. 6/10.Urban - I don't know why you thought this was cute. The messily placed face. The background. All the blank space. The Microsoft Word beveled text. I hope this was a product of rushing. 6/10.Phoe - Um. I'll start with the dark area between her arms and her torso. I'm assuming it's meant to be a cape? That definitely didn't translate. I thought you failed to cut that area out at first. Not a fan of the text or logo. The hair almost looks like metal to me. The eyes look very amateur. The effect on the dress is nice. 6/10.Belle - I love this. The only thing I'm not a fan of, is the text. The "AS" is really random in the middle of the poster. The edges of some of your cut outs could've used some blending too. 8/10.Sabbath - I honestly think this is really great. The effects are cartoony, but they kind of work? Cut out is really messy. Can't read the text at the bottom. Image is SUPER huge so it makes it easy to see how LQ it is. 7/10.Flavs - It's really good. You stole the concept, but recreated it completely. Turned it into something completely different. Joan's hair is messy in some spots. The men you took from the original poster are used very well, but the gun on the right side is transparent. That's all I really see. 8/10.SaintWest - I knew it was from the official Wonder Woman shots, but her head is placed so well. You could've made this into something really excellent if you had more time last week. Also the multiple watermarks are sending me. 7/10.Bad Things - The logo is really nice. It kind of gets lost though. I wish you could see it better. The cut out around the dress is great, but the hair is super flat. It looks like the wind is blowing but... her hair isn't. Everything else is pretty good. Her reflection made me chuckle a bit. 7/10. Fenrir DivaCup - 8.5/10 - Besides the blurry patches on the cutout and date being low I really liked this. Rian - 8.5/10 - Still love this more than that other one you were trying to send in. No real complaints here about it.Hurem - 6/10 - I’ll give you points cause it looks great but I know you’re capable of doing more than just slapping Gaga’s face on a poster. Urban - 7.5/10 - Her face looks off and I agree the poster could’ve been more interesting but I think it’s cute for what it is. I know you’ve been busy with work and it’s a decent entry overall, but not your best work.Phoenix - 7.5/10 - Don’t really like the coloring that you did and I think the title of the movie should’ve either been placed at the top instead of the tagline (and maybe colored different) or should’ve used a different color for the title because it definitely doesn’t stand out. Belle - 9/10 - A solid entry. Only things I would’ve changed would be having the “starring..” text curve elsewhere, like along the bottom of the hat like LiMe said. The “As” seems pretty random and doesn’t add anything to the poster. I get what you were trying to do with it but it just looks messy having the “Starring Tiffany ..” in the top right corner and then “As” in the middle. Movie title could’ve been a little bigger too. Overall this was great though. Probably one of your best entries so far. Sabbath - 8.5/10 - I reallllyyyy liked this. Maybe more than I should’ve going off of Melon and LiMe’s comments? The only two issues I had with this were some minor cutting problems I noticed and the credit text should’ve been a different color. Other than that I liked this.Flavs - 8.5/10 - Nothing really to complain about. I loved everything about this. SaintWest - 7/10 - I know you lost your original entry and just made this to submit something but it’s still great. Perfect head placement. Bad Things - 8/10 - Loved everything about this, especially the title font. No real complaints, though I do agree with Melon about her hair.. Results 1. Belle - 8.52. Flavs - 8.33. DivaCup - 7.84. Sabbath - 7.64. Bad Things - 7.66. Rian - 7.37. SaintWest - 6.68. URBAN - 6.58. Phoenix - 6.59. Hurem - 6.3 Eliminated: @Alesus for not submitting anything @URBAN @Hurem @Bad Things @DivaCup @Bellerophon @Sabbath @Rian. @SaintWest @Flavs97 @Phoenixstar @Alesus @Latch @Cantaloupe. @LiMe
DivaCup Posted March 7, 2017 Posted March 7, 2017 i really don't see how i could have cut her out easily.. the hair would have been a huge problem. i don't see these blurry spots you're talking about. I find the scores interesting.. you call one person's entry 'cheap and tacky' and then someone else's entry that was actually cheap and tacky gets a high score
Fenrir Posted March 7, 2017 Posted March 7, 2017 For round 6, you'll (finally) be making gifs!What kind of gif, you ask? Avis, of course!In past seasons, you'd simply find a client and make them an avi of their choice.But sometimes, finding a client wasn't so easy.To save you the trouble of finding one this season, you'll be going to the judges.Choose from these 3:@Fenrir @Cantaloupe. @LiMePM whomever you choose, and make the avi they request to the best of your ability. Tutorial: @URBAN @Hurem @Bad Things @DivaCup @Bellerophon @Sabbath @Rian. @SaintWest @Flavs97 @Phoenixstar Send your entries to either myself or Cantaloupe please.DEADLINE: Saturday (3/11) @ 10pm EST
Fenrir Posted March 7, 2017 Posted March 7, 2017 3 minutes ago, DivaCup said: i really don't see how i could have cut her out easily.. the hair would have been a huge problem. i don't see these blurry spots you're talking about. I find the scores interesting.. you call one person's entry 'cheap and tacky' and then someone else's entry that was actually cheap and tacky gets a high score Whose was actually cheap and tacky that got a highs core? I know I didn't call any of them 'cheap and tacky' but am curious which one you thought.
DivaCup Posted March 7, 2017 Posted March 7, 2017 4 minutes ago, Fenrir said: Whose was actually cheap and tacky that got a highs core? I know I didn't call any of them 'cheap and tacky' but am curious which one you thought. I don't want to reveal i like everybody here. i just think the scores are interesting I still don't see blurry patches on mine... because I didn't cut her out. but y'all are the judges and see things i don't.
Fenrir Posted March 7, 2017 Posted March 7, 2017 15 minutes ago, DivaCup said: I don't want to reveal i like everybody here. i just think the scores are interesting I still don't see blurry patches on mine... because I didn't cut her out. It's most noticeable along the side of her forearm on the arm she's holding up. There's some weird blurriness or effect on it. Maybe it's from the original photo but idk. I didn't dock points because of it since it doesn't detract a whole ton from the overall image, but was just something minor I wanted to point out.
DivaCup Posted March 7, 2017 Posted March 7, 2017 Oh. I think some of it was from the background image I used.. I guess I forgot to erase it maybe? I have no idea. This is the original pic
Rian. Posted March 7, 2017 Posted March 7, 2017 (edited) 41 minutes ago, Fenrir said: Rian - I like it. I really do. I just wish you would've listened to me about the things I pointed out. 7.5/10. @Cantaloupe.I did tho Edited March 7, 2017 by Rian.
Bellerophon Posted March 7, 2017 Posted March 7, 2017 Yeah I was debating over where to put the text on the cap Also I recolored her pics to blue.
Cantaloupe. Posted March 7, 2017 Author Posted March 7, 2017 2 hours ago, DivaCup said: I don't want to reveal i like everybody here. i just think the scores are interesting Same but I'm not gonna start lying ? Fenrir already pointed out one of the blurry spots, but there's more in other places. They could've been avoided if you cut her out. It would've been more difficult, yes, but I think it could've helped. 1 hour ago, Rian. said: @Cantaloupe.I did tho She's still yellow, the text wasn't really moved, and there's still white around her head. 1 hour ago, Phoenixstar said: I was hoping to get banned Ddd. GG I guess. Shut up.
Rian. Posted March 7, 2017 Posted March 7, 2017 1 hour ago, Cantaloupe. said: She's still yellow, the text wasn't really moved, and there's still white around her head. 1. you didn't say make her another color. You said that about blue because you did not want her to be blue. You said 'adjust the yellow to make her look more natural' which I did. 2. The text was moved tho. It's not close to the edges anymore. 3. You never told me about there being white around her head. You said the top of her hair was faded which I made not-visible by moving the font.
Cantaloupe. Posted March 7, 2017 Author Posted March 7, 2017 Just now, Rian. said: 1. you didn't say make her another color. You said that about blue because you did not want her to be blue. You said 'adjust the yellow to make her look more natural' which I did. 2. The text was moved tho. It's not close to the edges anymore. 3. You never told me about there being white around her head. You said the top of her hair was faded which I made not-visible by moving the font. 1. You said she was supposed to be gold, is what I meant for that one. 2. Still pretty close. 3. I did. I even sent you a picture of what I was talking about.
Rian. Posted March 7, 2017 Posted March 7, 2017 36 minutes ago, Cantaloupe. said: 1. You said she was supposed to be gold, is what I meant for that one. 2. Still pretty close. 3. I did. I even sent you a picture of what I was talking about. 1. I tried the gold, looked really bad. 2. Like .... where the **** is it supposed to go? The name of the movie should be the biggest font there. 3. I edited that and it looks a lot better. There's hair and skin there so how do you expect me to paint that area?
Fenrir Posted March 7, 2017 Posted March 7, 2017 4 hours ago, Fenrir said: For round 6, you'll (finally) be making gifs!What kind of gif, you ask? Avis, of course!In past seasons, you'd simply find a client and make them an avi of their choice.But sometimes, finding a client wasn't so easy.To save you the trouble of finding one this season, you'll be going to the judges.Choose from these 3:@Fenrir @Cantaloupe. @LiMePM whomever you choose, and make the avi they request to the best of your ability. Tutorial: @URBAN @Hurem @Bad Things @DivaCup @Bellerophon @Sabbath @Rian. @SaintWest @Flavs97 @Phoenixstar Send your entries to either myself or Cantaloupe please.DEADLINE: Saturday (3/11) @ 10pm EST YAY GIFS!
Cantaloupe. Posted March 8, 2017 Author Posted March 8, 2017 I think we can start having eliminations now, even if we don't get submissions. We have 5 rounds to get rid of 7 people.
Fenrir Posted March 8, 2017 Posted March 8, 2017 1 hour ago, URBESE said: I quit BYE you should be good at this round, bitch.
URBAN Posted March 8, 2017 Posted March 8, 2017 4 minutes ago, Fenrir said: BYE you should be good at this round, bitch. @Cantaloupe. forced me to sign a document stating I shall forfeit during the gif round.
Recommended Posts