Nurr Posted January 9, 2020 Posted January 9, 2020 Just now, Evy said: If you are town and got shot cause of my flop ass I just wanna say sorry already do you have any thoughts else btw, whom do you suspect atm? I've honestly been finding it hard to seize ppl down so far apart from when odd things happen after a Day/Night (like the Mr Blue and fiecE thing) but I'm starting to feel like Astronomy is kinda slipping by compared to that dessy war mafia? but then again I haven't said a lot either I guess
mokitsu Posted January 9, 2020 Posted January 9, 2020 3 minutes ago, Nurr said: but I'm starting to feel like Astronomy is kinda slipping by compared to that dessy war mafia? but then again I haven't said a lot either I guess i agree
Evy Posted January 9, 2020 Posted January 9, 2020 7 minutes ago, Nurr said: I've honestly been finding it hard to seize ppl down so far apart from when odd things happen after a Day/Night (like the Mr Blue and fiecE thing) but I'm starting to feel like Astronomy is kinda slipping by compared to that dessy war mafia? but then again I haven't said a lot either I guess ye astronomy is definitely up there among the suspicious people the only thing I remember is him lynching touya with the reason that "he prob mafia cause he never was before in a mafia" and lynching fierce on day 4 cuase "I haven't read the thread cause I was busy and ye I'm just jumping on the wagon"
Dessy Posted January 9, 2020 Posted January 9, 2020 26 minutes ago, Chiidish said: On my break, but seems things have slowed down as per usual at night. Guess we'll stay perched for @Dessy and @Evy to do all the heavy lifting Bold of you to assume that I will survive tonight.
Dessy Posted January 9, 2020 Posted January 9, 2020 I'm a bit a lot distracted rn but I trust some of yall to break down stuff.
Evy Posted January 9, 2020 Posted January 9, 2020 I just know we have enough info to be able to solve this so I'm counting on you guys
Evy Posted January 9, 2020 Posted January 9, 2020 random thought maybe thecptz is neutral, cause I still don't see him playing in a team but he obv doesn't act towny
Mattheo Posted January 9, 2020 Posted January 9, 2020 fierce being evil was not surprusing i guess i have to bt a lot this day well
Mattheo Posted January 9, 2020 Posted January 9, 2020 6 hours ago, Element said: Since fiercE is a titan, why would he try to get me voted out instead? That would be absolutely pointless for the mafia group since they’d be losing one person regardless it makes sense if fierce was trying to clear you and qould actually be suspecious for him and you if he doesnt lynch someone to save himself as a townie
Evy Posted January 9, 2020 Posted January 9, 2020 ok after reading more of diarrhoe on day5, he felt somewhat genuine in the way he talked he only pushed for the fierce lynch overall which he might have did to get town credit? or maybe he is really a towny who tought that lynching the most obv evil is the best thing (which is totally valid) looking at this game so far our best best is really just pressuring people that seem suspicious and seeing their defences
Evy Posted January 9, 2020 Posted January 9, 2020 Day 5 @Disruptive don't forget to add the tally into this post please https://atrl.net/forums/topic/272983-greek-mafia-battle-of-the-gods-anotha-one/?do=findComment&comment=14793708 Vote tally: fierce (12) - Touch It, Diarrhoea, Nurr, Navyofbadgals, luckystrike, Speezy, Dibbles, Element, Astronomy, EriKills, Kiiwii, DougAF Element (5) - PinkBox, Chiidish, Sabbath, fiercE, mokitsu Hug (3) - Evy, Dessy, Psycho thecptz (1) - Hug Nurr (1) - Mattheo Can't vote: thecptz element was probably the counterwagon to save fierce and thus I think they are towny, besides fierce I do kinda trust the other ones tho on elements wagon if I had to make list from most to least susp in the element wagon it would be pinkbox sabbath chiidish mokitsu I think there are 4-5 evils on fierces wagon, fierce is the 5th/ 6th evil and ye if he is the 5th the 6th is prob amongst hug, mattheo and thecptz the way hug never became an actual big wagon in this game so far, while most of the other afk people who got some votes at some point got big wagons before they started to defend themselves (think wonderlust, sabbath, element) could actually mean that hug is really evil and while the other evils didn't have a problem to jump on the other inactive wagons, they igmored hug cause he is a partner maybe like evils always try to look for mislynch opportunities the fact that hug wasn't used much for that could point to him in the big fierce wagon I think one of the evils voted early (so ye someone among nurr, diarrhoe, navy and luckystrike) defeniteely suspect astronomy since he again just voted for fierce only with some fluff sentence and then dissapeared erikills honestly I don't have much on her dougaf reacts really aggressive towards people who suspect him but I can't make out if he does that to avoid being mislynched as a towny, or if he is an evil trying to get people away from him
Evy Posted January 9, 2020 Posted January 9, 2020 So ye for my final words before I am outta here, good luck town whenever you gather new information (based on roles or dead/ lynched people) backtrack the thread and especially the tallys with that new infomation in mind also try to look for which people could be in a team together and which people could absolutely not be in a team together, the less evils there are the harder it will get finding them alone if they are good at blending in, so checking how people interacted with the known evils on previous days could give new info there are still 5 evils left and 2 neutrals also only medusa is a big threat atm my list would look smth like this atm trust dessy kiiwii touch it psycho mokitsu element speezy have less reasons to trust them than the others chiidish dibbles sabbath pinkbox thecptz luckystrike suspicious erikills mattheo dougaf navyofbadgles nurr diarrhoe astronomy hug
DougAF Posted January 10, 2020 Posted January 10, 2020 Wait @Evy is dying? My sus list is all wrong I’m just gonna start lynching people I don’t like
Dessy Posted January 10, 2020 Posted January 10, 2020 24 minutes ago, DougAF said: Wait @Evy is dying? My sus list is all wrong I’m just gonna start lynching people I don’t like Sis she been cursed a night ago and technically been mostly clear since she was enforced on N2
Touch It Posted January 10, 2020 Posted January 10, 2020 just got home from the city so I skimmed through all the recent posts, @Evy thank you so much for your great analysis! it's really helpful and I'm happy we were able to see how good of a player you are for your first mafia game. evy brought up a lot of good points of people who could be suspicious and we should definitely use some of the points for the next day phase and definitely start questioning the people that we find the most sus
miguel Posted January 10, 2020 Author Posted January 10, 2020 10 hours ago, Disruptive said: fierce (13) - Touch It, Diarrhoea, Nurr, Navyofbadgals, luckystrike, Speezy, Dibbles, Element, Astronomy, EriKills Element (5) - PinkBox, Chiidish, Sabbath, fiercE, mokitsu, kiiwii, DougAF, Hug*** Hug (3) - Evy, Dessy, Psycho thecptz (0) - Hug*** Nurr (1) - Mattheo ***Aphrodite changed Hug's vote from thecptz to fiercE. Couldn't vote: thecptz Added the vote tally to the Night 5 post. I forgot to mention in the story (sorry) that Aphrodite changed Hug's vote from thecptz to fiercE.
miguel Posted January 10, 2020 Author Posted January 10, 2020 Also, a bit over an hour for night to end
Sabbath Posted January 10, 2020 Posted January 10, 2020 my fierce theory being correct, my IQ thank you for your posts @Evy
EriKills Posted January 10, 2020 Posted January 10, 2020 Yah tea, thanks a bunch @Evy for the great analysis , (even though I’m on your list of sus nn), but they’ve been really insightful and there’s a lot I hadn’t noticed, so hopefully the momentum can continue in finding the rest of mafia/3P.
EriKills Posted January 10, 2020 Posted January 10, 2020 Also one thing I wanted to add ie the Fierce vote, I really don’t think Fierce was ever in danger of not being the one to be lynched, despite the various bandwagons that started (which were meant to get people talking). So that vote would have been a great time for mafia to hide in the Fierce votes.
thecptz Posted January 10, 2020 Posted January 10, 2020 4 hours ago, luckystrike said: (which still didn’t get rid of all my suspicions but at least calmed the waters on him a bit). still? DAMN MA
ATRL Moderator Element Posted January 10, 2020 ATRL Moderator Posted January 10, 2020 Thank you for everything @Evy! Your posts have been so insightful especially for someone learning how this works
thecptz Posted January 10, 2020 Posted January 10, 2020 24 minutes ago, Sabbath said: my fierce theory being correct, my IQ thank you for your posts @Evy but your theory about mine is wrong
thecptz Posted January 10, 2020 Posted January 10, 2020 oh i should thank @Evy as well. she's one of the few people who still trusts me
Recommended Posts