Mattheo Posted January 8, 2020 Posted January 8, 2020 2 hours ago, mokitsu said: that’s cute but we can’t even agree on 2 people who we think are sus much less make them vote for someone the only one on my radar rn is cptz ? Are the votes for Element/Nurr/Hug just based on inactivity? @Psycho @Mattheo no i wanted to interact with them, im not getting any presence thats why
Chiidish Posted January 8, 2020 Posted January 8, 2020 2 minutes ago, luckystrike said: Don’t see why y’all say discussing thecptz situation is useless, yes he is silenced and not able to say anything but I mean after seeing how he’s playing the game he probably won’t bother to defend himself properly. I personally just stated the facts to have more reasons to be suspicious of him so we can lynch him when we’re done with fiercE cause imo there’s enough reason to do so. Leaving that to the side, to the people who are random voting, maybe if y’all explained what makes you feel suspicious we could make some progress instead of being stuck discussing a silent bitch that's what i mean by useless. I gather he'll do the same shenanigans when he comes back. it's why there's no point talking about it, unless someone has some other perspective.
Chiidish Posted January 8, 2020 Posted January 8, 2020 5 minutes ago, Chiidish said: nope my top 2 from yesterday are on the chopping block, my number 4 was revealed to be Caerus, and I've cooled off on Dibbles. So would love some new leads at this point. I can go digging again but doubt i'll find something new. to add on these seemed to be overall the most sus people. 1. FiercE - saved by Rhea (whether he is Rhea or another mafia member). 2. Dibbles - defended themselves yesterday but is notably not present for most of the discussion so far 3. thecptz - conveniently silenced. 4. Wonderpuss - thought he could be mafia at some point but is now dead and was mostly helpful to town so far.
Chiidish Posted January 8, 2020 Posted January 8, 2020 Imagine tho...if mafia decided to dual frame FiercE with Rhea and then thecptz with a silence just to absolutely destroy town's momentum? There's no way right? One big power and a silence just for two townies and to destroy town confidence? It's more beneficial to use powers to save themselves right?
mokitsu Posted January 8, 2020 Posted January 8, 2020 3 minutes ago, Chiidish said: Imagine tho...if mafia decided to dual frame FiercE with Rhea and then thecptz with a silence just to absolutely destroy town's momentum? There's no way right? One big power and a silence just for two townies and to destroy town confidence? It's more beneficial to use powers to save themselves right? both have left me suspicious but i feel like ctpz's is just way too convenient idk. i do remember some seasons ago us suspecting someone and them having the majority, but the day got cancelled (just like yesterday). we proceeded to lynch them and they were indeed mafia. of course that might not be the case now
Evy Posted January 8, 2020 Posted January 8, 2020 okay I started to analyze day 1 tally and it just starting to become this huge ass mess of an essay I hope you guys will bother tho reading it lmao
Dessy Posted January 8, 2020 Posted January 8, 2020 Quote touya kinomoto (13) - Evy, Psycho, Touch It, Astronomy, Mr. Blue_Shirt, Sabbath, luckystrike, Overprotected, DAP (Hug), Element, Speezy, EriKills, DougAf Psycho (4) - mokitsu, worldwide angel, Navyofbadgals, Witch Privilege No Lynch (3) - Chiidish, fiercE, kiiwii PinkBox (2) - Diarrhoea, Wonderlust Navyofbadgals (2) - thecptz, wxvii (Nurr) luckystrike (2) - Guero, Dessy Evy (1) - touya kinomoto Diarrhoea (1) - Pinkbox Daylight (1) - Dibbles Dibbles (1) - Daylight kiiwii (1) - Mattheo Didn't vote: dweebz The touya wagon really had nothing happened to it since. Psycho - idk Touch It - Contributive, likely town Astronomy - not really doing anything The three above were the first to vote and stay but with Mr Blue Shirt hopping on, it's harder to say that they are indeed town. Sabbath - offered that one big defense last phase. But we don't really have much on them. luckystrike - well they been consistency active and defended themselves a few times. They also just seem to be posting freely which is probably more of a towny thing to do. These two pretty much secured that touya be the lead wagon so I'm inclined to view them in a slightly positive light. But my previous theory relied on Witch being mafia as well so I'm not as secure on this as I was before that Day Phase Hug - see Astronomy Element - idk, kinda just comes in and then exits Speezy - idk EriKills - I feel like they're doing less than what I remember from when they were mafia. Probably a good thing DougAF - idk. Though if I had to think something, they are mimicking the last town game they play. These spots have neutral equity from voting. I probably wouldn't mind voting those except EriKills. --- Psycho's wagon: Moki is doing stuff and questioning people. Navy generally gives off a towny vibe and possibly was spewed town by Blue Shirt. It's entirety possible this wagon was pure ignoring Witch. --- No Lynch's: Chiidish basically been playing and doing stuff. They're probably town but I'm still wary. kiiwii I think is possibly town due to just going for Blue Shirt in day 2. I just don't feel like a mafia would readily point out what has happened right away. And if they would, it would probably be a bigger name, no offense to kiiwii. --- Off-Wagon's: Diarrhoea - their trolling makes it easier to hide their alignment but they also made attempts to do some stuff thecptz - More trolling that hide alignment but I also think they're legitimately busy as well so can't really say. Though I do feel like they would at least help out more as town. Nurr - She hasn't really made much of an impact. BUT after a quick look at their posts I think they're kinda town tbh. So I will be retracting my vote there. Dessy - Hi PinkBox - I think their overall posts have been generally towny and they made a point to defend themself with reasons that aren't really disputable. Dibbles - She is within her towny range. How do I know? She does that thing when she make a big post, unprompted, and point out why someone or something is suspicious. Mattheo - I kinda wish I could see more from this player but I don't really sense malicious intent from them My current PoE: Evy kiiwii Touch It Dibbles NavyofBadgyals Mokitsu PinkBox luckystrike Chiidish EriKills Nurr Mattheo Sabbath Diarrheoa DougAF thecptz Speezy Element Hug
Evy Posted January 8, 2020 Posted January 8, 2020 not dessy basically doing the same thing I am doing currently aswell
Dessy Posted January 8, 2020 Posted January 8, 2020 4 minutes ago, Dessy said: Evy kiiwii Touch It Dibbles NavyofBadgyals Mokitsu PinkBox luckystrike Chiidish Psycho EriKills Nurr Mattheo Sabbath Astronomy Diarrheoa DougAF thecptz Speezy Element Hug Forgot Psycho and Astronomy
Evy Posted January 8, 2020 Posted January 8, 2020 actually I will gonna do it just bit by bit looking at day 1 tally and trying to follow my own sense how the evils would possibly have spread their votes on this day 1 touya kinomoto (13) - Evy, Psycho, Touch It, Astronomy, Mr. Blue_Shirt, Sabbath, luckystrike, Overprotected, DAP (hug), Element, Speezy, EriKills, DougAf Psycho (4) - mokitsu, worldwide angel, Navyofbadgals, Witch Privilege No Lynch (3) - Chiidish, fiercE, kiiwii PinkBox (2) - Diarrhoea, Wonderlust Navyofbadgals (2) - thecptz, wxvii(nurr) luckystrike (2) - Guero, Dessy Evy (1) - touya kinomoto Diarrhoea (1) - Pinkbox Daylight (1) - Dibbles Dibbles (1) - Daylight kiiwii (1) - Mattheo Didn't vote: dweebz red = evil green = town purple = neutral orange = suspect blue = somewhat trust (of course I could be wrong so take it with a grain of salt) I might be wrong on this but as I said earlier there are definitely evils on touyas wagon because if they weren't sitting there, hermes just could have checked the tally and bam confirm in one hit all the people on there as non-mafia, about half evils sitting on that wagon seems possible to me cause ye only 1-2 would be pretty risky, cause as soon as these are found all the other people would be confirmed non-mafia and overall it is easier to hide on the touya wagon cause they were probably afraid to go on wagons with not many ppl, in case hermes would check that and basically immiditaly find 1 evil so let's assume 4 evils sitting on the touya wagon and the rest 4 evils spread among the other votes we obv have touya and blue alrdy out so ye 3 evils left on the touya wagon and 3 on the others are left I don't think 2 evils would risk sitting on the same wagon, because if hermes would check that tally he would find in go 2 confirmed evils, so they probably voting on a wagon where a non-towny is alrdy voting on PinkBox (2) - Diarrhoea, Wonderlust Navyofbadgals (2) - thecptz, wxvii(nurr) luckystrike (2) - Guero, Dessy looking at these votes I do think diarrhoea and nurr could be most potentional evils as said thecptzs reactions towards me after touyas lynch seemed to attention drawing and genuine not-knowing that touya is mafia to be faked coming from a mafia, I do agree that he is messy and not towny aswell but ye I feel like he overall doesn't work in a team and reminds me kinda of wonderlust tbh but ye clearing out who among thecptz or nurr could be more likely evil could be useful and making the other one more trustworthy maybe dessy is of course aswell still an option but atm I do see dessy at worst a 3P since he done and said a lot fo stuff he didn't have to if he was mafia
Evy Posted January 8, 2020 Posted January 8, 2020 9 minutes ago, Dessy said: Alt accounts tea well actually going through your analyses I did mine differently so it is good to see it approach from different angles
Evy Posted January 8, 2020 Posted January 8, 2020 Okay there is definitely at least 1 evil among the psycho(4) and no lynch (3) tally imo since after the touya tally these 2 tallys are biggest ones, so better places to hide for evils in case hermes checks them I don't know if there is 1 evil on psycho and 1 evil on the no lynch tally but I am pretty sure, not 2 evils would risk sitting on the same tally Psycho (4) - mokitsu, worldwide angel, Navyofbadgals, Witch Privilege No Lynch (3) - Chiidish, fiercE, kiiwii atm it does look like fierce is our best bet for this group, since I do trust kiiwii since besides getting lynched blue he seems overall towny even if lowkey I do trust chiidish aswell somewhat, his poseidon thing unless planned in the evil mafia seems towny to me and ye he tries to be contribute between mokitsu and navyofbadgals I trust atm mokitsu more, I don't have much info on both atm but I remember mokitsu being more towny and raising some questions to solve the game
Evy Posted January 8, 2020 Posted January 8, 2020 Evy (1) - touya kinomoto Diarrhoea (1) - Pinkbox Daylight (1) - Dibbles Dibbles (1) - Daylight kiiwii (1) - Mattheo Didn't vote: dweebz the evils might have been to shook to lynch alone on someone, cause ye in case hermes would check he would find them immidiatly but they also prob could have bet that there is a lower chance for hermes to check an tally with 1 person overall looking at this group I do trust mattheo the least out of them, since he didn't do much yet and seem to lay low 2nd most supicious would be pinkbox to me, since besides his action on day 1 he seems laying low dibbles as I mentioned did draw attention with poseidon on her when she didn't really have to and overall seems the most towniest for me atm
miguel Posted January 8, 2020 Author Posted January 8, 2020 Vote tally: ~16 hours left fierce (8) - Touch It, Diarrhoea, Nurr, Navyofbadgals, luckystrike, Speezy, Dibbles, Element thecptz (3) - PinkBox, Chiidish, Hug Hug (1) - Evy Element (1) - Psycho Nurr (1) - Mattheo luckystrike (1) - fiercE Astronomy (1) - mokitsu
miguel Posted January 8, 2020 Author Posted January 8, 2020 MESSAGE FROM THE CARRIBEAN Spoiler Who's afraid of the big bad wolf? ? Spoiler
Evy Posted January 8, 2020 Posted January 8, 2020 ok if we assume 3 evils hide among the 3 groups I talked about so far my susp would be so far most susp fierce nurr diarrhoe navyofbadgals mattheo
PinkBox Posted January 8, 2020 Posted January 8, 2020 Lynch element He's smart, has been playing games since forever Yet seems completely useless in this game
Chiidish Posted January 8, 2020 Posted January 8, 2020 I'm gonna switch like, and change my vote to Lynch Element I do think that the second bandwagon is pointless but I also think putting it onto thecptz since their silenced won't get us any extra info. At least choosing someone unsilenced can potentially force someone to speak up more or even bait out a mistake from mafia.
Evy Posted January 8, 2020 Posted January 8, 2020 touya kinomoto (13) - Evy, Psycho, Touch It, Astronomy, Mr. Blue_Shirt, Sabbath, luckystrike, Overprotected, DAP(Hug), Element, Speezy, EriKills, DougAf ok the touya wagon is by far the hardest to analyze and why we hate big wagons so much, because getting info out of them is a nightmare I honestly have no clue, I mean I guess if astronomy is evil, I don't think sabbath is if sabbath is evil I dont think astronomy is, cause I don't particulary see 3 evils juming right after another on the same wagon (but it still could be a possibility who knows) out of the early voters I do trust touch it the most, psycho voted aswell early but he didn't really else give me much towny impression throughout the game tbh I would assume there is at least 1 evil among the super inactive ones on this wagon so: hug, element, sabbath hence why I really want to investigate hug today, cause the 2 other only came in to defend and then dissapeaerd again if I have time today I would like to look into luckystrie, speezy and erikills they are all pretty similar to me, they do seem somewhat confident and speak their mind but at the same time I don't remember yet having seen smth from them allignment indicative dougaf, was pretty attention drawing in the first few days and I could have seen that as non-mafia but in the last few days I barely remember him
Sabbath Posted January 8, 2020 Posted January 8, 2020 6 minutes ago, PinkBox said: Lynch element He's smart, has been playing games since forever Yet seems completely useless in this game RIGHT? You're telling me Element didn't reply to ANY accusations yesterday and only came here today to join a bandwagon? and he STILL hasn't provided any theories or thoughts or anything that might help? Nahhhhhh Lynch Element
Chiidish Posted January 8, 2020 Posted January 8, 2020 We do want to lynch FiercE tho right? so whoever has triple vote please be careful not to tip the scales.
Evy Posted January 8, 2020 Posted January 8, 2020 the way the essays are ignored do I even need to bother to do similar stuff to the other tallys?
Recommended Posts