Future Lover

Better 00s discography: Madonna, Mariah or Janet?

?  

100 members have voted

  1. 1. ?

    • Madonna
      62
    • Mariah
      29
    • Janet
      7


Recommended Posts

HïFidelity

Even tho Janet and Madonna have better albums (overall), Mariah’s album from the 2000s for more replay value out of me. Memoirs, MC2 and The Emancipation and Glitter were all great albums all the way through.

 

Madonna has Confessions / Hard Candy and Janet has All For You, but Mariah won.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1365

madonna's covers ALONE (except HC :rip:) are better than the other two's discographies put together...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Alongoria13

Hard Candy >>> 2nite >>>> the rest

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
stevyy

Chartsmasters:

 

01 - 10,700,000 - 2000 - Music

02 - 9,325,000 - 2005 - Confessions on a Dancefloor

03 - 8,600,000 - 2005 - The Emancipation of Mimi

04 - 5,900,000 - 2001 - All For You

00 - 5,600,000 - 2001 - GHV2

00 - 4,100,000 - 2001 - Greatest Hits

05 - 3,650,000 - 2008 - Hard Candy

06 - 3,375,000 - 2003 - American Life

07 - 3,100,000 - 2009 - Celebration

08 - 2,800,000 - 2002 - Charmbracelet

09 - 2,150,000 - 2008 - E=MC²

10 - 1,900,000 - 2001 - Glitter

11 - 1,550,000 - 2004 - Damita Jo

00 - 1,300,000 - 2007 - The Confessions Tour

12 - 1,050,000 - 2009 - Memoirs of an Imperfect Angel

13 - 1,000,000 - 2006 - 20 Y.O.

00 - 800,000 - 2008 - The Ballads

14 - 700,000 - 2008 - Discipline

00 - 700,000 - 2006 - I'm Going to Tell You a Secret

15 - 600,000 - 2009 - Number Ones

00 - 500,000 - 2003 - The Remixes

00 - 400,000 - 2003 - Remixed & Revisited

 

38,150,000 - 2000-2009 - 9 releases - Madonna (ages 42 - 51)

21,900,000 - 2000-2009 - 8 releases - Mariah Carey (ages 30 - 39)

9,750,000 - 2000-2009 - 5 releases - Janet Jackson (ages 34 - 43)

 

average:

4,238,888 - Madonna

2,737,500 - Mariah

1,950,000 - Janet

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Nexto
8 minutes ago, stevyy said:

Chartsmasters:

 

01 - 10,700,000 - 2000 - Music

02 - 9,325,000 - 2005 - Confessions on a Dancefloor

03 - 8,600,000 - 2005 - The Emancipation of Mimi

04 - 5,900,000 - 2001 - All For You

00 - 5,600,000 - 2001 - GHV2

00 - 4,100,000 - 2001 - Greatest Hits

05 - 3,650,000 - 2008 - Hard Candy

06 - 3,375,000 - 2003 - American Life

07 - 3,100,000 - 2009 - Celebration

08 - 2,800,000 - 2002 - Charmbracelet

09 - 2,150,000 - 2008 - E=MC²

10 - 1,900,000 - 2001 - Glitter

11 - 1,550,000 - 2004 - Damita Jo

00 - 1,300,000 - 2007 - The Confessions Tour

12 - 1,050,000 - 2009 - Memoirs of an Imperfect Angel

13 - 1,000,000 - 2006 - 20 Y.O.

00 - 800,000 - 2008 - The Ballads

14 - 700,000 - 2008 - Discipline

00 - 700,000 - 2006 - I'm Going to Tell You a Secret

15 - 600,000 - 2009 - Number Ones

00 - 500,000 - 2003 - The Remixes

00 - 400,000 - 2003 - Remixed & Revisited

 

38,150,000 - 2000-2009 - 9 releases - Madonna (ages 42 - 51)

21,900,000 - 2000-2009 - 8 releases - Mariah Carey (ages 30 - 39)

9,750,000 - 2000-2009 - 5 releases - Janet Jackson (ages 34 - 43)

 

average:

4,238,888 - Madonna

2,737,500 - Mariah

1,950,000 - Janet

 

we're not talking about charts hunni so stop with the random number spewing x

 

OT: mess @ jan receiving 0 votes so far :rip:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
stevyy
1 minute ago, Nexto said:

we're not talking about charts hunni so stop with the random number spewing x

 

OT: mess @ jan receiving 0 votes so far :rip:

I was simply stating the sales for everyone to see that some Madonna fans are completely ignorant by rating the music of the other 2 by their album covers in saying that Madonna's music is better bc her album covers are better - which in itself is a subjective observation. 

 

The Madonna stans seem very hostile towards Janet and Mariah... and I have 0 clue why this is. Of course... I totally understand that when Madonna is your fave out of the three you will put her at #1 and all... but the superlatives that are written in here in regards to the quality of the music of the other 2 is totally hostile and ignorant - if I can say so. 

 

I belong to those music fans, who actually know the music by these 3 women... I own all of their albums actually. And I find amazing tunes in all of their albums... (and some not so amazing ones in also all of their albums). 

 

Disregarding the other 2 so much, suggests to me, that the people are either very young and have to yell their opinion in order to be heard - in a very rude fashion I want to add - or they do not even know the content of the albums they are so easily dismissing. 

 

This poll makes it seem like the question being about yay or nay... but in all honesty the discussion should be / could be way more mature. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Nexto
1 minute ago, stevyy said:

I was simply stating the sales for everyone to see that some Madonna fans are completely ignorant by rating the music of the other 2 by their album covers in saying that Madonna's music is better bc her album covers are better - which in itself is a subjective observation. 

 

The Madonna stans seem very hostile towards Janet and Mariah... and I have 0 clue why this is. Of course... I totally understand that when Madonna is your fave out of the three you will put her at #1 and all... but the superlatives that are written in here in regards to the quality of the music of the other 2 is totally hostile and ignorant - if I can say so. 

 

I belong to those music fans, who actually know the music by these 3 women... I own all of their albums actually. And I find amazing tunes in all of their albums... (and some not so amazing ones in also all of their albums). 

 

Disregarding the other 2 so much, suggests to me, that the people are either very young and have to yell their opinion in order to be heard - in a very rude fashion I want to add - or they do not even know the content of the albums they are so easily dismissing. 

 

This poll makes it seem like the question being about yay or nay... but in all honesty the discussion should be / could be way more mature. 

:rip:

 

voted for mimi but go off ig.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
WhateverYouWant

Mariah > Janet > Madonna. I recently went back through Madonna’s discography and outside of her iconic hits much of it is trash imho

 

edit: thought this was the 90’s music thread. Madonna’s 2000’s music is better than Janet’s but Mariah still wins. 

Edited by WhateverYouWant

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
LoveLiveMusic

Confessions On A Dance Floor/Music

Hard Candy

Damita Jo

The Emancipation of Mimi

Discipline

All For You

American Life

Glitter

E=MC2

20 Y.O.

Charmbracelet

Memoirs of An Imperfect Angel

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Scotland

Madonna for sure. ‘00s is her best decade actually.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
SitarHero

Madonna's best decade against their...not best

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Elusive Chanteuse
5 hours ago, eli's_rhythm said:

Confessions > American Life > Damita Jo > Memoirs of an Imperfect Angel  > All for You > Music > The Emancipation of Mimi > Glitter > E=MC2 > 20 Y.O. > Hard Candy > Charmbracelet > Discipline

 

Madonna, but it's not as much of a landslide as I expected.

Eli not Hard Candy above Charmbracelet and Discipline. :dies:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Lover
7 hours ago, MotherSuperior said:

Janet's album covers... :toofunny3:

 

Why is she always half naked and covering her ****? 

 

anigif_enhanced-24648-1431788231-15.gif

 

:toofunny3:

because she's desperate and nasty. X

15984305.gif

 

2 users voting jj :rip:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1989

Madonna. American Life by itself is enough for her to win. Nothing Fails, X-Static Process, Die Another Day, Mother And Father, Easy Ride, etc. An alberm. :jonny5:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
C.Damen

Hollywood alone >>>

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
robbyds

Janet > Mariah > Madge

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
eli's_rhythm
13 hours ago, Elusive Chanteuse said:

Eli not Hard Candy above Charmbracelet and Discipline. :dies:

Charmbracelet is full of 6s and Discipline has 2 10s, a couple 8s and a bunch of 3s.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Nemo

madonna >>> mariah >>>>> janet

 

this is really the only order and non are even really close

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
HandsomeGumDrop

It goes Janet than Mariah than Madonna Janet music outshines both Madonna and Mariah discographies.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
TipToe

Madonna since she managed to produce 3 masterpieces (Music, COADF and Hard Grammy) meanwhile the other bishes only had one each. :1stplace:

Edited by TipToe

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
suburbannature

Mariah for TEOM and Glitter. Madonna is close behind because of Music and COADF, but they both have some of their weakest albums in the 00s

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
My Tears Ricochet

Mariah>>>>

Emancipations alone>>>>>> The other 2 dated discographies 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Bussea

Janet

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Xtianlofbritney

Confessions

 

 

the rest

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Bey_Rihstan

hm..

 

Madonna: 

Music - Great

American Life - OK

Confessions - Great

Hard Candy - Ok

Celebration - Why is this here

 

Mariah: 

Glitter - OK

Charmbracelet - OK

TEOM - Great

E=MC2 - Good

Memoirs - Great

 

Janet: 

All For You - Good

Damita Jo - Good

20 YO - Bad

Discipline - Bad

 

Mariah > Madonna > Janet

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites