tournament ATRL Mafia I: Stars vs. Flops: Day Ten Game Over [STARS WON]

[mokitsu]

Beyonce better start using ha power now that Keri is dead

[Badboidami]

I am dead at Keri Hilson's card. 

[Unoriginal]

25 minutes ago, mokitsu said:

Beyonce better start using ha power now that Keri is dead

ummm has Bey's power been revealed?

[Badboidami]

Now that I am looking into this thread, Dibbles gives me flop vibes with those "we have to lynch someone", lowkey same with Opium - look at their posts. I will look into this whole situation further tonight, when I have some more free time.

[Badboidami]

1 minute ago, Unoriginal said:

ummm has Bey's power been revealed?

No, but Keri Hilson's power was that she can select one person during night phase and if it's Bey, she will be killed. Basically, she is safe now.

[mokitsu]

3 minutes ago, Unoriginal said:

ummm has Bey's power been revealed?

Not that I know of 

 

2 minutes ago, Badboidami said:

Now that I am looking into this thread, Dibbles gives me flop vibes with those "we have to lynch someone", lowkey same with Opium - look at their posts. I will look into this whole situation further tonight, when I have some more free time.

+1 about Opium

[Badboidami]

@Jan could you post all the revealed stars cards? I think it was posted in the previous thread?

[Jan]

Just now, Badboidami said:

@Jan could you post all the revealed stars cards? I think it was posted in the previous thread?

From the signups thread:

 

 



 

 

Dead players cards:

 

 

[Badboidami]

@Jan thank you. Looking at them, I think that Madonna's card is the most powerful card of the ones we know so far and I might have a prediction who's Madonna. 

[lunnuyu]

Oh well, I’ll have to re-evaluate my choice for lynching ...that’s if I’ll be alive for the next day :c 

[touya kinomoto]

35 minutes ago, Badboidami said:

Now that I am looking into this thread, Dibbles gives me flop vibes with those "we have to lynch someone", lowkey same with Opium - look at their posts. I will look into this whole situation further tonight, when I have some more free time.

I agree with you on Dibbles. On Opium, not so much.

[Hug]

Hello, I just got to this thread and wow people are slandering me.

[Dessy]

2 hours ago, Badboidami said:

No, but Keri Hilson's power was that she can select one person during night phase and if it's Bey, she will be killed. Basically, she is safe now.

Beyonce's power is probably the same as Keri, only in reverse. But who knows? 

 

2 hours ago, Badboidami said:

@Jan thank you. Looking at them, I think that Madonna's card is the most powerful card of the ones we know so far and I might have a prediction who's Madonna. 

You better not reveal it   

[Dessy]

5 hours ago, Red Light said:

I wouldn't vote Satan yet because I think the coincidence of somebody with the name Satan being a flop just makes him less likely than the other four.  

 

Urban just started, so I'll hold off on ha unless further evidence comes in.

 

Idk about HotHeaven because it would be stupid to implicate themselves if they had something to lose, although it could be reverse psychology or a way to build up false trust with us.

 

Also don't know about Poki because he was the first person I voted to lynch as a joke and, again, it would just be a freaky coincidence if he were a flop. 

 

So that leaves @Unoriginal. 

 

 

5 hours ago, mokitsu said:

Wait so there are only 4 flops? For some reason I thought it was half-half or something 

 

Moki is derpclear btw. 

[Badboidami]

40 minutes ago, Dessy said:

You better not reveal it

I am not going to, that would be too ****ed up of me. 

 

39 minutes ago, Dessy said:

Moki is derpclear btw. 

What does derpclean stand for?

[Dessy]

3 minutes ago, Badboidami said:

I am not going to, that would be too ****ed up of me. 

 

What does derpclean stand for?

derpclear is basically when a player (usually town, or Stars in this case) basically say something that seems too dumb to say. Mafia have the information advantage over town, so they're less likely to say something dumb or ignorant about the gamestate. We also know generally that there are 5 mafia, not 4. So in my mind that makes moki "there are only 4 flops?" more towny. This CAN be faked by the mafia team but given this site relative experience level, I don't think that is the case here. 

[Badboidami]

1 minute ago, Dessy said:

derpclear is basically when a player (usually town, or Stars in this case) basically say something that seems too dumb to say. Mafia have the information advantage over town, so they're less likely to say something dumb or ignorant about the gamestate. We also know generally that there are 5 mafia, not 4. So in my mind that makes moki "there are only 4 flops?" more towny. This CAN be faked by the mafia team but given this site relative experience level, I don't think that is the case here. 

Oh, ok. Thanks.

 

This game will become much more interesting soon - the thories now prove it. That's gonna be such fun. 

[Dessy]

On 3/25/2018 at 2:25 PM, Jan said:

ATRL Mafia: Stars vs. Flops: Vote Tally.

 

22 hours 30 minutes left until end of Day One. Timer.

 

Dessy (8) - Alpha, gxnesis, Hug, KatyCatPH, levi_valvi, mokitsu, Opium, Pendulum

No Lynch (4) - Badboiami, Dibbles, Dolce Vita, that G.U.Y

Badboiami (2) - Caprice, Dessy

Hug (1) - Ecstasy

 

Yet to vote (11) - bestfiction, HotHeaven, jamesfog, Latinazza, Pacaveli, paulyyyozd, PoKiTaurus, Queen Conchita, Red Light, Satan, Unoriginal.

 

Please do check if the tallies are correct. I may sometimes miss something.

Pre-No Lynch Wagon Day One^ 

 

On 3/27/2018 at 5:22 PM, Jan said:

ATRL Mafia: Stars vs. Flops: Vote Tally.

 

Timer.

 

KatyCatPH (8) - Badboiami, Dolce Vita, Ecstasy, that G.U.Y., gxnesis, jamesfog, levi_valvi, mokitsu

No Lynch (3) - Dibbles, KatyCatPH, PoKiTaurus

Dessy (1) - Opium

Ecstasy (1) - Red Light

Opium (1) - Pendulum

 

Yet to vote (11) - Alpha, bestfiction, Caprice, Dessy, HotHeaven, Hug, Pacaveli, paulyyyozd, Satan, Unoriginal, Vigoorian King.

 

Peak Katy wagon. There is obviously another scum there. 

 

22 hours ago, Jan said:

ATRL Mafia: Stars vs. Flops: Vote Tally.

 

Timer.

 

KatyCatPH (7) - Badboiami, Dolce Vita, Ecstasy, gxnesis, jamesfog, levi_valvi, mokitsu

Ecstasy (4) - that G.U.Y., Hug, Red Light, Unoriginal

No Lynch (3) - Dibbles, KatyCatPH, PoKiTaurus

Dessy (1) - Opium

Opium (1) - Pendulum

 

Yet to vote (9) - Alpha, bestfiction, Caprice, Dessy, HotHeaven, Pacaveli, paulyyyozd, Satan, Vigoorian King.

The rise of the Ecstasy counter wagon. that GUY moved to Ecstasy...

 

23 hours ago, that G.U.Y. said:

I made a spelling error in my previous post. I vote to lynch ecstasy

 

 

But if you want to claim your star role i would switch my vote again

This is a bad post especially for someone who wasn't that threatened, yet...

 

17 hours ago, bestfiction said:

I actually think that neither KatyCatPH nor Ecstasy are flops so at this point I’ll just side with Dessy and vote to Lynch gxnesis

 

17 hours ago, Jan said:

ATRL Mafia: Stars vs. Flops: Vote Tally.

 

Timer.

 

KatyCatPH (7) - Badboiami, Dolce Vita, Ecstasy, gxnesis, jamesfog, levi_valvi, mokitsu

Ecstasy (5) - that G.U.Y., Hug, KatyCatPH, Red Light, Unoriginal

gxnesis (2) - bestfiction, Dessy

No Lynch (2) - Dibbles, PoKiTaurus

Dessy (1) - Opium

Opium (1) - Pendulum

 

Yet to vote (7) - Alpha, Caprice, HotHeaven, Pacaveli, paulyyyozd, Satan, Vigoorian King.

At this point I came in and bestfiction was the first person to join me. It's an easy spot to join in from not voting yet but we'll see.

 

---

There is the levi/HotHeaven interaction that I'm inclined to read as Star/Star. Merely it seemed like a disagreement in gameplay strategies. 

---

 

11 hours ago, Jan said:

ATRL Mafia: Stars vs. Flops: Vote Tally.

 

Timer.

 

Ecstasy (6) - Alpha, that G.U.Y., Hug, KatyCatPH, Red Light, Unoriginal

KatyCatPH (6) - Badboiami, Dolce Vita, Ecstasy, gxnesis, jamesfog, mokitsu

No Lynch (3) - Dibbles, PoKiTaurus, Satan

gxnesis (2) - bestfiction, Dessy

Dessy (1) - Opium

HotHeaven (1) - levi_valvi

levi_valvi (1) - HotHeaven

Opium (1) - Pendulum

 

Yet to vote (4) - Caprice, Pacaveli, paulyyyozd, Vigoorian King.

The stalement. (This is will vote shift starts to actually matters). 

 

10 hours ago, Caprice said:

I have a train to catch, I won't have the internet again until after the day is over and Dolce Vita didn't bother responding to me even tho I could see him in the thread up until a few seconds ago, so I'm Lynching Dolce Vita, the bandwagoning + the "omg idk what to do " + the not answering me even tho he read my post makes him more suspicious to me than KatyCat imo..

Caprice chose their own lane rather than voting into the lynches. +town

 

9 hours ago, mokitsu said:

So I'm gonna kill the only person who might buy Joyride?  

Lynch Gxnesis  

 

The first person that jumped off (Katy)

 

Making it gxnesis - 3

 

9 hours ago, levi_valvi said:

Alright Lynch Gxnesis

Jumped off his 1v1 wagon. There is little chance that a Flop jump on his own buddy unless it was absolutely certain they were going down. +town 

gxnesis - 4

 

9 hours ago, Badboidami said:

@Dessy is definitely making some points. Lemme change my vote.

 

Lynch gxnesis

Jumped off  of KatyCat making it

gxnesis - 5 and over KatyCat wagon.

 

9 hours ago, Pendulum said:

I change my vote!

 

Lynch gxnesis

Change from his 1v1 to tie the lynch. +town

gxnesis -6 now tied with Ecstasy 

 

9 hours ago, paulyyyozd said:

that’s what I’m thinking too tbh. their theories make sense but they have also the most experience here and on the other hand the other player’s „suspicious” behaviour maybe an arbitrary result of them being new to the game. 

 

I don’t wanna make a make or break decision and I have a class now so I don’t have much time to think it through so I’m gonna just lynch Dessy. 

 

 

And this person basically jumped on me cause busy or something. A weird spot to be in.

 

9 hours ago, Dibbles said:

Oh well we do have to lynch someone in the end

 

Lynch gxnesis

 

This is a tipping vote but their tone make it seem like they feel that gxnesis is defeated anyway (momentum). I normally consider this spot town but I have my doubt this time. 

gxnesis - 7

 

9 hours ago, KatyCatPH said:

Then I'll lynch gxnesis too.

Katy finally feeling safe makes it...

gxnesis - 8

 

9 hours ago, Jan said:

ATRL Mafia: Stars vs. Flops: Vote Tally.

 

Timer.

 

gxnesis (8) - Badboiami, bestfiction, Dessy, Dibbles, KatyCatPH, levi_valvi, mokitsu, Pendulum

Ecstasy (5) - Alpha, that G.U.Y., Hug, Red Light, Unoriginal

KatyCatPH (4) - Dolce Vita, Ecstasy, gxnesis, jamesfog

Dessy (2) - Opium, paulyyyozd

No Lynch (2) - PoKiTaurus, Satan

Dolce Vita (1) - Caprice

levi_valvi (1) - HotHeaven

 

Yet to vote (2) - URBAN, Vigoorian King.

9 hours ago, URBAN said:

**** it, Lynch gxnesis.

 

I ain't got time to read all that ****.

gxnesis - 9

 

9 hours ago, levi_valvi said:

I see your point though. I also am not completely sure why dessy is so sure that gxnesis is a flop, it seemed like he just had some otherworldly epiphany  

I just saw this. Frankly,I felt there was a chance that gxnesis could have been a low-level Star. But looking at their votes was telling (and comparing to yourself who had a similar voting history but entirely different progression). I merely believed that KatyCat and Ecstasy were Stars more. 

 

8 hours ago, Ecstasy said:

Well I'm caught up. Not like my vote matters anymore but I lost all confidence in KatyC being a flop so Lynch gxnesis I guess. @Dessy be better be right about this or next time we might end up on the opposite sides

gxnesis - 10 This is a safe spot for a Flop to be, but Ecstasy was the risk today.

 

8 hours ago, Dolce Vita said:

Lynch gxnesis. 

gxnesis - 11

 

8 hours ago, Unoriginal said:

@levi_valvi has now made some points...

 

But for now I'm going to change my vote to lynch gxnesis

8 hours ago, HotHeaven said:

am I the only one who is witnessing this SUDDEN change of votes led by Dessy at 1 hour until the votes are cast? 

This is all really ****ing sudden at the very last minute. I'm going to change my vote to No Lynch . geneix is a goner and I dont really believe in this last minute vote on him, I refuse to partake in this. But bet your ass @Dessy and to everyone who jumped ship with Dessy if geneix turns out star, I will whoop your ass. 

HotHeaven have been naturally skeptical. 

 

8 hours ago, Unoriginal said:

No I'm conflicted I'm going to go no lynch and leave it at that 

8 hours ago, URBAN said:

You know what, no lynch for me either.

 

I'm new to this, so I gotta get a grasp on this and can't really read up on it since I'm at work.

 

Ya'll wigs are safe for now.

Some would probably think "wow look at them NOT voting for a flop" in hindsight but idk. If they did kept their votes on gxnesis, it wouldn't have changed much feelings on them since they were late to it anyway.

 

8 hours ago, that G.U.Y. said:

I kinda want to switch to gxnesis but im sticking with @Ecstasy because they didnt even try to defend xirself and suddenly @Dessy made a weak argument for gxnesis and the votes filled up quickly.

 

And if i die this coming night yall better lynch one of them ASAP

that GUY wasn't feeling it, but again their vote wouldn't had matter at this point. HOWEVER, if it was a Flop they wouldn't be trying to throw dirt on the two towniest players that would've resulted from the flip. This actually look better for that GUY. 

 

8 hours ago, Vigoorian King said:

What Dessy says seems to make sense, so lynch gxnesis. Even tho I'm not completely sure if that's the right decision 

gxnesis - 11 and then the flip:

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

[that G.U.Y.]

@Dessy im actually important to the stars and i wanted to be connected asap.

 

Im guessing Madonna found you and statistically you probably arent Azealia

[Dessy]

8 hours ago, Jan said:

Votes:

gxnesis (11) - Badboiami, bestfiction, Dessy, Dibbles, Dolce Vita, Ecstasy, KatyCatPH, levi_valvi, mokitsu, Pendulum, Vigoorian King

No Lynch (5) - HotHeaven, PoKiTaurus, Satan, Unoriginal, URBAN

Ecstasy (4) - Alpha, that G.U.Y., Hug, Red Light

Dessy (2) - Opium, paulyyyozd

KatyCatPH (2) - gxnesis, jamesfog

Dolce Vita (1) - Caprice

So I'm adding in my current reads:

blue is townread

Purple is light town

Orange is lean Flop

Red is Floppy

Underlined are persons I find to be of interest, may or may not have a read on them

 

So I would look at the players in this order: 

 

URBAN - basically disappeared for a bit and came back when it didn't matter

Alpha - There have to be a flop left on Ecstasy

Red Light - See above

Opium - Tunneling on me, really. This is an all-too-common occurrence in this game but in my experience mafia do this more so they can pretend to target someone. Easier still if the person have been acting suspicious like many believed I was initially. 

Dibbles - Was the tipping vote for gxnesis wagon but made it seems like they did not care for it. 

bestfiction - Easy jump-on vote at the beginning. But have the most reason to be a flop out of these people. 

 

 This is basically my Process of Elimination at the moment. I could be wrong - likely since 5 Flops and 1 3P out of 25 people is already hard enough. 

[Dessy]

7 minutes ago, that G.U.Y. said:

@Dessy im actually important to the stars and i wanted to be connected asap.

 

Im guessing Madonna found you and statistically you probably arent Azealia

What you mean by connected?  

 

 

[that G.U.Y.]

1 minute ago, Dessy said:

What you mean by connected?  

 

 

 

Know who to tell my valuable inFormation

[Dessy]

1 minute ago, that G.U.Y. said:

 

Know who to tell my valuable inFormation

Sis don't be hinting at this stage of the game  

[Dessy]

On 3/25/2018 at 2:25 PM, Jan said:

ATRL Mafia: Stars vs. Flops: Vote Tally.

 

22 hours 30 minutes left until end of Day One. Timer.

 

Dessy (8) - Alpha, gxnesis, Hug, KatyCatPH, levi_valvi, mokitsu, Opium, Pendulum

No Lynch (4) - Badboiami, Dibbles, Dolce Vita, that G.U.Y

Badboiami (2) - Caprice, Dessy

Hug (1) - Ecstasy

 

Yet to vote (11) - bestfiction, HotHeaven, jamesfog, Latinazza, Pacaveli, paulyyyozd, PoKiTaurus, Queen Conchita, Red Light, Satan, Unoriginal.

 

Please do check if the tallies are correct. I may sometimes miss something.

Yeah this doesn't look great for Alpha. 

[Dessy]

On 3/25/2018 at 0:55 PM, Alpha said:

Dessy is doing way too much, he probably got a good card. We shall find out  Lynch Dessy

 

12 hours ago, Alpha said:

Lynching inactives is just as dumb as 'No Lynch' it will both help the mafia. Lynch Ecstasy