Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

ATRL

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.
Login issues

Was Donna Summer the first MPG?

Was Donna Summer the first MPG 81 members have voted

  1. 1. Was Donna Summer the first MPG?

    • No, we don't care about anything pre Madonna
      16%
      13
    • No, someone else
      28%
      23
    • Well, yes
      55%
      45

Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Featured Replies

  • Popular Post

Before Donna Summer no female solo artists saw this much success with their albums and singles simultaneously. Bad girls is low key the first main pop girl album/era. 

She performed at the Oscars and won Grammys. Chartmasters has Bad Girls at over 20m units. Really seems like the best example of a MPG moment pre-Madonna.

She scored 3 consecutive #1 albums on the Billboard 200 in 60 weeks 

Live and more(1978) #1 - 1 week

Bad girls(1979) #1  - 6 weeks 

On the Radio: Greatest Hits Volumes I & II(1979)- 1 week

8 consecutive top 5 singles on Hot 100

Last Dance(1978) #3 

MacArthuer Park(1978) #1 

Heaven knows(1979) #4

Hot Stuff(1979) #1 

Bad Girls(1979) #1 

Dim all the lights(1979) #2 

No more tears is enough(1979) #1

On the radio(1980) #5 

Get into Donna Summer if you haven't or aren't familiar with her yet. She is THE Queen of disco.

330px-Donna_Summer_%281980_ABC_special_%

  • Replies 84
  • Views 3.1k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • It was Diana Ross.

  • makeawish
    makeawish

    also we need to discuss MJG (main jazz girls) - billie holiday, nina simone, peggy lee, ella fiztgerald etc - the ATRLification of the 1950s needs to happen

  • I'd say one of the first, along with Dionne, Diana, Barbra, and Cher (in terms of what we think of when we think of an MPG), but she probably is the one who fares the best when it comes to both albums

Wasn't it Lena Horne?

edit:

AH- success-wise. Then Aretha Franklin maybe?

Edited by Taylor fanboy

Yes, that was massive success, especially for a female artist in the 70s. Maybe Olivia Newton John, but I'm not quite sure who came first?

Both were far bigger than Cher. Cher's career was mainly misses, with a few hits.

  • Popular Post

I'd say one of the first, along with Dionne, Diana, Barbra, and Cher (in terms of what we think of when we think of an MPG), but she probably is the one who fares the best when it comes to both albums and singles.

EDIT: Oh yeah, you could probably make a strong case for Olivia too. And Aretha if we're not limiting ourselves to just "pop."

Edited by conatus

I think it was Diana, and you also had Barbra and Olivia, but Donna was definitely one of them

1 minute ago, Killah said:

img_5413.jpeg

Diana is a strong contender. But there were big names before Diana too such as Connie Francis in the 50s/early 60s who was massive and is one best selling artists of all time and the first female artist to have a #1 single.

If we're talking about our contemporary concept of pop star it would be Diana or Donna. But Donna had more consistent success.

Barbra, Cher, Diana, and Donna all kinda became successful around the same time as each other (early 1970s). Except Cher and Diana had success in the 60s as part of Sonny & Cher and The Supremes. And Barbra had a top 5 hit, sold a ton of records, and won an Oscar in the 60s; she just didn't start properly racking up hits until the 70s.

3 minutes ago, Tropez said:

Diana is a strong contender. But there were big names before Diana too such as Connie Francis in the 50s/early 60s who was massive and is one best selling artists of all time and the first female artist to have a #1 single.

If we're talking about our contemporary concept of pop star it would be Diana or Donna. But Donna had more consistent success.

but you're undervaluing the huge success of The Supremes...

which literally were like the blueprint for the girlgroup...

Edited by Killah

Barbra, Cher, Diana, Donna, Debbie Harry, Stevie Nicks etc etc were all MPGs long before the 1980s.

I'd say Diana Ross or Cher were. Donna definitely played a role in shaping the modern music landscape though and Bad Girls was arguably the first female album era as we know it today. Unfortunately, her biggest success was pre-MTV and she was heavily associated with the disco era. It's always felt like a lot of her success and impact was forgotten because of the time period she dominated in.

It also didn't help that she pissed off the gays with her "alleged" AIDS comments.

if there's one before diana ross and cher i'd say ronnie spector, it definitely goes back to the 60s tho (also, could joni or carole king be MPGs? discuss)

11 minutes ago, DaphneGuinness said:

Also Cher practically invented "eras"

As in she didn't at all? You could make that case for Olivia and Diana, who changed for several eras. Blondie created the first album with music videos for every track. Cher released albums, and most of them were flops, with a couple of big successes and a few that were minor successes. She did not create eras. But the ignorance is no surprise as it's par for the course from a particular base.

Edited by ____Summer

16 minutes ago, Killah said:

but you're undervaluing the huge success of The Supremes...

which literally were like the blueprint for the girlgroup...

Yeah, and that's why I said she's a strong contender but Donna was more consistent. You're also undervaluing how much Donna did. Like writing much of her songs, releasing innovative music, having distinct music eras where one album was conceptually different from the last, and reinventing her image.

  • Popular Post

also we need to discuss MJG (main jazz girls) - billie holiday, nina simone, peggy lee, ella fiztgerald etc - the ATRLification of the 1950s needs to happen

Objectively, no. The ones that came before were already named.

She is, however, the first truly great MPG, if we ignore The Supremes for not being a solo act.

Donna was the first singer I was into. I saw her in my parents album collection. They had her greatest hits album (On the Radio), Bad Girls, and The Wanderer. I loved all three!

Edited by ____Summer

not sure if Brenda Lee was mentioned . she was huge for a few years in the 60's. she comes back every year at Christmas. also two uk females singers Petula Clark and Dusty Springfield had success in the 60's.

41 minutes ago, MP3 said:

we don't care about anything pre Madonna

zendaya

I hope this is a joke! Because otherwise that is your loss, particularly with Donna Summer! Her discography is incredible.

Her music STILL sounds fresh nearly 50 years later and I can't even imagine how cool it sounded to people in the 70s-80s. A lot of the modern pop girls are her daughters without even realizing it.

dare I say Donna was making ALBUMS while the others listed were trying to pump out radio hits

her discography (up until 1990) stood the test of time beautifully (and Crayons is actually underrated)

Pour one out for her last official single and #1 on the dance chart

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.