I'll admit, I've stated that she hasn't generated controversy, but maybe I stand corrected.

Which moment in recent years was the most controversial? If it's not listed, please say it in the comments.

the shirt is the only valid ‘controversial’ thing here lol.

• renaissance album and tour was a massive success, nobody care about the # of songwriters.

• we forced to sit and work around strangers all the time so

• she openly endorsed biden in 2020 and harris in 2024, attended a rally, and both album acts tapped into politics and the culture.

• the hive is an affluent fanbase. we can afford it and it sold out.

4 minutes ago, Devin said:

• the hive is an affluent fanbase. we can afford it and it sold out.

The way I will bend myself left, right, and sideways to defend The Variant of a Showgirl, but I don't resort to this logic.

Edited September 12Sep 12 by DevilsRollTheDice

But anyway I agree that none of these are real controversies. People always have to manufacture outrage. We also know where Bey stands politically. I wish everyone could just sort of put down their weapons on that sort of thing in stan wars unless it's someone like Nicki/P!nk, obviously.

I'd say the online outrage was probably worst at Ivanka. The box is a kii.

Edited September 12Sep 12 by DevilsRollTheDice

Y'all making her the villain behind Diddy's ****.

In real life her biggest controversy is the missing visuals

all of these are a bunch of nothing burgers. if I had to pick, I'm choosing the renny writing credits, as it's a talking point I still see regurgitated by (unintelligent) people to chip away at her artistic credibility

8 minutes ago, Devin said:

the shirt is the only valid 'controversial' thing here lol.

• renaissance album and tour was a massive success, nobody care about the # of songwriters.

• we forced to sit and work around strangers all the time so

• she openly endorsed biden in 2020 and harris in 2024, attended a rally, and both album acts tapped into politics and the culture.

• the hive is an affluent fanbase. we can afford it and it sold out.

the only real problem with the songwriting for love drought is when the lady said she wrote it as talking to her label like I know bey was like "yeah gurl that's crazy"

the fact that these are her biggest "controversies" and it's things only ATLRers and stan twitter would even know about

1 minute ago, Sheep said:

In real life her biggest controversy is the missing visuals

i want them in a movie, maybe IMAX if it's jordan peele who really directed it and they're only in real IMAX cameras

4 minutes ago, DevilsRollTheDice said:

The way I will bend myself left, right, and sideways to defend The Variant of a Showgirl, but I don't resort to this.

your fave is far worse.

2 minutes ago, Devin said:

your fave is far worse.

now gurl pllay nice they were gonna agree with you

Was the casino on Indigenous land?

Just now, needs said:

Was the casino on Indigenous land?

No but because you have dinner with Trump apparently means you agree with his policies

Just now, Cherish said:

No but because you have dinner with Trump apparently means you agree with his policies

Right . I was just curious for context

2 minutes ago, Devin said:

your fave is far worse.

I've recently learned that's just evidence of affluence.

1 minute ago, Cherish said:

now gurl pllay nice they were gonna agree with you

nothing like a good friday banter.

Just now, needs said:

Right . I was just curious for context

Oh, that wasn't a dig at you, I could tell you were curious! For anyone else.

The conspiracy theories of her being tied to Diddy and knowing about Aaliyah's death are known by more than a small subsection of the internet it feels like. People still even bring up the "fake" pregnancy

3 minutes ago, alejandreaux said:

the fact that these are her biggest "controversies" and it's things only ATLRers and stan twitter would even know about

But I thought she was a controversial and highly politically polarizing figure?

I guess I was correct in saying that she's not, after all.

The worst thing is the thing that has the least to do with her (Diddy).

lmao, none. The biggest controversy is the lack of visuals and lying about the 4K Bday videos...

Lobbying for a casino by dining with the Trump family and associates is the worst because it's the only one that exists outside Twitter.

Edited September 12Sep 12 by gustavothehuman

Using Selena Quintenilla Como La Flor song apparently is the newest uproar