Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

ATRL

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (โ‹ฎ) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.
Login issues

Has Ariana Grande quietly become a legacy act?

Featured Replies

19 minutes ago, chicbitch said:

That's why I compared her more to Beyoncรฉ/Gaga.. still completely capable of having current success, but established enough that they don't need to dominate every pop conversation to remain major figures.

that's not what legacy act means rip

  • Replies 50
  • Views 2.3k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • Truth Teller
    Truth Teller

    She just had one of the biggest and longest hits of her career with her previous album and a huge cultural moment with Wicked, so no. Even the new era which has been very muted, for reasons we might a

  • HonourableVomit
    HonourableVomit

    why are you always trying to redefine and reinterpret terms that have established meanings legacy acts do NOT get hits with new releases, they can only coast off their recurrents ala Katy Perry and Pi

  • No. She isn't reliant on her legacy work to remain relevant since she's still getting hits with her new material. As shown by the fact that HTIMYLM and petal are currently her #1 and #2 most streamed

since I hate that I made you love me is now her longest running top 10 , the facts don't agree with you

1 hour ago, chicbitch said:

I think you misunderstood what I meant a little .. I'm not saying she's unsuccessful or incapable of getting hits. Obviously she can still pull a #1 and Wicked was enormous.

I mean "legacy act" more in the sense that Ariana herself is now bigger than any individual era. At this point she has such an established catalogue, image and cultural presence that a new album doesn't really need to redefine her career or dominate for two years straight anymore.

That's kind of what I meant with Petal feeling a little filler-ish in her overall trajectory despite being a very good album. It can be successful without necessarily feeling like another Dangerous Woman / thank u, next-level chapter that changes how people see Ariana Grande.

That's not a legacy artist is.

A legacy artist is someone whos fans are not interested in new material but just their back catalog. They can tour very easily with huge numbers but struggle to make any impact with new material.

Cher, P!nk, Katy Perry, Shania Twain, Barbra Streisand

1 hour ago, chicbitch said:

I mean "legacy act" more in the sense that Ariana herself is now bigger than any individual era.

So that's not what the term legacy act means.

I get what you're saying but I think she's just in the sweet spot of having a 13+ year career under her belt while still releasing hits and opening with big numbers

she might be past peak but she literally had the #1 song on the global 200 for three weeks this year, it's hardly giving cher

Edited by makeawish

Legacy acts are artists who barely release new music, rely on their decade old hits and core fanbase so what are you talking about.

She has #1 with her lead and album this year, one of the most streamed artists. Please be frrr.

No, I see a legacy act as someone who doesn't put out new music and is either retired or someone who only performs their greatest hits from a long time ago.

she has one of the biggest songs of the year deadbanana2

her last two albums would have been much bigger if she felt like pushing them but it's not where her priorities are right now

5 hours ago, HonourableVomit said:

Pink

That name be flying throughout this thread but she's sadly scored a hit with her latest album

her recent album is underperforming cause the GP thinks that being overly skinny is shameful and they should not stream the music of people with EDs so they don't encourage other people to have EDs too, yet they refuse to do it for male acts like a literal murderer and rapists like D4vid or Justin or Chris Poopoo Brown.

But one underperformance caused by a misogynistic hate train doesn't mean she's a legacy act. She still manage to get a big hit in her 8th album, 13 years in her career (counting her career from the time she released her debut album). She'll be fine, she just needs to disappear from the public eye for a bit so people start missing her. She is one of the most influential girls in the industry right now and she does have a huge fanbase and a lot of casual listeners, so by the time she's back with her 9th album she'll be fine. Maybe not tu,n/ME success but she'll probably manage to get a hit out of it (unless the music is catastrophic which is never the case for miss Grande, sorry not sorry).

Legacy acts are unable to have hits, even if they try and try
They're likeโ€ฆ they've already left their mark on pop culture-industry, but commercially, they're falling toward the bottom, and people don't care about their new projects as much. Some of them have sparkly times but theyre all in the graveyard. Their time in the mainstream is over.

Ariana is not at that stage. If she decides to drop her new diva/classy persona and go back to her 2010s era, she could have some big smashes again. She's far from being a legacy act. Maybe in one decade-two decades. She's a current main popgirl. She's just facin a random cancellation era.


Edited by AvadaKedavra

7 hours ago, chicbitch said:

My point is that Ariana has reached a stage where the career itself is bigger than the current pop cycle. She can still chart and have huge hits, but her status no longer depends on every era being culturally dominant. Her name, catalogue and past eras already carry enough weight on their own.

That's why I compared her more to Beyoncรฉ/Gaga.. still completely capable of having current success, but established enough that they don't need to dominate every pop conversation to remain major figures.

That's not what a legacy act is, which is why you're getting corrected. A legacy act is an artist who has no current relevancy except for that of their legacy. Think of Rod Stewart. Nobody is going to check for something new from him, but he'll forever be relevant for the career he already had.

You can argue that Ariana is an act with a legacy, but she is NOT a legacy act.

  • Author
8 hours ago, HonourableVomit said:

you might be like 16 years old and not know why the term was coined but pop culture vocabulary terms exist to describe observable phenomena and not theoretical ones you reach by interpreting the words literally

will you call Sabrina Carpenter a "nostalgia act" because people feel nostalgia when they hear Espresso? ridiculous

every single artist new or old is judged in the context of what work they have done or not done previously

But that's not really analogous. "Nostalgia act" would be me inventing a category from the literal meaning of a word; "legacy act" is already used to describe a career stage, and career stages are obviously transitional rather than some switch that flips the second an artist stops getting hits.

And yes, every artist is viewed in context of their previous work. The difference is that not every artist has a previous body of work substantial enough to sustain their status independently of the current cycle.

That's why I don't buy "legacy acts do NOT get new hits" as some hard rule. A legacy is a career position, not commercial death. You can have an established catalogue/status that exists independently of the current cycle and still occasionally smash within it.

That overlap is literally what I'm arguing Ariana is beginning to enter.

  • Author
2 hours ago, AvadaKedavra said:

Legacy acts are unable to have hits, even if they try and try
They're likeโ€ฆ they've already left their mark on pop culture-industry, but commercially, they're falling toward the bottom, and people don't care about their new projects as much. Some of them have sparkly times but theyre all in the graveyard. Their time in the mainstream is over.

Ariana is not at that stage. If she decides to drop her new diva/classy persona and go back to her 2010s era, she could have some big smashes again. She's far from being a legacy act. Maybe in one decade-two decades. She's a current main popgirl. She's just facin a random cancellation era.

I actually think Gaga and Ariana are interesting counterexamples to this though. Both have already built careers substantial enough to be discussed in terms of legacy, yet both can still produce very current hits.

There's clearly this newer middle stage where an artist's legacy is already cemented and they're still commercially viable. Ariana feels firmly in that space to me.

  • Author
1 hour ago, Eternium said:

That's not what a legacy act is, which is why you're getting corrected. A legacy act is an artist who has no current relevancy except for that of their legacy. Think of Rod Stewart. Nobody is going to check for something new from him, but he'll forever be relevant for the career he already had.

You can argue that Ariana is an act with a legacy, but she is NOT a legacy act.

"Act with a legacy" is probably technically cleaner. My broader point is just that she no longer needs each new era to establish or protect her place in pop, that part is already done.

4 hours ago, howboutdat said:

That name be flying throughout this thread but she's sadly scored a hit with her latest album

Pink is usually flying anyway.

pink-2-070224-a5d276baf5464f0c803989071e

This thread reads as a purposeful misinterpretation of a very well established term to jump on a hate train and be shady and the doubling down when called out and corrected on the definition kinda proves it rip

Edited by Relampago.

  • Author
42 minutes ago, Relampago. said:

This thread reads as a purposeful misinterpretation of a very well established term to jump on a hate train and be shady and the doubling down when called out and corrected on the definition kinda proves it rip

But is she not a legacy act? You can disagree with the wording, but acting like the entire premise is secretly a hate campaign because I used "legacy act" more broadly is a little dramatic.

I've already clarified what I mean several times. At this point we're arguing semantics more than Ariana.

I get what you mean. She's established. The longevity is there. She doesn't have to heavily rely on promo (and is at a point in her career where she can choose whether or not she does promo and choose when she wants to release new music). She can tour whenever she wants, and the numbers are there.

7 hours ago, chicbitch said:

"Act with a legacy" is probably technically cleaner. My broader point is just that she no longer needs each new era to establish or protect her place in pop, that part is already done.

The term you're looking for is "established." And yes, Ariana has been an established act since TUN, at the very least.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions โ†’ Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.