Who has the superior discography?

charli sweetie....

Tinashe has Songs for You, 333, and BB Angel, and I bet Popstar is gonna gag too, so her

Charli has Pop 2 and Brat but T has been more consistent I fear

I'm sorry but Tinashe is so far ahead of everyone else this century it isn't fair. 333 & Songs For You alone hard carry, but BB/ANG3L and Quantum Baby are heavy hitters too

They're both really great, but I think Charli has more memorable/better songs in her discog.

it's charli babyyyy

Nope, literally impossible.

8 minutes ago, SlimyGhoul said:

They're both really great, but I think Charli has more memorable/better songs in her discog.

I mean we gotta admit. Charli's success helps with the memorability of her songs as well.

Tinashe, Charli gets carried by her producers and Noonie Bao

Edited August 11Aug 11 by playboi

The disrespect towards tinashe, omg

Love both and truly listen to both discography very often but gotta give it to my queen.

Both have excellent highs, but Charli has more lows

I definitely revisit Tinashe's more. I love Charli's albums on release but they kind of age quickly for me

3 minutes ago, playboi said:

Tinashe, Charli gets carried by her producers and Noonie Bao

The question was "who has the better discography", who carried what shouldn't be relevant to the question of what music is better quality. Catalogue vs catalogue - it's Charli & it's not even close. This site is wild. People in this thread talking about charli's lows are lower like Tinashe didn't release Joyride

Edited August 11Aug 11 by LoveInStereo

I don't do ket so Tinashe

Edited August 11Aug 11 by sk8erfan

Tinashe. Half of Charli's discography is crap

Hard one but Charli, she has higher highs imo.

Tinashe doesn't have an album better than Brat but at the same time she has a lot of good albums as well. This is hard and I'm going to say they're about even.

Love them both but I personally listen to more Charli than Tinashe even tho the gap is close. Love me some N1A and Nightride

Love Nashe but she has albums that are very similar sonically. I believe Charli's versatility makes her discography to stand out more. Both absolute queens of quality

14 minutes ago, LoveInStereo said:

The question was "who has the better discography", who carried what shouldn't be relevant to the question of what music is better quality. Catalogue vs catalogue - it's Charli & it's not even close. This site is wild. People in this thread talking about charli's lows are lower like Tinashe didn't release Joyride

I know but I wanted to shake the table

27 minutes ago, Indie Go Mind said:

I mean we gotta admit. Charli's success helps with the memorability of her songs as well.

Ohhh no no no, I've loved Charli's music since like 2015 lol her recent success has nothing to do with it (for me anyways)

51 minutes ago, PoisonedIvy said:

I'm sorry but Tinashe is so far ahead of everyone else this century it isn't fair. 333 & Songs For You alone hard carry, but BB/ANG3L and Quantum Baby are heavy hitters too

Hot and has taste. Yep!

Tinashe

love charli but i mean look at the material