June 29Jun 29 comment_29525016 I would think that queer people would understand the necessity of social media and online communities to discover one's identity outside of your immediate reality, but I guess not Children are really viewed and treated as second-class citizen Link to comment https://atrl.net/forums/topic/537583-democrats-project-2029-first-proposal-online-censorship/page/2/#findComment-29525016 Share on other sites Share on Bluesky Share on X Share on Facebook {lang="reddit_text" Share on Pinterest More sharing options... Share this post
June 29Jun 29 comment_29525020 1 minute ago, Démodé said:wake up and clock that tea!"Bbbbbut spcial media is evil and children need protection 🥺" This will make it into the top 5 stupidest things people said before full government surveillance on the internet. Link to comment https://atrl.net/forums/topic/537583-democrats-project-2029-first-proposal-online-censorship/page/2/#findComment-29525020 Share on other sites Share on Bluesky Share on X Share on Facebook {lang="reddit_text" Share on Pinterest More sharing options... Share this post
June 29Jun 29 comment_29525022 Just now, jesus del rey said:"Bbbbbut spcial media is evil and children need protection 🥺" This will make it into the top 5 stupidest things people said before full government surveillance on the internet."think of the children" is almost always, always, a red flag in a discourse. Link to comment https://atrl.net/forums/topic/537583-democrats-project-2029-first-proposal-online-censorship/page/2/#findComment-29525022 Share on other sites Share on Bluesky Share on X Share on Facebook {lang="reddit_text" Share on Pinterest More sharing options... Share this post
June 29Jun 29 comment_29525024 30 minutes ago, Démodé said:Some of you are extremely quick to cheer for a terrible idea.Online spaces are harmful af, yes, but they can also be very helpful to minorities to form safe communities. There have been enough indications that LGBTQ+ (especially T) people who live away from urban areas can find escape routes on fringes of social media.Censorship always mathermatically leads to escalation of violence and hate speech.Please stop blindly supporting Democrats; their only proposal is that they're not GOP.Every policy decision has winners and losers. Its about the balance of harms. I am absolutely sure that as a result of this policy there would be extreme cases of harm. But on balance, for society as a whole, I think its the right thing. Link to comment https://atrl.net/forums/topic/537583-democrats-project-2029-first-proposal-online-censorship/page/2/#findComment-29525024 Share on other sites Share on Bluesky Share on X Share on Facebook {lang="reddit_text" Share on Pinterest More sharing options... Share this post
June 29Jun 29 comment_29525025 gays of all people gleefully asking for more government surveillance and censorship always makes me Link to comment https://atrl.net/forums/topic/537583-democrats-project-2029-first-proposal-online-censorship/page/2/#findComment-29525025 Share on other sites Share on Bluesky Share on X Share on Facebook {lang="reddit_text" Share on Pinterest More sharing options... Share this post
June 29Jun 29 comment_29525028 Just now, CallumDavies said:Every policy decision has winners and losers. Its about the balance of harms. I am absolutely sure that as a result of this policy there would be extreme cases of harm. But on balance, for society as a whole, I think its the right thing.let's agree to disagre. Link to comment https://atrl.net/forums/topic/537583-democrats-project-2029-first-proposal-online-censorship/page/2/#findComment-29525028 Share on other sites Share on Bluesky Share on X Share on Facebook {lang="reddit_text" Share on Pinterest More sharing options... Share this post
June 29Jun 29 comment_29525043 2 minutes ago, Démodé said:let's agree to disagre. I mean sure... I wasn't trying to convince you though Link to comment https://atrl.net/forums/topic/537583-democrats-project-2029-first-proposal-online-censorship/page/2/#findComment-29525043 Share on other sites Share on Bluesky Share on X Share on Facebook {lang="reddit_text" Share on Pinterest More sharing options... Share this post
June 29Jun 29 comment_29525044 41 minutes ago, DevilsRollTheDice said:Presenting this genuinely great idea-Just for context, however people feel about this is irrelevant when the elephant in the room is that tons of Democrats joined Republicans in claiming TikTok must be a shady Chinese spay app because Chinese utilized the exact same youth regulations that are now being explored here. --China leads, America follows Link to comment https://atrl.net/forums/topic/537583-democrats-project-2029-first-proposal-online-censorship/page/2/#findComment-29525044 Share on other sites Share on Bluesky Share on X Share on Facebook {lang="reddit_text" Share on Pinterest More sharing options... Share this post
June 29Jun 29 Author comment_29525058 48 minutes ago, KatyPrismSpirit said:Online censorship* for children below age 16 yes.Children are incredibly vulnerable online and are often exposed to dangerous content that can cause harm. Examples include bullying, pedophilia, radical right wing/Islamic rhetoric.I fully agree that we should not allow kids below age 16 on public social media platforms. WhatsApp or something okay, but looking back at my time as a teen, many of my girlfriends were definitely in dangerous situations because of their online presence. Grown ass men hitting on them and eventually meeting with them / taking advantage. Its a serious thing.44 minutes ago, DevilsRollTheDice said:Presenting this genuinely great idea as a bad thing is sending me It is the damn phones. Children are especially vulnerable to all the terrible things online from alt-right pipelines to grooming to insane conspiracies to all kinds of mis and disinformation. I'd be fine with social media going away entirely. Definitely a net negative for the world. But it should certainly be taken away from people with developing minds. We'll look back on many aspects of the internet like cigarettes except maybe worse because we allowed literal children to take part.Imagine living in this delusional world thinking that the American government whom has protected Epstein, doesn't provide free school lunch, let alone health care, is thinking about the children. This is obviously an attempt to remove anonymity on the internet. Peter Thiel, The Heritage Foundation all support this btw! You should question why you are on the same side as those two. Link to comment https://atrl.net/forums/topic/537583-democrats-project-2029-first-proposal-online-censorship/page/2/#findComment-29525058 Share on other sites Share on Bluesky Share on X Share on Facebook {lang="reddit_text" Share on Pinterest More sharing options... Share this post
June 29Jun 29 comment_29525073 I agree with the sentiment but I don't know if this is the right way to go about it. I think there be a stronger focus on reducing overall screen time in children (which in my opinion, is the more important issue that includes but is larger than just social media).If this just means we all suffer less privacy, but kids' brains are still getting fried on TV, games, etc. because parents still let them have their iPads... then it's kinda pointless IMO.I think Australia tried something like this recently and it's kinda flopping. Like the kids just immediately found a way around it. Link to comment https://atrl.net/forums/topic/537583-democrats-project-2029-first-proposal-online-censorship/page/2/#findComment-29525073 Share on other sites Share on Bluesky Share on X Share on Facebook {lang="reddit_text" Share on Pinterest More sharing options... Share this post
June 29Jun 29 comment_29525078 3 minutes ago, Cesar said:Imagine living in this delusional world thinking that the American government whom has protected Epstein, doesn't provide free school lunch, let alone health care, is thinking about the children. This is obviously an attempt to remove anonymity on the internet. Peter Thiel, The Heritage Foundation all support this btw! You should question why you are on the same side as those two.It's not just America who has protocols like this tho? Similar social media restrictions for < 16 year olds have been implemented in Australia and will likely be enforced in the UK and the rest of Europe soon as well. Link to comment https://atrl.net/forums/topic/537583-democrats-project-2029-first-proposal-online-censorship/page/2/#findComment-29525078 Share on other sites Share on Bluesky Share on X Share on Facebook {lang="reddit_text" Share on Pinterest More sharing options... Share this post
June 29Jun 29 comment_29525112 12 minutes ago, Cesar said:Imagine living in this delusional world thinking that the American government whom has protected Epstein, doesn't provide free school lunch, let alone health care, is thinking about the children. This is obviously an attempt to remove anonymity on the internet. Peter Thiel, The Heritage Foundation all support this btw! You should question why you are on the same side as those two.ATRL user Cesar Link to comment https://atrl.net/forums/topic/537583-democrats-project-2029-first-proposal-online-censorship/page/2/#findComment-29525112 Share on other sites Share on Bluesky Share on X Share on Facebook {lang="reddit_text" Share on Pinterest More sharing options... Share this post
June 29Jun 29 comment_29525130 Europe's social media ban debate risks silencing the very...By the time governments propose to ban social media access for young people, they have already lost the argument.The impact would be even greater on those already most excluded. For LGBTQIA+ young people, for those with disabilities, those residing in rural areas and refugees, social media can provide safe spaces and support networks that a ban would eliminate.https://www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/entry/social-media-ban-lgbtq-youth-impact_uk_6a2fcd95e4b07679090ddb18Experts have expressed concern about how a social media ban could alienate young people who identify as LGBTQ+, especially as research has established that access to the internet and social media is "vital" for this group.The University of BrightonLGBTQ Youth Cultures and Social MediaResearch has established that access to the Internet and social media is vital for many lesbian, gay, bi, trans, queer + (LGBTQ+) young people (Hillier and Harrison, 2007; Selkie et al., 2020). LGBTQ+ social media youth cultures form across platforms and are shaped by a range of media affordances and vernaculars. LGBTQ+ youth use social media for self-expression, connecting with other LGBTQ+ young people, entertainment, activism, as well as for collecting and curating information.Three radical left (lol) sources who bring valid criticism on Social Media Bans for Minors. Link to comment https://atrl.net/forums/topic/537583-democrats-project-2029-first-proposal-online-censorship/page/2/#findComment-29525130 Share on other sites Share on Bluesky Share on X Share on Facebook {lang="reddit_text" Share on Pinterest More sharing options... Share this post
June 29Jun 29 comment_29525156 From what I see, the drawback here is that the US will do as it always does - a half-measure that doesn't actually meaningfully address behaviors.What make the Douyin restrictions interesting within China is that - despite the fear-mongering about content censorship - much more focus is spent on access to technology at large than access to specific content. ie: children under certain ages can only use Douyin at all for a limited # of hours.Such kind of regulations (people under the age of 14 can only use TikTok for up to an hour a day, only have access from 10 AM to 6 PM) would probably be extremely effective within the context of the US. But such regulations would only be accepted in a society where there is a consensus the government has a structural responsibility to manage social cohesion for the. greater good.Unlike China, the US has probably millions of citizens who have enough weaponry to launch a civil war and would likely do so if you told them you're restricting how many hours their 11-year-old is allowed to Xbox within a certain day.Content moderation is far more futile of an exploration in a society that simply does not also believe the government has not just the responsibility to shape what people consume but shape how people consume. In fact, we saw the exact opposite in the US: the US government allowed such deregulation of online content that they allowed a billionaire to buy the main social media platform and turn it into a mass propaganda arm that he personally decided.The text is even worse and seemingly does the typically American thing of deciding the actual lever of accountability is.... civil lawsuits. Among other items, the group wants to clarify that companies aren't protected from lawsuits stemming from AI-generated content, paid ads, illegal content or activity, and platforms that promote stalking or other nonconsensual behavior.Always focused on the wrong pain points and always not going too far enough on where the actual issue is. Shocking! Link to comment https://atrl.net/forums/topic/537583-democrats-project-2029-first-proposal-online-censorship/page/2/#findComment-29525156 Share on other sites Share on Bluesky Share on X Share on Facebook {lang="reddit_text" Share on Pinterest More sharing options... Share this post
June 29Jun 29 comment_29525169 37 minutes ago, jesus del rey said:Studies that show a significant effect of social media on youth mental health only show a very limited effect size. You know what has the biggest effect size? Socioeconomic position. But I guess it is easier to focus on government surveillance than actul things that empower people.This is just a lie. Many studies have shown negative effects of social media use on children and adolescents and that data is becoming stronger over time. Link to comment https://atrl.net/forums/topic/537583-democrats-project-2029-first-proposal-online-censorship/page/2/#findComment-29525169 Share on other sites Share on Bluesky Share on X Share on Facebook {lang="reddit_text" Share on Pinterest More sharing options... Share this post
June 29Jun 29 comment_29525170 12 minutes ago, KatyPrismSpirit said:It's not just America who has protocols like this tho? Similar social media restrictions for < 16 year olds have been implemented in Australia and will likely be enforced in the UK and the rest of Europe soon as well.How does that make it better though? Are you really about to argue that this coordinated political effort is not driven by conservatism and reactionary ideology? Just because leftist are following those ideas doesn't mean they didn't originate from the right. No one is saying social media can't be dangerous, but the goal should be to make them better, not to ban them. Link to comment https://atrl.net/forums/topic/537583-democrats-project-2029-first-proposal-online-censorship/page/2/#findComment-29525170 Share on other sites Share on Bluesky Share on X Share on Facebook {lang="reddit_text" Share on Pinterest More sharing options... Share this post
June 29Jun 29 comment_29525180 I should also say that while I don't completely write off the idea of much, MUCH tighter restrictions for youths on social media , I also don't support watering down, weakening or repealing Section 230 of the Comms Act to achieve any of this. All the efforts to repeal Section 230 reek of governments trying to enact even more state sanctioned surveillance, as many other members have pointed out. Link to comment https://atrl.net/forums/topic/537583-democrats-project-2029-first-proposal-online-censorship/page/2/#findComment-29525180 Share on other sites Share on Bluesky Share on X Share on Facebook {lang="reddit_text" Share on Pinterest More sharing options... Share this post
June 29Jun 29 comment_29525183 Just now, DevilsRollTheDice said:This is just a lie. Many studies have shown negative effects of social media use on children and adolescents and that data is becoming stronger over time.Significant effect and effect size are different things. In my post, if you care to read before you dismiss it as a lie, I said that they found a significant effect but the effect size is quite low Also, anyone with any affinity to statistics would know that as long as you have a large population size, most effect will be significant, hence, scientists focus on effect sizes. Link to comment https://atrl.net/forums/topic/537583-democrats-project-2029-first-proposal-online-censorship/page/2/#findComment-29525183 Share on other sites Share on Bluesky Share on X Share on Facebook {lang="reddit_text" Share on Pinterest More sharing options... Share this post
June 29Jun 29 comment_29525207 It's baffling to me how actual scientists who work on developmental psychology and adolescent mental health preach everywhere that the bans on social media are stupid, but yet, people are still going off of politicians who ignore the evidence just to win some votes. Link to comment https://atrl.net/forums/topic/537583-democrats-project-2029-first-proposal-online-censorship/page/2/#findComment-29525207 Share on other sites Share on Bluesky Share on X Share on Facebook {lang="reddit_text" Share on Pinterest More sharing options... Share this post
June 29Jun 29 comment_29525217 Only on ATRL will the same users who ****-ride authoritarian states that don't allow any citizen to access the internet without major censorship (or sometimes even at all!) balk at the idea that children might not benefit from unrestricted access to an incredibly predatory and dangerous information environment because Dems suggested it. Edited June 29Jun 29 by DevilsRollTheDice Link to comment https://atrl.net/forums/topic/537583-democrats-project-2029-first-proposal-online-censorship/page/2/#findComment-29525217 Share on other sites Share on Bluesky Share on X Share on Facebook {lang="reddit_text" Share on Pinterest More sharing options... Share this post
June 29Jun 29 comment_29525226 I think yall Americans seriously need to separate science from politics. You can't defend your favorite politicians even though the science says otherwise on important topics like this. Link to comment https://atrl.net/forums/topic/537583-democrats-project-2029-first-proposal-online-censorship/page/2/#findComment-29525226 Share on other sites Share on Bluesky Share on X Share on Facebook {lang="reddit_text" Share on Pinterest More sharing options... Share this post
June 29Jun 29 comment_29525232 3 minutes ago, jesus del rey said:It's baffling to me how actual scientists who work on developmental psychology and adolescent mental health preach everywhere that the bans on social media are stupid, but yet, people are still going off of politicians who ignore the evidence just to win some votes. And here you are heavily misleading again!There is nothing close to academic consensus in the psychology community regarding these bans. Many experts who don't support all out bans also favor heavy and significant regulation. You are making it out like this is some conservative satanic panic when it very obviously is not. As time goes on the data around children and social media is growing more and more concerning. People also scoffed at early whistleblowers on tobacco and some "experts" fought back heavily. Like cigs, this is also something many of us can see plainly with our eyes. But it isn't as though there isn't growing academic data to support it! Link to comment https://atrl.net/forums/topic/537583-democrats-project-2029-first-proposal-online-censorship/page/2/#findComment-29525232 Share on other sites Share on Bluesky Share on X Share on Facebook {lang="reddit_text" Share on Pinterest More sharing options... Share this post
June 29Jun 29 comment_29525236 2 minutes ago, DevilsRollTheDice said:because Dems suggested it.and they wouldn't have, had right-wing groups such as The Heritage Foundation and Morality in Media not pushed this issue so hard talk about dick-riding Link to comment https://atrl.net/forums/topic/537583-democrats-project-2029-first-proposal-online-censorship/page/2/#findComment-29525236 Share on other sites Share on Bluesky Share on X Share on Facebook {lang="reddit_text" Share on Pinterest More sharing options... Share this post
June 29Jun 29 comment_29525242 who needs the republicans when you have.... republicans light right there Link to comment https://atrl.net/forums/topic/537583-democrats-project-2029-first-proposal-online-censorship/page/2/#findComment-29525242 Share on other sites Share on Bluesky Share on X Share on Facebook {lang="reddit_text" Share on Pinterest More sharing options... Share this post
June 29Jun 29 comment_29525244 That user failing to understand, after many back-and-forths, that this isn't about protecting children Really goes to show how gullible people are Link to comment https://atrl.net/forums/topic/537583-democrats-project-2029-first-proposal-online-censorship/page/2/#findComment-29525244 Share on other sites Share on Bluesky Share on X Share on Facebook {lang="reddit_text" Share on Pinterest More sharing options... Share this post
Create an account or sign in to comment