Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

ATRL

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.
Login issues

Eminem vs. Beyoncé: whose legacy will be stronger in 30 years?

Eminem vs. Beyoncé: whose legacy will be stronger in 30 years? 209 members have voted

  1. 1. Eminem vs. Beyoncé: whose legacy will be stronger in 30 years?

    • Beyonce
      58%
      121
    • Eminem
      41%
      86

Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Featured Replies

1 hour ago, Yuanyu said:

You love to praise Beyoncé's legacy whilst belittling Eminem's, but the reality is that we're talking about someone who can manage the entire album cycle himself – composition, production, technical arrangements – compared to someone else who needs a whole army of people just to release music

You can claim I "love" to belittle Eminem but I've not done so. Whereas you have relied on snarky, shady jabs laced with misogyny, I have engaged with the topic and his accomplishments without rudeness or derision.

Edited by swissman

  • Replies 122
  • Views 4.6k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • Funny, Eminem appears on the iFPI list for both 2024 and 2025, something Beyoncé is currently unable to achieve Just because Eminem doesn't go around buying awards doesn't mean people aren't intereste

  • Eminem already feels done & left behind. Beyoncé is hanging in there.

  • Egon Schiele
    Egon Schiele

    I'd say Em, because his career is about the music and it has proven to be timeless. Bey is more about the powerful celeb status, the glam, the power she has in the industry, the music itself is like a

8 hours ago, swissman said:

You can claim I "love" to belittle Eminem but I've not done so. Whereas you have relied on snarky, shady jabs laced with misogyny, I have engaged with the topic and his accomplishments without rudeness or derision.

Can you explain to me where the misogyny is in what I said? I didn't know that saying that Beyoncé has fewer sales and streams and that she doesn't write her songs is misogynistic, especially when they are facts that are easily verifiable.

As a woman, it really bothers me that you use the word "misogynistic" to defend your argument. Honestly, that says more about your lack of ideas than anything else.

12 hours ago, Trent W said:

I stan Beyonce, but I think sadly Eminem will take this one

Bey is like 10x more talented, but we had other black women like her that are definitely remembered but not in the same way that their white male counterparts

Eminem will be remembered as the white guy that revolutionized rap in the 00s and 2010s, and while he is basic compared to Beyonce that is enough for society.

Unless there is a very deep change in society in the next decades it will be this way

I was just about to say that in a better and more fair world, it would undoubtedly be Beyoncé. Unfortunately, this isn't that world.

You white punks on here are so stupid and disrespectful. Most of eminem discography doesn't hold a ******* candle to Beyonce discography. Y'all are out of Y'all mind. And not Y'all trying to make this white male racist who had many disgusting lyrics about raping women a better person than Beyonce. Again you are white punks.

How Is Eminem revolutionary for Rap? Black people are still in Hip hop and successful. The only reason why he even sold the most records is because he was a white guy that actually could rap and wasn't seen as wack like Vanilla Ice was back in the day. Also there are plenty of black male rappers who can out-rap him. He is not the only rapper that can rap fast. Beyonce career will age better. Her whole image is based on perfection and being royalty. People want to be her. Y'all can't erase this Black woman legacy. It's not happening this time and Thank God for social media.

Did you idiots remember what happened to elvis Pressley? Y'all are too confident and bold with the disrespect. I'm leaving this website. I can't deal with Mayo twinks.

This is an interesting comparison and it has a lot of nuance.

They both serve very different audiences. Eminem has a predominantly white male following. Beyoncé has a large women/poc/lgbt audience. They both are living legends.

I do however think Beyoncé will have the stronger legacy in 30 years. She's a pop culture institution. Her biggest strength is that she can still put out albums that spark a cultural conversation that are also critically and commercially successful. I would argue that Eminem hasn't put out anything on that level since the 2000's.

Also the fact that she's an exceptional performer will always be seen with reverence for decades to come. The fact that she still feels so current this deep into her career is such a rare feat that people don't give her credit for.

disingenuous monsters and swifties running in here to defend the white man whose legacy can be boiled down to calling yall 🚬s and stealing from black people lmaooo

the one whose talent doesn't necessarily need to be used to put other artists down. also she's been acclaimed by many of your fav's favs. so. yeah. gayoncecat3

17 hours ago, Pheromosa said:

With the constant and inane comparisons, Beyonce will outlast everyone

rogue2

This. This right here.

I have never seen someone else compared to literally everyone. From dead, to living, old, to new, rappers etc. Beyoncé is just that girl.

I dont have much of an opinion on Em. He's made some good albums (later ones not so much), and has numbers on his side. Kudos for that

This is not really comparable. They both have really strong legacies. Bey has the gays so she wins I fink since we actually care about pop culture unlike GP who are very fickle, but like I said it's not comparable.

For better or worse, Eminem feels completely irrelevant in my bubble so Beyoncé.

"More remembered" is such a dumb take when both are legends.

You cannot look back at the 90s and especially 00s and not mention or think of both of them. Then you have Bey who just completely raised the bar artistically and became one of, if not the best performer of her generation and Eminem still meaning so much to so many (straight, white) men.

Edited by Kristie Kuwa

3 hours ago, blondrin said:

no one outside the usa cares abt or knows eminem

"Eminem is generally considered more successful and widely recognized on a global scale outside the US compared to Beyoncé. With over 224 million equivalent album sales, he is ranked as one of the top-selling artists globally, with intense popularity across Europe, Australia, and Asia, often surpassing Beyoncé in international chart longevity."

Hmmm sherlock

10 hours ago, Yuanyu said:

Can you explain to me where the misogyny is in what I said? I didn't know that saying that Beyoncé has fewer sales and streams and that she doesn't write her songs is misogynistic, especially when they are facts that are easily verifiable.

As a woman, it really bothers me that you use the word "misogynistic" to defend your argument. Honestly, that says more about your lack of ideas than anything else.

Sure.

It was when you said: "Honestly, it's funny hearing that from you, especially when Beyoncé needed her husband to make a Netflix Christmas special just to promote her album after it dropped off the charts in its 28 week"

The idea that Beyoncé "needed her husband" to do anything for her in the music industry, as if the NFL hadn't worked with Beyoncé four times prior before Jay-Z had any say in the matter, and as if Beyoncé is not one of the biggest and most reliable performers in the world, gives her far less power than she deserves credit for, and is a common misogynistic trope that follows a general history of shady remarks that paint Beyoncé as unable to achieve anything if not for her husband's power.

As I stated your jabs were "laced with misogyny", I think my point is valid.

I did not say you were outright being misogynistic, nor did I use misogyny to prove a point. Consequently, I don't think it has anything to do with a "lack of ideas", whatever that means in this context. You made it seem that a powerful, respected and accomplished woman in her own right "needed" a man to come save her and that is laced with misogyny. If you were not playing into this misogynistic narrative, then so be it. I was mistaken in your motive. But intention doesn't necessarily invalidate how something comes across.

And yet again: I said "laced" which means it wasn't total misogyny, but had some of the facets of it.

Edited by swissman

5 hours ago, blondrin said:

no one outside the usa cares abt or knows eminem

It's because of things like this that this forum is wonderful and always will be.

3 minutes ago, swissman said:

Sure.

It was when you said: "Honestly, it's funny hearing that from you, especially when Beyoncé needed her husband to make a Netflix Christmas special just to promote her album after it dropped off the charts in its 28 week"

The idea that Beyoncé "needed her husband" to do anything for her in the music industry, as if the NFL hadn't worked with Beyoncé four times prior before Jay-Z had any say in the matter, and as if Beyoncé is not one of the biggest and most reliable performers in the world, gives her far less power than she deserves credit for, and follows a history of shady remarks that paint Beyoncé as unable to achieve anything if not for her husband's power.

As I stated your jabs were "laced with misogyny", I think my point is valid.

I did not say you were outright being misogynistic, nor did I use misogyny to prove a point. Consequently, I don't think it has anything to do with a "lack of ideas", whatever that means in this context. You made it seem that a woman powerful, respected and accomplished in her own right "needed" a man to come save her and that is laced with misogyny. If you were not playing into this misogynistic narrative, then so be it. I was mistaken in your motive. But intention doesn't necessarily invalidate how something comes across.

And yet again: I said "laced" which means it wasn't total misogyny, but had some of the facets of it.

Are we going to pretend now that Z wasn't the person in charge of the NFL's musical events and that this event didn't coincide with a poor performance of her album?

In any other professional field, the fact that one part of the marriage favors the other thanks to their position in a company wouldn't have happened because it isn't ethical. And mentioning it is anything but misogynistic. But I understand this isn't the place to talk about misogyny, because you don't know what it actually is or experience it, but it sounds nice to say it when you don't have many ideas

all these novels when nobody can just decide "impact." anyway eminem continues to have the more successful catalog even outside of hit singles and this definitely speaks to his standing today. however both artist will have a strong legacy to their audiences and i guess that's all that matters.

Eminem.

Hilarious to see some people saying Eminem is unknown outside of USA. Eminem is way bigger than Beyonce globally.

Just now, Yuanyu said:

Are we going to pretend now that Z wasn't the person in charge of the NFL's musical events and that this event didn't coincide with a poor performance of her album?

In any other professional field, the fact that one part of the marriage favors the other thanks to their position in a company wouldn't have happened because it isn't ethical. And mentioning it is anything but misogynistic. But I understand this isn't the place to talk about misogyny, because you don't know what it actually is or experience it, but it sounds nice to say it when you don't have many ideas

lol.

There's a few things you're missing. I'll get to them after but let's just wrap up the misogyny bit. I said your jabs were laced with misogyny. No, it's not your fault Jay-Z works with the NFL, but I'm sure you knew you were belittling her own star power, respect and achievements by making it seem like she, a woman who had performed with the NFL four times prior, needed her husband to push for her. If this was not your intent, great. That doesn't change that on paper your words are echoing a common misogynistic trope labelled at Beyoncé. You don't have to acknowledge or agree, but I won't back down from this stance. Regardless my point remains without it: you have relied on snarky, shady jabs.

As for what you're missing.

Though Jay-Z is involved with selecting the NFL Super Bowl halftime shows, it was Netflix that approached the NFL to create the Christmas Bowl. Netflix selected Beyoncé. Netflix also has a history with Beyoncé, with their presentation of Homecoming, which was a great success for them.

To say that there is an unethical factor in one of America's biggest artists and most respected performers who is already a Netflix collaborator and 4x NFL-performer being selected to debut a Netflix event hosted in her home town is a bit silly. Claims of nepotism only really work when the person benefitting from their connections could not have achieved it otherwise, and achieved it despite not being adequately qualified, or qualified whatsoever. As these do not apply to Beyoncé, it's a bit silly to claim what you have. Again, I maintain your points are all snarky, shady jabs. They're not actually engaging with the topic maturely or with facts. You've taken one fact (Jay-Z works with the NFL) and neglected another (the show was created by Netflix and was not produced by Roc Nation).

TLDR: Roc Nation did not even produce the show you are claiming Beyoncé "needed" Jay-Z to get her.

19 minutes ago, Yuanyu said:

Are we going to pretend now that Z wasn't the person in charge of the NFL's musical events and that this event didn't coincide with a poor performance of her album?

In any other professional field, the fact that one part of the marriage favors the other thanks to their position in a company wouldn't have happened because it isn't ethical. And mentioning it is anything but misogynistic. But I understand this isn't the place to talk about misogyny, because you don't know what it actually is or experience it, but it sounds nice to say it when you don't have many ideas

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.