L

O

L

Congrats... Or something

Great for a legacy act,, with no legacy

I'm surprised it made it to the top 3 last week

I can only blame the autopen allegations. I think it left a bad taste in peoples mouths

It's a shame as the music is great and I thought it would've been more stable. Top 20 atleast on the 2nd week.

However on the bright side.. at least the tour is sold out

1 minute ago, Sergi91 said:

I'm surprised it made it to the top 3 last week

She pushed limited* variants and scammed countless fans with fake signatures to get there.

*originally marketed and sold as limited but then decided to remove the limits 4 salez.

6 minutes ago, GaGathaChristie said:

Great for a legacy act,, with no legacy

Top 3 on first week is still great.

She just doesn't have longevity. I think the drop is pretty normal for someone who is a nostalgic act and mainly catered to millennials. She should be proud of her sold out arena tour.

4 minutes ago, on the line said:

She pushed limited* variants and scammed countless fans with fake signatures to get there.

*originally marketed and sold as limited but then decided to remove the limits 4 salez.

I don't know if you were even a fan or just a hater tbh. Did you even buy it?

I agree that the autopen allegations probably didn't help. it went pretty viral on TikTok and twitter. I feel kinda bad for her but she's probably learned from it.

The fact that she already did 83K in the first week is something she probably didn't even expect herself, so I'm impressed she's still in the Top 200.

She came. She accomplished. Great first-week numbers for someone who had been inactive for 143 years, plus a sold-out tour.

The last laugh? Definitely Queen Hilary.

Edited March 10Mar 10 by Sharamee6

I was surprised to see it charted this week tho. Thought it was gonna serve a 3-out

2 minutes ago, Plasticdoll said:

I don't know if you were even a fan or just a hater tbh. Did you even buy it?

I agree that the autopen allegations probably didn't help. it went pretty viral on TikTok and twitter. I feel kinda bad for her but she's probably learned from it.

I was a fan. The Duffster was my first boyfriend and my favorite back in the day. I bought the signed CD and was planning to buy the Barnes and Noble variant (I like yellow) and the RSD vinyl. Returned the signed CD for a refund and didn't even finish listening to the album by the time the autopen news broke. It'd be one thing if she hadn't made that insta video and replied to a fan saying she was signing them. So scummy. She is so yesterday to me now.

1 minute ago, on the line said:

I was a fan. The Duffster was my first boyfriend and my favorite back in the day. I bought the signed CD and was planning to buy the Barnes and Noble variant (I like yellow) and the RSD vinyl. Returned the signed CD for a refund and didn't even finish listening to the album by the time the autopen news broke. It'd be one thing if she hadn't made that insta video and replied to a fan saying she was signing them. So scummy. She is so yesterday to me now.

Your first boyfriend? girl what-

1 minute ago, Plasticdoll said:

Your first boyfriend? girl what-

Like my first boyfriend way back in high school? Lol

is this the biggest freefall ever?

"way back in high school" and continues to behave like that

OT: good for her to chart anyway, I didn't think she would

9 minutes ago, KatyPrismSpirit said:

is this the biggest freefall ever?

No, that record belongs to Celine Dione. 1-OUT

So those first week sales really were luck….or something

Didn't an OBH make a thread about her outlasting Brit? Someone bump it!

She's goin' places

Slump... or something

Not Hilary having haters

The American Kylie

Almost all of her units were pure sales, this was beyond obvious. As obvious as that one user RUNNING here