Which of Taylor Swift's albums is the most overrated by gay men? Discuss!

evermore

Any of her pop albums. None of them are in her discography top 6.

1 minute ago, KatyPrismSpirit said:

evermore

Actually none of her albums are overrated

1 minute ago, Achilles. said:

Any of her pop albums. None of them are in her discography top 6.

Which one is not a pop album?

By the gays? Rep.

By the GP? Showgirl.

Midnights?

By the gays? rep, for sure.

1989

People say it's a pop bible, but it holds some of my least favorite Taylor tracks. Bad Blood, Welcome to New York, Shake it Off, Blank Space- all chops.

The gays stay trying to convince me that reputation is a better album than 1989 / is in her top 3

Reputation. It's #7 for me.

Reputation. By far. By any gender. By any sexuality. By any hater.

11 minutes ago, suburbannature said:

Which one is not a pop album?

Valid point but within the context of her discography "pop album" means 1989, reputation, Lover, Midnights, and Showgirl. Probably Poets standard too.

Popheads keeps calling 1989 a pop bible for some reason

1989 or Reputation. I'd lean more towards saying 1989 is more overrated.

Definitely puta

1989

1989 or Reputation.

i think it's 1989. personally i see it as a record with strong singles, but weak deep cuts (maybe with a few exceptions here and there).

gays love rep but i don't see it as overrated because it was panned at the time and for me it has aged very well, especially because i LOVE some of the deep cuts like getaway car, so it goes, dwoht, amongst others

Reputation of course, genuinely don't know what some of you are hearing when you press play on that album

Reputation.

The Tortured Poets Department by far.

I would say The Reich of a Slopgirl but no self-respecting gay person would use that album

reputation.

Very obviously Reputation and the 1989 slander in here is actually a part of that too!