Who has the better catalogue?

Edited March 8Mar 8 by PopLord86

Xtina

Gaga and it's not even close. Kesha gets too much credit on this website.

Not you making me choose between my mother and my sister. Bye

They both have excellent albums in different ways

Gaga

I used to be a huge Kesha fan, but after Cannibal there has never been a project I fully loved after that.

Gaga has a much better ear to compile a body of work.

Edited March 8Mar 8 by J-esper

Gaga is a lot more consistent and has a better discography overall, but I think Rainbow is the best album of the bunch.

11 minutes ago, Genie in a Bottle said:

Xtina

Gaga showed us what true versatility is with QUALITY to back it up, let not.

OT:

Lady Gaga. Rolling Stones said Kesha as an artist herself wouldn't exist without her

Gaga and it's not even close. Kesha doesn't get enough credit on this website.

i have more of a personal fondness for kesha but for consistency its probably gaga

Gaga, but Kesha wins best album cover with Rainbow.

15 minutes ago, Sugar-Rush said:

Not you making me choose between my mother and my sister. Bye

They both have excellent albums in different ways

29 minutes ago, PopLord86 said:

Wait what is this and where's Cannibal?

Gaga sweetie..... this is like comparing gold and plastic

look at this point Both! I love both there earlier albums but didn't vibe with many of there later stuff.

I love both of them 🥰 equally 🤗

It's Lady Gaga

Kesha's highest peaks within her discography eclipse GaGa with ease lmao. Its not even close. GaGa has highs too but they aren't as consistent or quality.

gaga by far, she's eaten kesha up since 2013

Both

Kesha, more fun at the start and doesn't take herself as painfully serious as Gags does.

My two main white faves

I choose Kesha, mostly because I think her discography is more varied and I think she's overall a better songwriter (some of you clearly haven't heard Gag Order)

But they're both leagues above their caucasian peer(s) that debuted around the same time.

Blow alone >>>>>>

45 minutes ago, Kayseri Mantisi said:

Gaga and it's not even close. Kesha gets too much credit on this website.

The opposite is true .

32 minutes ago, Mr. Stratus said:

Lady Gaga. Rolling Stones said Kesha as an artist herself wouldn't exist without her.

That is honestly a massive lie and untenable as a statement in 2026.

44 minutes ago, Spicy Pisces said:

Wait what is this

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Warrior_(Kesha_album)#Deconstructed_EP

44 minutes ago, Kiss It Better said:

Gaga sweetie..... this is like comparing gold and plastic

Kesha is literally an A+ songwriter and one the most versatile artists in pop music. You can prefer Gaga without tearing Kesha down for no reason. Kesha isn't some panned artist, she has an acclaimed discography to her name and proven herself time and again (Rainbow, Gag Order).

OT: Ultimately, it probably comes down to what's important to you since both have different strengths. For me it's Kesha, for others it's Gaga.

Gaga has been and will continue to be the better of the two for me.

But Kesha was polluted by Luke for so long, maybe she's coming into her own now. I like some of her old stuff, but not as much as I like Gaga's old stuff. On that note, Meet Me in Space deserved to be released, I wish it was on streaming services.

In terms of future releases, though, I'm still looking forward to Gaga's more than Kesha.

Edited March 8Mar 8 by JackOfHearts

31 minutes ago, Punky Rooster said:

Kesha, more fun at the start and doesn't take herself as painfully serious as Gags does.

Gaga meows in her new album by the way