It's obviously Taylor and anyone saying otherwise is delulu

eminem has no real talent

Elvis

Vocally it's definitely Taylor, but she has some other talents

1 hour ago, iHype. said:

Frank Sinatra and Celine if I understand are the only ones on this list who didn't write, produce, play any instruments, etc but just sang which is the minimum for a singer. However Celine's voice is obviously more remarkable so.

I voted Frank Sinatra, it was just gut feeling

Elvis ****sley

legends, eminem and taylor swift

the answer from legends is celine, if we include eminem and taylor the answer is taylor. at least celine can sing and eminem can rap

I'm voting for Elton cause his whole career which rendered him a legend is carried by anyone else

people for voting for Taylor just hate her cause she's more talented than U2

Edited March 7Mar 7 by Démodé

I just read today that Led Zeppelin apparently stole a lot from Blues artists, so …

Same obv goes for Elvis

IRAN

to vote for a certain "singer"

Not everyone jumping Ms. Allison like that.

Damn Taylor got slaughtered

Taylor is winning by a landslide, but I don't think the answer is that obvious. It really depends on how you approach the question. If you consider a certain type of talent to be equal to any other type of talent then legends like Celine may fall short here because it's all focused on her voice. But if you consider being so good at that one talent that it may be called extraordinary talent, then Celine suddenly appears as one of the most talented legends out there. Would you really call Aretha Franklin less talented than Taylor. It just.... doesn't work

Elvis had an amazing voice, often considered to be one of the best ever. And he had an insane amount of charisma that could light up any stage, so he was a truly extraordinary performer.

Taylor can write yes, but she can't sing or perform at all (kinda the basic requirements for a musician). She can also play some instruments, but she's not particularly good at that to impress anyone.

I must say Frank Sinatra I'm not that familiar with, so idk, maybe it's him

But dying at anyone saying The Beatles or Elton John

I started to feel bad for Taylor here, then saw that two Swifties voted for the most well-rounded talent here (Mariah). I voted for Madonna just to maintain cosmic balance, but Swifties need to tread very, very lightly.

it's objectively Madonna

8 hours ago, LikeATattoo said:

I started to feel bad for Taylor here, then saw that two Swifties voted for the most well-rounded talent here (Mariah). I voted for Madonna just to maintain cosmic balance, but Swifties need to tread very, very lightly.

I sometimes feel that they have a problem with black artists.

1 hour ago, stevyy said:

I sometimes feel that they have a problem with black artists.

Swifties are amongst the most nakedly anti-black fandoms in all of music, quite frankly.

1 hour ago, stevyy said:

I sometimes feel that they have a problem with black artists.

Mariah isn't black she's mixed.

Lowkey it's Frank.

Taylor has been releasing turd after turd but she's very talented outside of the performing/singing department. She just needs a break to reboot herself.

this transparent attempt at normalizing taylor as a legend when she's clearly not there yet

Edited March 25Mar 25 by Harry_

1 hour ago, stevyy said:

I sometimes feel that they have a problem with black artists.

The way Jlo is actually more "African/Black" than Mariah yet Mariah gets away with calling herself black when she's probably at most 10-15 percent African. Venezuelans are more Native/European with a minority African while her mother is straight up Irish lol.

9 minutes ago, VioletsandRoses said:

The way Jlo is actually more "African/Black" than Mariah yet Mariah gets away with calling herself black when she's probably at most 10-15 percent African. Venezuelans are more Native/European with a minority African while her mother is straight up Irish lol.

What an absurd hill to die on, but as a mixed race black person myself, I assure you Mariah wields more Afrocentric features than Jennifer Lopez does

OT: Elvis or Frank tbh

Edited March 25Mar 25 by PoisonedIvy

Frank