Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

ATRL

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.
Login issues

Second to None: The #1 Debuts Rate | And the winner is...

Featured Replies

  • Author
  • ATRL Moderator
1 minute ago, Eeveelution said:

Yes rip I heard the demo version one time and she was singing about drinking tea and being British. We're grateful it went to Miley

Oh boy, her over-singing the hell out of this saps it of some energy, because it feels like she's about to fall off time at any moment. Sometimes you need a lesser vocalist to make a track really work!

  • Replies 2.7k
  • Views 70.7k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • this is going to be the first time anyone's listened to candle in the wind 97 since 97

  • 87. Average score: 1.98 High score: 8.5 (@Rev8) Low score: 1 (@NEX , @slw84, @David_Greengrass97, @EJQL8, @Album Leak, @Genie in a Bottle, @naval23, @Florence Belch, @SupremeGoddess, @McNulty, @Pero

  • Author
  • ATRL Moderator

The next one is a boatmate with "You Are Not Alone" for several reasons...

  • Author
  • ATRL Moderator

37.

jeMNepy.png

Average score: 6.42

High score: 10 (@HarajukuPrincess, @Icarus, @naval23, @MP2K, @Mythical, @Invisibility, @MusicLoverDude, @Taylor fanboy)

Low score: 1 (@David_Greengrass97, @SupremeGoddess, @Luckitty, @conatus, @Eeveelution)

Back when he was known as Puff Daddy, Sean Combs became, ahem, notorious for his productions that effectively amounted to retreads of the songs he was theoretically sampling. The prime example is this teary memorial to the late rapper The Notorious B.I.G., which served as the second single for Puffy’s debut album in May 1997, a few months after his friend was slain, and spent 11 weeks atop the Hot 100. “I’ll Be Missing You” finds Combs rapping over the melody to the Police’s 1983 classic “Every Breath You Take” while Biggie’s widow, Faith Evans, sings a barely changed version of the chorus. (The verses were actually written by the rapper Sauce Money, at the suggestion of Jay-Z, who turned down the opportunity.) If you felt squeamish about financially supporting Combs’ legal fund while listening to the playlist for this rate, don’t worry. He never sought permission to interpolate “Every Breath You Take” and Sting won 100% of the royalties in a lawsuit, though they reconciled for a performance at the 1997 MTV Video Music Awards.

Best bit: “Give anything to hear half your breath/I know you still livin' your life after death”

ATRL says…: Faith Evans carried. “I'm sorry but I'm giving this a 10 for Faith Evans alone – her vocals are heaven in this song,” @naval23 apologized. “Lazy as fuck, but Faith does sound hella good so points for that,” @Graves conceded. “Diddy is a disgrace to humanity, but the song is nice,” @blown away wrote. “Faith Evans does the heavy lifting, though. The chorus is easily the best part.” @Johnny Jacobs agreed it was a “catchy song thanks to the chorus, but f Diddy.” @slw84 “loved it in my youth. Thanks, Faith, not you, Puff and 112.” @Florence Belch wouldn’t “give it a 1.0 just because of Miss Evans' magical voice.”

@SupremeGoddess did give it a 1. “Oh, I'm sorry, I just can't give him any good scores after everything that has happened,” she explained. “It just feels disgusting and icky, especially considering what this song is about. Practice what you preach, you criminal. The one is for Faith and Faith only.” @DiamondHeart also “loved this as a kid when I heard this on radio, so it has some nostalgic value. I also like Faith Evans’ hook here. But now knowing what we do about Diddy...it's just so hard to take anything said here seriously. Not the worst song in here but probably one of the worst people here.” @McNulty wondered “why I like this song by pedos.” @Rev8 called it “a great song (about an amazing rapper). We gonna ignore the elephant in the room..........”

@makeawish thought “it hops comfortably onto the back of its sample but the original material is here often pretty bad. Lyrics to the second verse are a real low point of the ‘90s.” But @sparrowblue “somehow developed core memories with this. Sigh. Also nice usage of the sample.” @MusicLoverDude deemed it “a good tribute.” Not @Eeveelution. “I can't do this right now,” he declared. @glitch gave it a 7, apparently for comedy value. “Is it bad that this song makes me laugh?” he asked. “I genuinely don't know why.”

8 minutes ago, supaspaz said:

Well, no! Because that's a great song!

I have a personal aversion but also just generally hate Dr Rape pop songs. Absolute bottom of the trash can production.

  • Author
  • ATRL Moderator

Cannot get over this being a Jessie J original. Guess I never got the m-m-m-m-memo!

  • Author
  • ATRL Moderator
2 minutes ago, ChooseyLover said:

All those 10s for what dies

Biggie would have been huge on ATRL in 1997

Waitttt the way that I rated this completely forgetting that Puff Daddy is P Diddy. Didn't even think about it. deadbanana2

  • Author
  • ATRL Moderator

Anyone else know this one before they ever heard "Every Breath You Take"?

  • Author
  • ATRL Moderator
Just now, Achilles. said:

Waitttt the way that I rated this completely forgetting that Puff Daddy is P Diddy. Didn't even think about it. deadbanana2

A rebrand after another bout of legal trouble

https://apnews.com/article/diddy-trial-jury-selection-sean-combs-names-513b5165620cb3bc6ecf7462e102dc75

  • Author
  • ATRL Moderator
1 minute ago, Eeveelution said:

My 1s finally leaving

crying-thank-you-fergie.gif

Unfortunately, you gave the next one a 9

  • Author
  • ATRL Moderator

36.

5Msf5VV.png

Average score: 6.44

High score: 10 (@Inner Insanity, @naval23, @Peroxide, @Frozen99, @Indie Go Mind, @KillingYourCareer, @MusicLoverDude, @Achilles.)

Low score: 1 (@Album Leak, @Queen Conchita, @theblackestday)

How sincere of an exercise is “Anti-Hero”? I’ve always found the lead single from Midnights to be fundamentally flawed, ringing hollow with false modesty. Even as Taylor Swift dives deep into her most crushing insecurities – sharing brutally honest confessions like she never has before about feeling depressed, unattractive and scared that she’ll end up alone – it all feels carefully stage-managed. Not for one second do I buy that Taylor has ever believed she’s the anti-hero; just look at how she blithely spoofs the criticisms (“Did you hear my covert narcissism I disguise as altruism/Like some kind of congressman?”) that probably strike closer to reality than she’d care to admit. Nevertheless, it was a highly effective performance of self-flagellating relatability, with perhaps the most quotable hook (“It’s me, hi/I’m the problem, it’s me”) of her entire discography. “Anti-Hero” became one of Taylor’s biggest hits ever on the Hot 100 following its release in October 2022, including her longest reign to date at #1, with eight weeks.

Best bit: “I'll stare directly at the sun, but never in the mirror”

ATRL says…: “Anti-Hero” seems to be a nearly undeniable hit. “For all the faults of modern Taylor (and there are many) she has a good ear for picking a lead single,” @Graves admitted. @naval23 thought it was “the rare time where she picked the right lead. This was the switch that made her go from radio poison to radio darling.” @MusicLoverDude would have given it an 11. “Easily her best lead single and it gives me instant joy without fail every single time,” he said. @makeawish “thought I was over this but no, tears by the second chorus.” @blown away deemed it “one of her better post-2021 songs.” @sparrowblue complimented Taylor for “a little self-awareness.”

Hi, it’s the lyrics, the lyrics were the problem even for some fans, though. “Some bizarre lyrics (why does it matter if it's teatime?),” @Diarrhoea noted, “but it's basically the best case post-Folkmore attempt at adult-pop from a perpetual child.” @SupremeGoddess had the same hang-up. “The lyrics can be jarring (tea party? What are you, Alice in Wonderland?),” she wrote, “but the message sticks well enough, and it's a solid pop track. It's infectious.” @Technicolor agreed it has “very cringey lyrics but it's catchy.” So did @glitch . “Unfortunately, this bops a little bit,” he conceded, “but the lyrical content is more egregious than usual. ‘It's me, hi, I'm the victim it's me.’” @Johnny Jacobs seemed to reference when the lyrics when he called it “not my cup of tea.” @Ewan Chaos s felt it was a “shame Showgirls is getting all the flack that MIDnights deserved, even if it's not great either.”

Or maybe the problem is the people who didn’t get it. “Someone once said that a queen is never late, everyone else is simply early,” @Achilles. explained. “So it isn't a problem that she arrived 13 years late to the ‘I’m the problem’ lyric. The song that she built around it was more than worth the wait.”

Maybe my score was generous, but it's a bop! Yes, the lyrics are clunky, but that's more often than not the case with Taylor these days.

Anti-Hero and The Fate of Ophelia are, in the grand scheme of post-folkmore Taylor, pretty inoffensive I guess. And I say that as someone who thinks TLOAS is a steaming pile of **** of an album.

I'll Be Missing You on the other hand... Some of the worst verses in a mainstream rap hit ever. Faith innocent.

  • Author
  • ATRL Moderator
1 minute ago, conatus said:

I'll Be Missing You on the other hand... Some of the worst verses in a mainstream rap hit ever. Faith innocent.

OSMH

My comment being snubbed. Okay.

People interpreting "tea time" literally when it's clearly meant to function in the gay "spill the tea" way; "when people talk about me / everybody agrees."

  • Author
  • ATRL Moderator
3 minutes ago, Eeveelution said:

Maybe my score was generous, but it's a bop! Yes, the lyrics are clunky, but that's more often than not the case with Taylor these days.

I would say the lyrics to "Anti-Hero" (minus that sexy baby nonsense) are far stronger than "The Fate of Ophelia." I just find the whole sentiment so false.

1 minute ago, Achilles. said:

People interpreting "tea time" literally when it's clearly meant to function in the gay "spill the tea" way; "when people talk about me / everybody agrees."

I'm not sure that this makes the lyric any better.

gretchen-humor.gif

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.