Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

ATRL

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.
Login issues

Second to None: The #1 Debuts Rate | And the winner is...

Featured Replies

  • Author
  • ATRL Moderator

43.

5sAJ0Y6.png

Average score: 5.98

High score: 10 (@Dark Miracles, @KillingYourCareer, @Norte, @andresg770, @MusicLoverDude, @theblackestday)

Low score: 1 (@NEX, @SupremeGoddess, @sparrowblue)

During her career peak, through the historic Teenage Dream run and before Prism tapered off, Katy Perry hit the summit of the Hot 100 eight times – but only once did she debut at #1, in February 2012, with this lead single for her Teenage Dream: The Complete Confection reissue. And, wow, was she coasting on momentum at that point. “Part of Me” is undoubtedly the worst top ten hit Katy ever scored, a post-breakup affirmation that sounds dour and claustrophobic and entirely lacking in the bubbly magic that launched its parent album into the pop stratosphere. It makes sense when you consider that Katy plucked this one out of her Teenage Dream reject pile and spruced it up with a new narrative about her pending divorce from Russell Brand (it was actually written before they ever married, probably about ex-boyfriend Travie McCoy) and a glossy, but extremely silly, music video where she enlists to get over a cheating man. Given the talent involved – Max Martin, Dr. Luke, Cirkut and Bonnie McKee – there’s no excuse.

Best bit: “In fact, you can keep everything, yeah, yeah/EXCEPT FOR MEEEEEEE!!!!”

ATRL says…: “Out of all the songs she was smashing with at the time, why this turd?” @Florence Belch asked. @DiamondHeart also wanted to know “how was this a #1 debut but not the other singles?” May I introduce you to the concept of an imperial period?

“Well, Katy, sorry to say but no one even wants to take this part away from you,” @SupremeGoddess explained. “In fact, you should've have kept this in the drawer. You'd have done the whole world a good service.” @OrbitNumber1 called it a “horrible song. Sorry, Katy.” @Johnny Jacobs recalled that “Katy was corny back then and this one is no different. It wasn't for me.” @sparrowblue was stunned by her vocals. “Revisiting some of these songs you really realize why Ms. Adele snatched everybody during this time,” he marveled. “‘Cause chile…where is the note? Where is the key?” (This makes me giggle every I time I read it.) “A 7th single and it SOUNDS like it,” @Graves complained. “The creative juices had run stale, the whole thing is limp. And the video is so funny (the only time anybody has ever said this about a Katy video).” He must have forgotten about “Last Friday Night (T.G.I.F.)”!

There was a lot of ire for the music video, which got compared at the time to military propaganda. “Not as instant as the other Teenage Dream singles, but it's still a decent song. The music video is the real enemy,” @blown away insisted. “A lot of people hate this song but I think it holds up pretty well melodically,” @glitch defended. “Obviously the music video and lyrics are a disaster, but ignore those and it's a serviceable bop.” @Diarrhoea mourned that “this heartless banger has none of her cartoon magic. The video was strange then and is strange now. Positioning this as a post-Russell Brand (!) revenge song when it was written pre-marriage and has absolutely no emotional core is more cynical than Witness could dream of being.”

The few, the proud, the fans included @MusicLoverDude. “This gets overhated but Katy made an ANTHEM with this,” he asserted. @theblackestday pondered that it might be “her most underrated single? Like, this is top 5 for her kinda.” (Kinda is doing some heavy lifting there...) @makeawish would have given it a 10, “but there are so many genuinely terrible people in involved in this record one way or another that I have to knock a mark off somewhere.” @Rev8 noted similarities to Britney Spears’ “He About to Lose Me,” which he said “is the slow version of this.”

  • Replies 2.7k
  • Views 70.8k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • this is going to be the first time anyone's listened to candle in the wind 97 since 97

  • 87. Average score: 1.98 High score: 8.5 (@Rev8) Low score: 1 (@NEX , @slw84, @David_Greengrass97, @EJQL8, @Album Leak, @Genie in a Bottle, @naval23, @Florence Belch, @SupremeGoddess, @McNulty, @Pero

Just now, supaspaz said:

Please explain!

Never liked the song! Never cared for him as an artist outside of like Redbone. Also I'm pretty sure he plagiarised it anyway so who cares

IMG_0882.thumb.gif.89db21c2b8e84770a7915

  • Author
  • ATRL Moderator
Just now, Eeveelution said:

Never liked the song! Never cared for him as an artist outside of like Redbone. Also I'm pretty sure he plagiarised it anyway so who cares

IMG_0882.thumb.gif.89db21c2b8e84770a7915

Oh, I couldn't fit that controversy in my write-up!

https://www.tmz.com/2019/02/12/childish-gambino-house-slave-jase-harley-grammy-win-this-is-america/

Calling him a "house slave" was crazy!

1 minute ago, supaspaz said:

Plus that one member who gives a 1 to every song by a Black man...

again... a katy perry fan. is that shocking that they are a black excellence hater coffee

I was such a hardcore LM back in 2011 that hating on Katy was just part and parcel of the job.

But she certainly made it easier with songs like this.

IMG_0882.thumb.gif.89db21c2b8e84770a7915

Edited by Graves

2 minutes ago, supaspaz said:

compared at the time to military propaganda

My intro to feminism class dragging it for this. rofl

3 minutes ago, supaspaz said:

43.

5sAJ0Y6.png

Average score: 5.98

High score: 10 (@Dark Miracles, @KillingYourCareer, @Norte, @andresg770, @MusicLoverDude, @theblackestday)

Low score: 1 (@NEX, @SupremeGoddess, @sparrowblue)

During her career peak, through the historic Teenage Dream run and before Prism tapered off, Katy Perry hit the summit of the Hot 100 eight times – but only once did she debut at #1, in February 2012, with this lead single for her Teenage Dream: The Complete Confection reissue. And, wow, was she coasting on momentum at that point. "Part of Me" is undoubtedly the worst top ten hit Katy ever scored, a post-breakup affirmation that sounds dour and claustrophobic and entirely lacking in the bubbly magic that launched its parent album into the pop stratosphere. It makes sense when you consider that Katy plucked this one out of her Teenage Dream reject pile and spruced it up with a new narrative about her pending divorce from Russell Brand (it was actually written before they ever married, probably about ex-boyfriend Travie McCoy) and a glossy, but extremely silly, music video where she enlists to get over a cheating man. Given the talent involved – Max Martin, Dr. Luke, Cirkut and Bonnie McKee – there's no excuse.

Best bit: "In fact, you can keep everything, yeah, yeah/EXCEPT FOR MEEEEEEE!!!!"

ATRL says…: "Out of all the songs she was smashing with at the time, why this turd?" @Florence Belch asked. @DiamondHeart also wanted to know "how was this a #1 debut but not the other singles?" May I introduce you to the concept of an imperial period?

"Well, Katy, sorry to say but no one even wants to take this part away from you," @SupremeGoddess explained. "In fact, you should've have kept this in the drawer. You'd have done the whole world a good service." @OrbitNumber1 called it a "horrible song. Sorry, Katy." @Johnny Jacobs recalled that "Katy was corny back then and this one is no different. It wasn't for me." @sparrowblue was stunned by her vocals. "Revisiting some of these songs you really realize why Ms. Adele snatched everybody during this time," he marveled. "'Cause chile…where is the note? Where is the key?" (This makes me giggle every I time I read it.) "A 7th single and it SOUNDS like it," @Graves complained. "The creative juices had run stale, the whole thing is limp. And the video is so funny (the only time anybody has ever said this about a Katy video)." He must have forgotten about "Last Friday Night (T.G.I.F.)"!

There was a lot of ire for the music video, which got compared at the time to military propaganda. "Not as instant as the other Teenage Dream singles, but it's still a decent song. The music video is the real enemy," @blown away insisted. "A lot of people hate this song but I think it holds up pretty well melodically," @glitch defended. "Obviously the music video and lyrics are a disaster, but ignore those and it's a serviceable bop." @Diarrhoea mourned that "this heartless banger has none of her cartoon magic. The video was strange then and is strange now. Positioning this as a post-Russell Brand (!) revenge song when it was written pre-marriage and has absolutely no emotional core is more cynical than Witness could dream of being."

The few, the proud, the fans included @MusicLoverDude. "This gets overhated but Katy made an ANTHEM with this," he asserted. @theblackestday pondered that it might be "her most underrated single? Like, this is top 5 for her kinda." (Kinda is doing some heavy lifting there...) @makeawish would have given it a 10, "but there are so many genuinely terrible people in involved in this record one way or another that I have to knock a mark off somewhere." @Rev8 noted similarities to Britney Spears' "He About to Lose Me," which he said "is the slow version of this."

i was so generous to give this utter rubbish a 3. I should've given a -1000. a bloody horrid track.

Thank you (@NEX, @SupremeGoddess, @sparrowblue) for doing the lord's work and giving it a 1.

Edited by Maroonx

  • Author
  • ATRL Moderator
1 minute ago, Achilles. said:

My intro to feminism class dragging it for this. rofl

Naomi Wolf, you will always be famous

It's crazy how back then she could send a boring snooze of a song like this to #1 like it was nothing, but in 2025...

IMG_0882.thumb.gif.89db21c2b8e84770a7915

  • Author
  • ATRL Moderator
1 minute ago, Maroonx said:

again... a katy perry fan. is that shocking that they are a black excellence hater coffee

So you were talking about who I thought you were fhdhdsgsf

1 minute ago, Graves said:

I was such a hardcore LM back in 2011 than hating on Katy was just part and parcel of the job.

A lot of things are starting to make sense

IMG_0882.thumb.gif.89db21c2b8e84770a7915

4 minutes ago, supaspaz said:

Plus that one member who gives a 1 to every song by a Black man...

hoetenks

Shouldn't that be considered trolling?

4 minutes ago, supaspaz said:

Plus that one member who gives a 1 to every song by a Black man...

La Rä'çîsmé

2 minutes ago, Achilles. said:

My intro to feminism class dragging it for this. rofl

As they SHOULD! Not only is it gross imperialism, but it's ******* lame! Katy's take on being "edgy" was... giving herself a lesbian pixie cut and enlisting, oh lord. Truly a preacher's kid.

IMG_0882.thumb.gif.89db21c2b8e84770a7915

1 minute ago, Eeveelution said:

A lot of things are starting to make sense

IMG_0882.thumb.gif.89db21c2b8e84770a7915

Not too much on the album of the century.

IMG_0882.thumb.gif.89db21c2b8e84770a7915

1 minute ago, HarajukuPrincess said:

La Rä'çîsmé

the amount of WP I got from katy rats... checks out... again bird

  • Author
  • ATRL Moderator
4 minutes ago, blown away said:

hoetenks

Shouldn't that be considered trolling?

I think in KFC's case, it really is just shockingly bad taste

  • Author
  • ATRL Moderator

42.

fjTnXp0.png

Average score: 6.08

High score: 10 (@Icarus, @greento, @Ghibli, @Taylor fanboy, @Taemira)

Low score: 1 (@Album Leak, @Soda Pop Queen, @Queen Conchita, @theblackestday)

Props to Taylor Swift and frequent collaborator Jack Antonoff for changing things up on the lead single for The Tortured Poets Department, an understated, downtempo duet with Post Malone about a short-lived romance that lingers on the mind. But it was clear from the diminishing artistic returns that their partnership had run its course, even before the unusually muted public response to this song. Taylor is, of course, too big to fail at this stage of her career; “Fortnight” hit its requisite marks upon release in April 2024, including breaking the single-day streaming record on Spotify. Yet it faded surprisingly quickly: Just two weeks (appropriately enough) at #1 on the Hot 100 and off the chart in 21, less than “It Is Over Now?” After one of the highest debuts ever on pop radio, it stalled out at #5 at the format. Hardly anyone outside of the hardcore Swifties seems to still be listening to “Fortnight.” The Grammy nominations months later for Record of the Year and Song of the Year felt perfunctory, while MTV’s decision to crown it Video of the Year at the Video Music Awards – Taylor’s third consecutive win – was just plain baffling.

Best bit: The song finally comes alive in the gorgeous outro, where a fantasy about escaping to Florida with an old lover provides both emotional and musical release.

ATRL says…: “Fortnight” has plenty of defenders, thought many thought Taylor made a mistake releasing it. “Great vocal harmonies! Some of her best languid musicianship,” @Diarrhoea raved. “Kind of a bizarre single choice but also insanely memorable.” @Achilles. agreed it was “her weirdest choice as a single, but there really is something about it—those hooks did in fact sink their hooks in me.” @makeawish will “come and go on this one. It's OK, the end is terrific. In no way should Taylor be releasing this as the lead single from anything.” @MusicLoverDude called it “a good song but not meant for spring and summer. It's better in fall and winter.”

Even some Swift skeptics seem to have a soft spot for this one. “Surprisingly refreshing for late-career Taylor,” @Graves conceded. @SupremeGoddess thought “this is one of the rare times where a slightly above average track actually makes a dent. Idk what makes it work but it works very well.” @Rev8 “would've given it a lower score, but I gotta acknowledge the sound they were going for.”

Yet enough of you were bored to sink its chances. “Why is this woman allergic to fun?” @glitch asked, “Let's explore synth pop and suck all the life out of it.” @Johnny Jacobs deemed it a “bland and unnecessary song.” @blown away needs “pre-2017 Taylor back. Folklore and Evermore were a great course correction after Lover, but everything else after has been uninspired shit for the most part. Including this.” @naval23 sniped that “this was when Taylor knew the GP would eat up anything she releases and stopped caring.”

Katy's dominance was such a strange time to be alive. I wonder if there are any other stars who managed to be mega successful whilst simultaneously being the antithesis of cool.

Edit: The timing of this couldn't have been more perfect if I'd tried

Edited by glitch

Her best song... you guys wouldn't get it

IMG_0882.thumb.gif.89db21c2b8e84770a7915

EDIT this was about PART OF ME!!! Taylor dieeee

Edited by theblackestday

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.