Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

ATRL

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.
Login issues

Taylor & Ariana collab: Would it smash?

How would a Taylor X Ariana single perform? 50 members have voted

  1. 1. How would a Taylor X Ariana single perform?

    • Smash hard with longevity
      44%
    • Smash initially but end up being a front-loaded mess
      56%

Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Featured Replies

If Pop Icons Ariana and Taylor released a collab single tomorrow, both co-writing it together and someone like Max Martin producing. How would it realistically perform on the Billboard Hot 100 and overall?

 

Obviously it would debut at #1, no doubt about that. However, would it be a smash hit with insane streams, sales, and longevity? Or would it initially smash hard at first, be more fan-driven and then start dropping after a few weeks? 

 

Do you think sonically a song between them could work and serve pop perfection? Would it be bigger than Telephone and Rain On Me? Would the internet explode? Or would it be a front-loaded mess and bad quality song? Discuss!

 

spacer.png

 

 

 

  • Replies 34
  • Views 743
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • At least someone will be doing the singing

  • It would easily break streaming records with its debut for sure.    Longevity depends on the song. I think it helps they are so different and could contrast one another. As already mentioned

  • Swiftienator13
    Swiftienator13

    Agreed.   Taylor and Ariana, for a collab to work, would have to find a middleground between their respective core sounds. Taylor is in that atmospheric synth-pop with occasional acoustic so

Taylor flopped with Ed Sheeran at his peak. Sometimes I feel like there's a two positives make a negative around her singles :gaycat7:

2 minutes ago, gustavothehuman said:

Taylor flopped with Ed Sheeran at his peak. Sometimes I feel like there's a two positives make a negative around her singles :gaycat7:

You must be on to something...

 

Taylor's only smash collab I think was IDWLF with Zayn, and while not initially a big hit but had incredible longevity and a bonifide universal fan-fave Safe & Sound, and it involves collabing with artists that "you did not expect" that she would collab with

13 minutes ago, aesthetic bih said:

You must be on to something...

 

Taylor's only smash collab I think was IDWLF with Zayn, and while not initially a big hit but had incredible longevity and a bonifide universal fan-fave Safe & Sound, and it involves collabing with artists that "you did not expect" that she would collab with

Yeah, the only other collab I can think of that might fit the cult classic definition would be exile, which is another song with an unexpected feature. I guess there's a conversation to be had about whether or not Fortnight could be considered a flop, but it was certainly less successful than IDWLF. 

 

All that's to say that Taylor's collaborations with men are pretty hit or miss, her collaborations with other women are either excellent and get ignored by the GP (Breathe, Florida, Nothing New) or are messes that get shipped back with haste (SOTB, You All Over Me). That fact, and the fact that all but one of her collabs with relevant mainstream artists have been flops to some degree (the most recent examples of collaborative singles being Fortnight, ME!, and End Game...), it doesn't bode well for this hypothetical Tayriana collab. 

26 minutes ago, aesthetic bih said:

You must be on to something...

 

Taylor's only smash collab I think was IDWLF with Zayn, and while not initially a big hit but had incredible longevity and a bonifide universal fan-fave Safe & Sound, and it involves collabing with artists that "you did not expect" that she would collab with

Not so coincidentally, those were also two of the only songs she had on Spotify for a handful of years. 

The song would be terrible; I think it'd have the same issues as Don't Call Me Angel, where it's incoherent because they couldn't find a good compromise for their styles. But it'd be a hit :nicole2:

It would easily break streaming records with its debut for sure. 

 

Longevity depends on the song. I think it helps they are so different and could contrast one another. As already mentioned Taylor's better collabs are unexpected and Ariana isn't someone she would typically fit with. Could work if all the pieces come together. I don't ever see this collab happening irl though so we'll never know lol. 

It would be like a Rihanna and Taylor collab aka a mess. The two don't vibe

 

A number one for sure but an overall smash? Idk

Edited by Johnny Jacobs

it would smash

 

esp if it's something in the vibe of 'Stuck With U'

 

6 minutes ago, Sabrina Carpenter said:

it would smash

 

esp if it's something in the vibe of 'Stuck With U'

Agreed.

 

Taylor and Ariana, for a collab to work, would have to find a middleground between their respective core sounds. Taylor is in that atmospheric synth-pop with occasional acoustic sounds realm while Ariana is in that trap-pop 808s, bass, full synth production type of sound.

 

Stuck with U is absolutely a perfect middle ground for the both of them, a big catchy midtempo would be perfect, Taylor singing lead with Ariana doing big high note background vocals would be such a slay :jonny6:

There is a huge vocal gap between those two, I don't think it would sound good.

It would be so gigantic in its debut week, longevity would depend on if it's good or not.

I feel like Ari can blend with Taylor especially after eternal sunshine. 

 

50m streams first week, first song to debut with +2000 points :coffee:

  • Author
24 minutes ago, swtamira said:

It would be so gigantic in its debut week, longevity would depend on if it's good or not.

 

20 minutes ago, GAGAISTHEBESTYA said:

I feel like Ari can blend with Taylor especially after eternal sunshine. 

 

50m streams first week, first song to debut with +2000 points :coffee:

 

46 minutes ago, Sabrina Carpenter said:

it would smash

 

esp if it's something in the vibe of 'Stuck With U'

 

1 hour ago, Tm4074 said:

It would easily break streaming records with its debut for sure. 

 

Longevity depends on the song. I think it helps they are so different and could contrast one another. As already mentioned Taylor's better collabs are unexpected and Ariana isn't someone she would typically fit with. Could work if all the pieces come together. I don't ever see this collab happening irl though so we'll never know lol. 

I'm really digging the takes in here, whether I agree with them or not. :alexz:

 

Imo Taylor's collabs that work the best are the most unexpected ones where she is different sonically and artistically from the other artist. With the right song/material and producer, both could benefit from each other in a song and could possibly release a pop smash. 
 

No doubt it would break streaming and digital/physical single sales records in its debut week. Even if the song was a chop, the combination of both fanbases and viral hype of it would have the song be #1 for at least a few weeks. 

 

 

 
 

 

Edited by Lethal

Most big name + big name collab suck and end up flopping big time :rip:

I think it could work. Zayn ate up Taylor in I Don't Wanna Live Forever and no one batted an eye. It'd make me nervous for Ariana tho because everyone that collabs with Taylor eventually ends up in the khia asylum.

2 hours ago, Johnny Jacobs said:

It would be like a Rihanna and Taylor collab aka a mess. The two don't vibe

 

A number one for sure but an overall smash? Idk

Rihanna Taylor collab is a huge smash hit 

TIWYCF is blockbuster

2 hours ago, FolkLover1989 said:

Rihanna Taylor collab is a huge smash hit 

TIWYCF is blockbuster

Thank you, Calvin

2 hours ago, FolkLover1989 said:

Rihanna Taylor collab is a huge smash hit 

TIWYCF is blockbuster

You're right. Taylor in the distant background really is a match in heaven :ryan3:

Recent history shows that collaboration of big pop girls FLOP in comparison to their combined fame and hype.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.