Oh I know some of yall thought this basement run publication was gonna tear her apart, but are you shocked they stanned this career highlight of an album??

 

https://pitchfork.com/reviews/albums/sabrina-carpenter-mans-best-friend/

Edited September 3, 2025Sep 3 by Walk_Away21

oh this thread will be quiet

 

nobody's son did that

 

 

Edited September 3, 2025Sep 3 by Calvin

Nobody can stop Hurricane Sabrina of 2025. 
 

I hate P4k but I am glad they came through for Sabrina despite the unnecessary hate by 2/3 fandoms for this album. 

 

 

They heard My Man on Willpower and had no choice!

I know those stans who predicted she will be next Katy 

They must be really sad seeing this

We love Pitchfork again! 

So much for the protests over the cover controversy.

 

 

...Vin

SnS scored an 8 on P4K...

People are hating but her wield of the acoustic/country pop with the juxtaposition of how flirty winky her lyrics are is such a niche she does so well, I love it so much!

Pitchfork is a joke, but what else is new?

The decline 

 

Edited September 3, 2025Sep 3 by EnigmaticAndroid

3 minutes ago, l3disko said:

Pitchfork is a joke, but what else is new?

When Did You Get Hot? deserved.  

Addison 8.0

whoa …yes

 

it's growing on me a lot but i'm very shocked by this actually. lemme read the review. this doesn't make up for them giving Rihanna's Unapologetic a 4.5 though, still. it's just… they have such strange biases and loyalties and are always swayed so much by public opinion. I feel like they love going against the grain. I'm sorry but I still don't understand how Addison's album (still good!) got a higher score than Marina's new album… it just. idk. very baffling to me. the bias is at work. I'm gonna relisten to Sabrina's album in full tonight, but i'm already LOVING Manchild (of course), Tears, Nobody's Son, Go Go Juice, and House Tour 

im mad about the 0.1 missing just not to give her a 8 

what halsey said

 

2 minutes ago, Diet Pepsi said:

Addison 8.0

Biggest industry plant since Billie

 

It's just that she doesn't have talent to go along with it

NOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!

Spoiler

.....one hates Sabrina though, she is pretty and makes good looking music videos with women/bottoms empowering themes 

 

 

Higher than blackout by britney? Hell no

GUTS 8.0

9 minutes ago, jeauseph said:

whoa …yes

 

it's growing on me a lot but i'm very shocked by this actually. lemme read the review. this doesn't make up for them giving Rihanna's Unapologetic a 4.5 though, still. it's just… they have such strange biases and loyalties and are always swayed so much by public opinion. I feel like they love going against the grain. I'm sorry but I still don't understand how Addison's album (still good!) got a higher score than Marina's new album… it just. idk. very baffling to me. the bias is at work. I'm gonna relisten to Sabrina's album in full tonight, but i'm already LOVING Manchild (of course), Tears, Nobody's Son, Go Go Juice, and House Tour 

It's bias at work indeed.

Their offices are full of OTHs (confirmed), so I wouldn't be surprised if they had something against Rihanna and Marina too.

 

It just seems like their reviews are being influenced by $$ behind the scenes.

like, how is it that the industry's biggest plants are the ones getting such overinflated scores?

 

Edited September 3, 2025Sep 3 by l3disko