Iconic song but it seems like it's a bit polarizing, do you like it or not?

 

 

Edited August 26, 2025Aug 26 by Technicolor

Like somewhat (likely liked more back then) but overrated song in her catalogue 

 

My taste evolved I guess 

She has so many gems in her discog and this one is a stain  

she has way better songs.

Edited August 22, 2025Aug 22 by KatyPrismSpirit

Like 

 

And love it but "Unthinkable" deserved that level of success 

 

 

This is a modern standard. 

Classic 

I like the actual song I guess but I just wish somebody else sang it

 

Her voice somehow both sounds strained and completely devoid of all emotion

It's technically good but I wouldn't be sad if I never hear it again 

it was super overplayed back then, so much that I hated it for years, but now I like it again

her best song however is still TSWABH imo

dislike 

One of her worst singles together with Girl On Fire

 

49 minutes ago, HarajukuPrincess said:

"Unthinkable" deserved that level of success 

 

 

I agree 

I don't like this song. She's screaming on the track 

 

No One should sing like that….

Like, but as others have said, she has many better songs in her discography.

Extreme dislike. 

She has better but I still like it, it did what it had to do

Can't tell if I dislike it because its a bad song or because its so overplayed.

like.

but i LOVED this specific live version that i ripped from Youtube years ago that i can't find anywhere anymore. 

you can here it in this Dior show

 

This is bad.

"Girl on fire" is even worse.

 

She has much better music from her first 4 albums.

Love it. One of my faves

like but Alicia had better songs. 

I cannot listen to it from beginning to end. She's pushing her voice too far out of her comfort zone and it sounds kinda grating.

I love it tbh, there's also some nostalgia attached to it.

Love it. The melody is absolutely beautiful and the bridge is otherworldly 

 

Modern classic hit