Both have Florence Welch collabs, but which album is better? I suggest you choose.

 

 

 

 

 

 

Edited August 15, 20251 yr by sunbathinganimal

is there a third option

not you setting Nose up like this. Slow day in the base I guess 

 

Just now, motra_gaga said:

not you setting Nose up like this. Slow day in the base I guess 

 

I am an impartial observer as I think both albums are horrible 

 

TTPD is just disgusting. At least Joanne has John Wayne and the title track. 

Diamond Heart alone >>>

The Manuscript >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

PTSD sweetie... 

Only one has Dancing In Circles, so Jolene 

I'm inclined to pick the one that has Perfect Godllusion on it.

 

Joanne is just disgusting. At least TTPD has Guilty as Sin?

Don't set Gaga up like that sis

Diamond Heart vs. Fortnight (featuring Post Malone)

A-Yo vs. The Tortured Poets Department

Joanne vs. My Boy Only Breaks His Favorite Toys

John Wayne vs. Down Bad

Dancin' in Circles vs. So Long, London

Perfect Illusion vs. But Daddy I Love Him

Million Reasons vs. Fresh Out the Slammer

Sinner's Prayer vs. Florida!!! (featuring Florence and the Machine)

Come to Mama vs. Guilty as Sin?

Hey Girl (featuring Florence Welch) vs. Who's Afraid of Little Old Me?

Angel Down vs. I Can Fix Him (No Really I Can)

Grigio Girls vs. Loml

Just Another Day vs. I Can Do It with a Broken Heart

Edited August 15, 20251 yr by David_Greengrass97

Both are among the worst albums I've ever listened but at least the Taylor album doesn't have all that shouting Ga Ga calls singing

Only one of them has Grammy's Prayer so

 

Tortured Poets Department is better

Joanne's lead single went #1 in the Louvre. TTPD can't say that

 

If you trim down ttpd there's an album in there. Maybe with some more production

There's like 3 good songs on Joanne and I'm being generous.

It may be Taylor's worst album but it's still much better 

Diamond Heart vs. Fortnight (featuring Post Malone)

A-Yo vs. The Tortured Poets Department

Joanne vs. My Boy Only Breaks His Favorite Toys

John Wayne vs. Down Bad

Dancin' in Circles vs. So Long, London

Perfect Illusion vs. But Daddy I Love Him

Million Reasons vs. Fresh Out the Slammer

Sinner's Prayer vs. Florida!!! (featuring Florence and the Machine)

Come to Mama vs. Guilty as Sin?

Hey Girl (featuring Florence Welch) vs. Who's Afraid of Little Old Me?

Angel Down vs. I Can Fix Him (No Really I Can)

Grigio Girls vs. Loml

Just Another Day vs. I Can Do It with a Broken Heart

 

Joanne: 4

TTPD: 9

 

Gaga I am so sorry...

6 minutes ago, Digitalism said:

If you trim down ttpd there's an album in there. Maybe with some more production

There's like 3 good songs on Joanne and I'm being generous.

This. Despite TTPD being bloated, you can at least get 13 solid songs out of it. Joanme is just sad all around. Which is a shame cause it has some very solid 5 songs in it. 

I'm gonna go with the one that has Just Another Day

11 minutes ago, B-Luke said:

Only one of them has Grammy's Prayer so

 

Only one of them has a Grammy, period.

Diamond Heart vs. Fortnight (featuring Post Malone)

A-YO vs. The Tortured Poets Department

Joanne vs. My Boy Only Breaks His Favorite Toys

John Wayne vs. Down Bad

Dancin' In Circles vs. So Long, London

Perfect Illusion vs. But Daddy I Love Him

Million Reasons vs. Fresh Out the Slammer

Sinner's Prayer vs. Florida!!! (featuring Florence + the Machine)

Come to Mama vs. Guilty as Sin?

Hey Girl (featuring Florence Welch) vs. Who's Afraid of Little Old Me?

Angel Down vs. I Can Fix Him (No Really I Can)

Grigio Girls vs. loml

Just Another Day vs. I Can Do It With a Broken Heart

Perfect Illusion wins this one, but without it my vote would go for TTPD I fear