P!nk is silently killing it in the music game, yet gets no fanfare. Why?

[Feanor]

 

P!nk is an incredible live performer and one of the biggest female artists ever. Among the early 2000s pop girls, she's only behind Beyoncé and Shakira in total Spotify streams, which highlights the longevity she has had in this business.

 

And she shines the most in touring, where she currently has the 2nd biggest female tour of all time.

Even before Taylor Swift & Beyoncé became the first to surpass Madonna's long-standing record of biggest female tour ever, it was actually P!nk who came closest to breaking that record with her Beautiful Trauma World Tour in 2018/19.

 

She has the hits, she has the successful albums, she has the longevity, she is an undeniable talent and she's a force in touring… all things stans love to brag about. However her presence in stan circles like Twitter or ATRL is rather muted, to put it mildly. Even the media often ignores her, like they did last year when the Eras vs. Renaissance tour comparisons were rampant, even tho P!nk herself was also on a huge tour.

 

P!nk is silently killing it in the music game, yet gets little to no fanfare from online stan culture & the media. Why?

 

 

Edited 3 hours ago by Feanor

[Radical Pessimism]

Her fans are older and have no time to meddle in silly stan wars. They're busy buying her tickets instead.

[Kern]

Because she hasn't released anything interesting for many years now. 

[Mrnoniee]

for Fanfare you need to be Interesting and she's not
She's a Zionist deserve NO success which she has got

I hope she remains ABSENT
Such pro genocide / pro killing voices need NO mainstream publicity

[Europe]

I think she prefers it this way. If you think about it, she has a very successful career but also a semblance of normalcy. A little bit like Lana but there is more of a cult aound her.

[Technicolor]

She is not a tabloid figure and most of her fans are not into stan culture

Edited 2 hours ago by Technicolor

[Janet]

Boring. Simple as that 

[Junlin]

lesbians are boring online. 

 

[Bumba]

Because gays get threatened by a strong independent butch woman. 

Edited 2 hours ago by Bumba

[glitch]

Pink, get doon

[kellebrity98]

she's still topping the album charts, her singles get certified and charting, none of her peers can say this

Edited 2 hours ago by kellebrity98

[sherloid_bai]

The LGBT acrobat market is unrealised

[itshyolee]

 

37 minutes ago, Radical Pessimism said:

Her fans are older and have no time to meddle in silly stan wars. They're busy buying her tickets instead.

This. I'm sure all the soccer moms and middle aged Lesbians used to windmill on everyone for her on message boards from back in the day, but they grew up and Pink just doesn't have a young fanbase that will go to war for her unlike the other MPGs of her generation and before.

[Mr.X]

She's a zionist monster, I hope she ******* rots in hell

[smartalek22]

Online male gay spaces presence ≠ the entirety of fanfare

 

The former and real life commercial success typically do not come hand in hand, actually. 

Edited 2 hours ago by smartalek22

[P!NK2LOVE]

11 minutes ago, Mr.X said:

She's a zionist monster, I hope she ******* rots in hell

So even if she is that, is wishing her eternal suffering in hell really a morally superior thing to say? Like do you people hear yourselves? 

[prettyinpink940]

She stays out of the limelight.

She never attends events.

She doesn't have any scandals.

 

[prettyinpink940]

14 minutes ago, Mr.X said:

She's a zionist monster, I hope she ******* rots in hell

how do you know? 

[Mr.X]

3 minutes ago, P!NK2LOVE said:

So even if she is that, is wishing her eternal suffering in hell really a morally superior thing to say? Like do you people hear yourselves? 

I never claimed moral superiority, hun. Just that people who support occupations, zionism and genocide should rot in hell. That's it.

[P!NK2LOVE]

3 minutes ago, Mr.X said:

I never claimed moral superiority, hun. Just that people who support occupations, zionism and genocide should rot in hell. That's it.

She's a good person from what I've seen. Shame on you for being so quick to wish hell upon her. If anything, you should be praying that they change their minds. Not reacting with such hatred. Hope you find some peace.  

[Gelato]

because atrl is for middle aged males, not middle aged females

[Danny789]

If people are buying her tickets then she has fanfare. Twitter and ATRL are not the standard. 

[Dante Silva]

She makes the same album to the same formula, over and over again.

[Marla Singer]

Because she outlasted the likes of Britney and Christina and has proven to be significantly bigger and better than them in every way imaginable, and online pop stans just aren't prepared to admit that.