Perfect Stranger vs. Good Luck, Babe!

[GraceRandolph]

 

[halcyonday]

Good Luck Babe, sweetie

[Thin White Duke]

A weird comparison, but ok.

Anyway, Twigs over everything. That outro alone 

[Post Malone]

I was like not the jonas blue song from 2016

[JoeAg]

Perfect Stranger isn't a hit  I mean I WISH it could be! FKA twigs and Banks obviously both deserve their Brat moments and I been saying this for a moment now! the two underappreciated art pop queens of today 

 

but yeah

 

bigger hit: Good Luck, Babe!

better song: Perfect Stranger

superior artistry exhibited: Perfect Stranger 

 

I like Good Luck, Babe! a lot too but it's not quite at the pop perfection level of Perfect Stranger even though it's still a great, summery song! Perfect Stranger just feels like an ALL seasons classic, whereas GL,B! for some reason doesn't sound as appealing to listen to in the winter months? idk how to explain why it feels this way tbh. I'd say Chappell's

best song is STILL Red Wine Supernova 

[crf13]

Twigs, I'm so sorry… 

[makeawish]

traditionally i don't really like twigs but i keep hearing perfect stranger on the radio and it's really good 

 

meanwhile i have battered good luck babe all year to the point where i'm struggling to be so bothered about it now (tho that doesn't take away how much i've enjoyed it already)

 

as such, this is a tricky multi dimensional question that cannot be answered in a simply yes/no format