Recently on ATRL there's been lots of discussion surrounding Lady Gaga and Katy Perry about whether both stars are in the "same boat". However, with much of this discussion focused on their music release, what with recent releases from both stars having shaking starts (or in some cases, filing to even start), I thought it would be interesting to compare the acting careers of both of them, and discuss who clears in that area, or if they're "boatmates" here as well.Included below is a selection of both stars' filmographies, not comprehensive by any means bc i cba to sift through all the "appears as herself" roles in each filmography to decide what was worth including. Feel free to compare both the selection below and their full filmographies (linked in each of their names) for yourself.

Lady Gaga:

Film:

• Machete Kills (2013), supporting role
• Sin City: A Dame To Kill For (2014), supporting role
• Gaga: Five Foot Two (2017), documentary
• A Star Is Born (2018), main role
• House of Gucci (2021), main role
• Joker: Folie à Deux (2024), main role

   TV:

• American Horror Story: Hotel (2015), main role
• American Horror Story: Roanoke (2016) (guest star)

 

Katy Perry

Film:

• The Smurfs (2011), main role, voice (Smurfette)
• Kety Perr: Pert of Me 3D (2012), documentary
• The Smurfs 2 (2013), main role, voice (Smurfette)

TV:

• How I Met Your Mother (2011) guest stay, 1 episode
• Raising Hope (2012) guest star, 1 episode

 

Who has the best acting career? Whose is bigger, and who has displayed superior acting abilities? Research, vote and discuss.

i'm tired... 

GaGa is the Katy Perry of the acting industry:

 

Boiling Points - Katy Hudson

AHS - OOTB

ASIB - TD

HoG - Prism

J:FAD - Witness

 

 

 

You all be saying anything these days 

Anyway. 

Gaga's run from American Horror Story Hotel, A Star is Born, House of Gucci and Joker >>>>>>>>>>

You know it's gaga. We know it's gaga. What are we doing here 

1 minute ago, perfect blue said:

GaGa is the Katy Perry of the acting industry:

 

Boiling Points - Katy Hudson

AHS - OOTB

ASIB - TD

HoG - Prism

J:FAD - Witness

 

 

 

Her smile and 143 is coming then 

Gaga may have a shaky time, but this shouldn't even be a question. You're taking it too far 

Smurfs>>>>>>>>the other

Number of Lady Gaga movies that turned a profit during their theatrical run: 1

Number of Katy Perry movies that turned a profit during their theatrical run: 3 

Only beloved Hollywood actress Katy Perry. She should return to theatrical motion pictures. She clearly has a knack for it! 
 

 

Edited November 14, 20241 yr by Stunnah

I mean, Katy hasn't done anything remarkable  

Just now, UnusualBoy said:

I mean, Katy hasn't done anything remarkable  

Except for consistently turning a profit at the box office! 

Reported cos i'm tired

The one with smash franchise the Smurfs of course

Katy sweetie

Ali Larter >>>

33 minutes ago, halcyonday said:

The one with smash franchise the Smurfs of course

i need you to turn a liddo asap i can't do this anymore sistren... 

16 minutes ago, RideOrDie said:

i need you to turn a liddo asap i can't do this anymore sistren... 

how about you tell her to produce new excellence ala TEOG and i just might

Where's Katy's "acting career"?

Gaga just BOMBED 200m. Like she flat out ate 200m.

 

I am sure that's more harm than any of Katy's flops in any sector COMBINED.

Edited November 14, 20241 yr by P.O.P

19 minutes ago, halcyonday said:

how about you tell her to produce new excellence ala TEOG and i just might

oh i didn't know your standards were set to excellence considering who you stan for... be serious! 

6 minutes ago, RideOrDie said:

oh i didn't know your standards were set to excellence considering who you stan for... be serious! 

ooouh not the shade...  fine, i'll take anything where she doesn't scream with the theatre vocals nnnn