this pic 

Clearly Beyonce in every way. Even in terms of the very subjective definition of "impact" ATRL has Beyonce destroys her.

Beyoncé in every way 

oh this nasty setup for miss spears 

 

Beyonce of course since 2003  

3 hours ago, Jeremiah said:

Like fave, like fan

 

wtf is this gif  

The way y’all disrespect the First Lady of music on this site should be study 

Beyonce. 

 

My my how things have changed on ATRL since I joined, never thought I'd see the day when the Army wouldn't dare even enter a Bey vs Brit thread.

The top two girls from their gen, the others can't relate.

Of course it's Bey, she took control and got more creative with her music as time went by, while Britney didn't get a chance to showcase what she could offer in her mature years and ended up not caring about her career for the last 12+ years. Still ate up the rest of her peers tho 

4 hours ago, Jeremiah said:

Like fave, like fan

 

6 hours ago, perfillusion said:

Beyonce. 

 

My my how things have changed on ATRL since I joined, never thought I'd see the day when the Army wouldn't dare even enter a Bey vs Brit thread.

Right ? Even some of the worst Bee haters on their fandom who got exposed several times,pretend to like her now

 

OT: Britney stans better not try it on this one and get ridiculed once again cause they surpassed expectations on the Gaga and Taylor ones 

Tabloid fodder vs Thriving Legend 

 

Beyonce by default

The answer is obviously Beyonce, but part of the reason is obviously her insane PR machinery and Jay-Z's powerful connections.

Queen b winning 

On 4/16/2023 at 6:23 PM, JoAddams said:

this pic 

I legit screamed 

Daily streams:

 

Halo (#5 peak) — 589,092

 

Baby One More time (#1 peak) — 382,409

Womanizer (#1 peak) — 245,196

3 (#1 peak) — 35,775

S&M Remix (#1 peak) — 27,269

Hold It Against Me (#1 peak) — 16,755

 

Both careers are much bigger than the OP’s fave, Christina Aguilera 

Beyoncé is respected and has a reputation for live, great vocals. She wins

18 hours ago, Majka Jeżowska said:

Daily streams:

 

Halo (#5 peak) — 589,092

 

Baby One More time (#1 peak) — 382,409

 

Break My Soul 2020 #1 w/ 80m playlisting 370k daily streams

 

Welp

 

Her streams are actually lowkey better than Bey's (let alone xtina's)

Edited April 21, 20233 yr by Mr. Stratus

On 4/16/2023 at 10:39 PM, LittleStarmen said:

its like marylin vs elizabeth taylor

 

Elizabeth taylor had a bigger carreerr and better films but marylin had a bigger media personality

No. Beyoncé has the bigger media personality too

9 minutes ago, Mr. Stratus said:

Break My Soul 2020 #1 w/ 80m playlisting 370k daily streams

 

Welp

 

Her streams are actually lowkey better than Bey's (let alone xtina's)

You're obsessed with Xtina, it's really sad. :(

On 4/17/2023 at 3:47 AM, Majka Jeżowska said:

No, it's like Prince vs Milli Vanilli

I-  

 

OT: clearly Beyoncé since '03

On 4/21/2023 at 4:15 PM, Icarus said:

No. Beyoncé has the bigger media personality too

How does Beyonce have a bigger media personality than Britney? I'm not even a Britney stan. Maybe what you mean is, Beyonce and JayZ are a bigger power couple than Britney and Sam (who is a nobody). Bey solo media personality aint all that, it's tied to being a power billionaire couple.