If Loser surpasses Speak Now I will riot 

Melanie 

Loser  But it makes sense since Tay Tay's breakup is THE event of the year.

 

Melanie

Taylor two albums top 10

51 minutes ago, family.guy123 said:

2006-2010 really was her peak. both chart wise and musically

How is that the case when her best-selling album WW to date came out in 2014 and she just had a record-shattering era that established her as the biggest pop star of her time?  She was practically unknown outside of the US before 2012. And what exactly did she achieve chart-wise in 2006, 2007 and 2010? Self-titled accumulated its sales over a long period of time but isn't really known for much else – it didn't go #1, didn't spawn any notable singles (in terms of chart performance) and is her only album that doesn't chart recurrently. Fearless stands on its own for sure, but Speak Now's singles failed to make a dent like other eras despite its first-week sales, nor did the album itself have the longevity of its successors and predecessor.

 

Self-titled and Fearless are objectively her weakest albums to date so I don't know how either could be considered a musical peak, though that's just my opinion.

Edited April 11, 20233 yr by Carry My Heart

22 minutes ago, FolkLover1989 said:

Rep has a multi week #1 single

And multi week #1 album

 

 

Does Lover has that ?? 

 

Lover is cute but there is a reason Reputation production is best in Eras Tour 

Logevity >>> Quick little peaks 

 

Reputation is forgotten by the GP, while Lover is thriving.

1 hour ago, FolkLover1989 said:

Lover is her 7th biggest album 

 

All her first 6 albums are bigger

 

Debut and Red 8x plat

SN 7x plat+

1989 close to 12x plat

Fearless close to 12x plat

Rep 5x plat+

how much has lover done so far?

 

feel like it will easily outsell sn and rep at least (not accounting for possible TV smashage)

They should add All Of The Girls You Loved Before to the album and it will be even higher. I don't understand why they haven't done it yet.

Lover = WINNER

Little MAGAts = LOSERS

Morgan doing like 150k on SEA

After she’s done with the re-recordings, she should honestly re-package the album and re-rerelease it.

 

Delete, ME!, YTCD and The man.

 

Release Cruel Summer as a single with a video

 

And release 2 new vault tracks

 

It would smash so hard  

Edited April 11, 20233 yr by Trent W

50 minutes ago, FolkLover1989 said:

Well even in the world it's below

 

1989 , Fearless,  Red , Speak Now and Reputation for Now

 

 

Well, yes, but that’s only because it’s way newer and albums take a lot longer to move units, albeit obviously more consistently than before, in the streaming era. Of course those old albums, which were also huge, have way more units. Lover is easily her 3rd biggest album on a worldwide scale behind 1989 and Midnights. Red is of course bigger overall but not as big in Asia or Europe as Lover (basically outside US in general). The same goes for the US numbers, it’ll probably settle behind 1989, Fearless, Midnights and Red with ease, judging by the amount of units it’s moving each week (32k )

 

Wow at it re-entering the top 10 though, hopefully it doesn’t end up at #11 

What in the world? Would be a staple in the top 10 if AOTG was included.

 

something about her first fully owned record smashing years later makes me happy

somehow it always stays there  miss americana better carry

7 minutes ago, Holiest Dreams said:

Well, yes, but that’s only because it’s way newer and albums take a lot longer to move units, albeit obviously more consistently than before, in the streaming era. Of course those old albums, which were also huge, have way more units. Lover is easily her 3rd biggest album on a worldwide scale behind 1989 and Midnights. Red is of course bigger overall but not as big in Asia or Europe as Lover (basically outside US in general). The same goes for the US numbers, it’ll probably settle behind 1989, Fearless, Midnights and Red with ease, judging by the amount of units it’s moving each week (32k )

 

Wow at it re-entering the top 10 though, hopefully it doesn’t end up at #11 

Lover is not big as Red or Fearless anywhere

 

Everybody knows YBWM , LS , WANGEBT,  IKYWT 

 

1 hour ago, kimberly said:

Lover had already surpassed Reputation by 2021 on the Billboard 200 Greatest of All-Time list:

 

 

 

The way Reputation was kind of a flop for Taylor’s insane standards  

49 minutes ago, Ger-55 said:

Loser  But it makes sense since Tay Tay's breakup is THE event of the year.

 

Melanie

It's weirdly predicted to do only like 1k more than last week. Seems a bit low to me 

 

Easter hurt everyone a bit, okay, but 

Great hold for Melanie, even lana top20 

false god did that 

 

ready for the resurrection of the iconic ME! 

2 hours ago, Carry My Heart said:

How is that the case when her best-selling album WW to date came out in 2014 and she just had a record-shattering era that established her as the biggest pop star of her time?  She was practically unknown outside of the US before 2012. And what exactly did she achieve chart-wise in 2006, 2007 and 2010? Self-titled accumulated its sales over a long period of time but isn't really known for much else – it didn't go #1, didn't spawn any notable singles (in terms of chart performance) and is her only album that doesn't chart recurrently. Fearless stands on its own for sure, but Speak Now's singles failed to make a dent like other eras despite its first-week sales, nor did the album itself have the longevity of its successors and predecessor.

 

Self-titled and Fearless are objectively her weakest albums to date so I don't know how either could be considered a musical peak, though that's just my opinion.

It's important to remember that Self-Titled is the longest charting album of the 00s in the US. I mean that's quite impressive considering how different he music industry was back then.

 

2 hours ago, Space Cowboy said:

Logevity >>> Quick little peaks 

 

Reputation is forgotten by the GP, while Lover is thriving.

Suuuuuuure, keep telling yourself that 

 

The way people are so desperate to hate on Reputation is beyond weird at this point. And it's only happening on pop forums for some reason.

1 hour ago, FolkLover1989 said:

Rep has a multi week #1 single

And multi week #1 album

 

 

Does Lover has that ?? 

 

Lover is cute but there is a reason Reputation production is best in Eras Tour 

The rep set is my pee break tbh. 

Melanie a second week top 5, great hold 

 

Taylor back in the top 3  Along with L(over) going top 10 again almost 4 years later 

it should have been reputation 

 

i cant

2 hours ago, UseYourIllusion2002 said:

Is Lover her biggest album at this point? Does anybody know the Soundscan sales or SPS of all her albums? This is insane. Considering the fact people called it a flop at one point (which it never was). 

Lover is not even close to being at the same level as 1989, Red, Fearless etc