Saying you only know 4 Madonna songs is alright seeing as the GP barely knows ANY of Gaga's songs.

 

 

 

Imagine openly saying "Lovegame" is a...classic.

15 minutes ago, Jjang said:

CSPC album equivalent sales: 

 

1. 2008 – Lady Gaga – Poker Face [The Fame / The Fame Monster] – 7,140,000
2. 2009 – Lady Gaga – Bad Romance [The Fame / The Fame Monster] – 7,100,000
3. 2009 – Lady Gaga ft. Beyoncé – Telephone [The Fame / The Fame Monster] – 4,880,000
4. 2008 – Lady Gaga ft. Colby O’Donis – Just Dance [The Fame / The Fame Monster] – 4,710,000
5. 2011 – Lady Gaga – Born This Way [Born This Way] – 4,120,000
6. 2018 – Lady Gaga & Bradley Cooper – Shallow [A Star Is Born] – 3,310,000
7. 2009 – Lady Gaga – Alejandro [The Fame / The Fame Monster] – 3,010,000
8. 2008 – Lady Gaga – Paparazzi [The Fame / The Fame Monster] – 2,770,000
9. 2011 – Lady Gaga – The Edge Of Glory [Born This Way] – 2,220,000
10. 2013 – Lady Gaga – Applause [Artpop] – 1,860,000
11. 2011 – Lady Gaga – Judas [Born This Way] – 1,730,000
12. 2008 – Lady Gaga – LoveGame [The Fame / The Fame Monster] – 1,640,000
13. 2011 – Lady Gaga – Yoü And I [Born This Way] – 1,510,000
14. 2016 – Lady Gaga – Million Reasons [Joanne] – 1,400,000

 

1. 1989 – Like A Prayer [Like A Prayer] – 18,550,000
2. 1984 – Like A Virgin [Like A Virgin] – 15,210,000
3. 1986 – La Isla Bonita [True Blue] – 14,160,000
4. 1984 – Material Girl [Like A Virgin] – 12,550,000
5. 1990 – Vogue [I’m Breathless] – 11,790,000
6. 1983 – Holiday [Madonna] – 9,310,000
7. 1984 – Into The Groove [Like A Virgin] – 8,860,000
8. 1986 – Papa Don’t Preach [True Blue] – 8,460,000
9. 1998 – Frozen [Ray Of Light] – 8,340,000
10. 2005 – Hung Up [Confessions On A Dance Floor] – 7,470,000
11. 2000 – Music [Music] – 6,470,000
12. 1986 – Live To Tell [True Blue] – 6,440,000
13. 1998 – Ray Of Light [Ray Of Light] – 5,720,000
14. 1994 – Take A Bow [Bedtime Stories] – 5,420,000
15. 1985 – Crazy for You [Orphan] – 4,660,000
16. 1987 – Who’s That Girl [Who’s That Girl] – 4,620,000
17. 1986 – Open Your Heart [True Blue] – 4,440,000
18. 1983 – Borderline [Madonna] – 3,670,000
19. 2008 – 4 Minutes [Hard Candy] – 3,570,000
20. 1989 – Express Yourself [Like A Prayer] – 3,450,000

 

 

i mean you didn't have to pull this but i see that the few monsters tried it.

 

 

if the GP only knows 4 madonna songs then the GP also only knows BR and Shallow 

 

3 hours ago, besaid said:

The set up  Madonna against any other female automatically wins.

This is factually incorrect when artists such as Whitney Houston and Celine Dion still have a discography. 
 

 

I love Madonna, and I stan her, but I also stan others so let’s not. 
 

Madonna only objectively wins against 21st century debuting artists because, whereas there may be acts like Rihanna who have many “modern classics” for our time, they’re still too new to stand against those from 20-30+ years ago. Madonna has peers who have just as many, if not bigger classics. 

Edited March 4, 20233 yr by GoodGuyGoneGhetto

26 minutes ago, GoodGuyGoneGhetto said:

This is factually incorrect when artists such as Whitney Houston and Celine Dion still have a discography. 
 

 

I love Madonna, and I stan her, but I also stan others so let’s not. 
 

Madonna only objectively wins against 21st century debuting artists because, whereas there may be acts like Rihanna who have many “modern classics” for our time, they’re still too new to stand against those from 20-30+ years ago. Madonna has peers who have just as many, if not bigger classics. 

There is a reason why Madonna has the best-selling solo greatest hits album of all time.

1 hour ago, GoodGuyGoneGhetto said:

This is factually incorrect when artists such as Whitney Houston and Celine Dion still have a discography. 
 

 

I love Madonna, and I stan her, but I also stan others so let’s not. 
 

Madonna only objectively wins against 21st century debuting artists because, whereas there may be acts like Rihanna who have many “modern classics” for our time, they’re still too new to stand against those from 20-30+ years ago. Madonna has peers who have just as many, if not bigger classics. 

Whitney and especially Celine cannot compete with Madonna in terms of classics. At all. They might come closer than the likes of Britney, Katy or Rihanna but Madonna is the queen of pop for a reason. 

15 minutes ago, besaid said:

Whitney and especially Celine cannot compete with Madonna in terms of classics. At all.

Gaga.
Madonna's first 15 years are erased and the few people from this generation who know her probably only know her for things like using the N word.

I'm not a huge fan of either, but off the top of my head:

Gaga:
Just Dance
Poker Face

Born This Way

Shallow

 

Madonna:

Material Girl

Like a Virgin

Like a Prayer

Papa Don't Preach 

Vogue

Frozen

Maybe Borderline?

 

I assume Music and Hung Up are too late.

 

EDIT:
Not me forgetting Bad Romance, La Isla Bonita, Holiday, and Into the Groove

Edited March 5, 20233 yr by Tylerbv
I'm stupid

I don't know Madonna so GaGa 

Why would you set Gaga up like this? 
 

it’s not 2012 anymore.  

Just now, Juanny said:

Music and Hung Up were released before Gaga's debut. If those songs are too late, Gaga's entire catalog is too late.

I meant they're not within the first 15 years of Madonna's career.

Gaga doesn't even have 15 years worth of classics she has 3.5 Eras (The Fame/Monster, Born This Way & A Star Is Born) Madonna has classics on classics on classics

11 minutes ago, Juanny said:

Oh I see, I completely forgot the thread is calling for the first 15 years!

It’s hard to keep track when Madonna has hits across like 4 decades  

Why you’re setting up miss Gaga like that 

 

Madonna and it’s NOT even close 

Edited March 5, 20233 yr by Gottasadae

How is this even a comparison??? Insecure? Jealousy? Why dont yall compare her with her peers?

 

Madonna classic isn’t as big as her stan want us to believe

Compared to her peers, she had no billion (youtube or spotify) song like majority of her peers have. 
The definition of classic is being remembered years later and that can be proven by current STAT.

 

 

 

Madonna for all. She has TRUE timeless classics. 

Never heard a single Madonna song ever before joining this site.

Does she even have a single song above 500M streams on Spotify? She's clearly a forgotten fad from ancient times. So Gaga easily. Poker face, Bad Romance and Shallow are infinitely bigger than all of Madonna's forgotten hits

6 hours ago, Elusive Chanteuse said:

GaGa only has Bad Romance and Born This Way. 

Lol and Born this way is a Madonna song bassically 

1 hour ago, My Tears Ricochet said:

Does she even have a single song above 500M streams on Spotify?

Does Lady Gaga have a Diamond album?

Madonna, clearly 

 

Some of the songs being listed as classics in here…

Imagine anyone asking this with a straight face. Gaga can’t even compete with Paula Abdul here.

6 hours ago, My Tears Ricochet said:

Never heard a single Madonna song ever before joining this site.

Why would you wear ignorance like a badge? Glad ATRL could help.

 

6 hours ago, My Tears Ricochet said:

She's clearly a forgotten fad from ancient times.

...could you define "fad" for us?

 

6 hours ago, My Tears Ricochet said:

Does she even have a single song above 500M streams on Spotify?

500M streams is less than 150,000 units. That's an amount Madonna has bested many times--which she also did when music cost more to purchase. 

 

This really wasn't the drag that you thought it was. In the history of music, streaming has been around for roughly 20 years. It's a sliver of the story.

This thread is hiarlious because Madonna is the biggest Female artist in history.