2 minutes ago, Shelter said:

Xder is so mad 

No I'm not

6 minutes ago, Xder said:

nobody even plays it on the radio

First you discuss 100 million streams.

 

Then you mention it being played on the radio.

 

Which is it?

 

And for your information, Vogue does get recurrent play on the radio.

 

Are you joking?

3 minutes ago, Xder said:

It shows me 320m have you added remixes, other versions?

Other versions?

 

You do know other artists literally combine all versions of their songs on Spotify, right?

 

Why is Madonna getting called out?

 

2 minutes ago, Xder said:

It shows me 320m have you added remixes, other versions?

Madonna's streams are scattered across different albums. The numbers I posted are genuine numbers. Shooketh a bit perhaps? 

 

 

 

 

 

 

... you got the memo 

 

 

 

 

9 minutes ago, The Second Coming said:

I guess we already have a winner for the moronic thread of the year

More like moronic users.

Also how about Ray of light? That single screams CLASSIC

 

 

Also how about Open your Heart? Whew she has too many classics..

 

 

 

 

22 minutes ago, Jjang said:

Material Girl - 372,554,103

Like a Prayer - 350,946,122 

La Isla Bonita - 280,936,980

Like A Virgin - 260,291,013 

.

.

.

Vogue - 204,727,526 

Wait, when did Madonna’s streams increase so much? Better playlisting I guess?

 

They used to be tragic but this is more fitting for the Queen of Pop  

57 minutes ago, GraceRandolph said:

In 2023 it's not a classic. Poll people and see how many people can name it as a Madonna song.

People don't suffer from amnesia. For those people for whom it was a classic, it remains a classic. Of course if you're gonna ask random people on the street, more people would name Gaga songs because they were released within the most recent generation. 

 

your poll didn't prove your point either

GaGa only has Bad Romance and Born This Way. 

Gaga.

 This isn’t a serious question right? 

Edited March 4, 20233 yr by LikeaRebel

56 minutes ago, CaptainMusic said:

Wait, when did Madonna’s streams increase so much? Better playlisting I guess?

 

They used to be tragic but this is more fitting for the Queen of Pop  

Still sh!tty playlisting overall tbh lol

 

Also, those were just a few from the first 15 years of her career since that's the topic of this thread 

 

3/3 update 

 

Hung Up - 326,311,786 (+300,375)

4 Minutes - 253,813,157 (+275,812)

This is subjective, but the songs that I feel have had a certain level of continued cultural impact within that time period would be the following (fully understanding that this is an unfair battle for GaGa, whose most recent output has yet to be tested by time):

 

Lucky Star

Holiday

Like a Virgin

Material Girl

Into the Groove

Dress You Up

Papa Don't Preach

La Isla Bonita

Like a Prayer

Express Yourself

Vogue

Take a Bow

Don't Cry for Me Argentina

 

Just Dance

Paparazzi

Poker Face

Bad Romance

Born This Way

Telephone

The Edge of Glory

Bloody Mary

Shallow

Rain on Me

 

Honestly, for a thread designed to diss GaGa, she definitely held her own.

are you being for real? 

Some of y’all really can’t read. FIRST 15 YEARS…

 

anyway:

Holiday

Like A Virgin

Material Girl

Crazy For You (?)

Into The Groove

Papa Don’t Preach

Open Your Heart

La Isla Bonita

Like A Prayer 

Express Yourself

Vogue

 

v

 

Just Dance

Pokerface

Lovegame (?)

Paparazzi

Bad Romance

Telephone

Alejandro

Born This Way

Shallow

Rain on Me 

 

 

So Madge wins by 1 

I don’t know any Madonna songs other than like 3-4 (GP teas). Gaga has gay classics BTW/ROM then universal smash classic shallow like this may have set M up.

Madonna effortlessly clears and washes that other woman

2 minutes ago, Mr. Stratus said:

I don’t know any Madonna songs other than like 3-4 (GP teas).

That sounds like a YOU problem 

9 minutes ago, Pud said:

Some of y’all really can’t read. FIRST 15 YEARS…

 

anyway:

Holiday

Like A Virgin

Material Girl

Crazy For You (?)

Into The Groove

Papa Don’t Preach

Open Your Heart

La Isla Bonita

Like A Prayer 

Express Yourself

Vogue

 

v

 

Just Dance

Pokerface

Lovegame (?)

Paparazzi

Bad Romance

Telephone

Alejandro

Born This Way

Shallow

Rain on Me 

 

 

So Madge wins by 1 

ROM and Lovegame classics? 

Lady Gaga - 15 classics so far, one per year on avg. 

Just Dance

Poker Face

LoveGame

Paparazzi

Bad Romance

Telephone

Alejandro

Born This Way

The Edge of Glory

You and I

Applause

Million Reasons

Shallow

Always Remember Us This Way

Bloody Mary

 

Madonna - 30 classics up until 1997, twice as many per year  (sorry to the liddos who don't wanna hear it but I gotta keep it real)

Everybody

Holiday

Lucky Star

Borderline

Like a Virgin

Material Girl

Crazy for You

Into the Groove

Dress You Up

Live to Tell

Papa Don't Preach

True Blue

Open Your Heart

La Isla Bonita

Who's That Girl

Like a Prayer

Express Yourself

Cherish

Til Death Do Us Part

Spanish Eyes

Vogue

Justify My Love

Erotica

Deeper and Deeper

Bad Girl

Rain

Secret

Take a Bow

Human Nature

Don't Cry for Me Argentina (Miami Mix)

 

 

3 minutes ago, brenda-walsh said:

ROM and Lovegame classics? 

Both were big hits at the time and are now known by Gen Z thanks to tik tok 

 

“I wanna take a ride on your disco stick” is iconic, like it or not

CSPC album equivalent sales: 

 

1. 2008 – Lady Gaga – Poker Face [The Fame / The Fame Monster] – 7,140,000
2. 2009 – Lady Gaga – Bad Romance [The Fame / The Fame Monster] – 7,100,000
3. 2009 – Lady Gaga ft. Beyoncé – Telephone [The Fame / The Fame Monster] – 4,880,000
4. 2008 – Lady Gaga ft. Colby O’Donis – Just Dance [The Fame / The Fame Monster] – 4,710,000
5. 2011 – Lady Gaga – Born This Way [Born This Way] – 4,120,000
6. 2018 – Lady Gaga & Bradley Cooper – Shallow [A Star Is Born] – 3,310,000
7. 2009 – Lady Gaga – Alejandro [The Fame / The Fame Monster] – 3,010,000
8. 2008 – Lady Gaga – Paparazzi [The Fame / The Fame Monster] – 2,770,000
9. 2011 – Lady Gaga – The Edge Of Glory [Born This Way] – 2,220,000
10. 2013 – Lady Gaga – Applause [Artpop] – 1,860,000
11. 2011 – Lady Gaga – Judas [Born This Way] – 1,730,000
12. 2008 – Lady Gaga – LoveGame [The Fame / The Fame Monster] – 1,640,000
13. 2011 – Lady Gaga – Yoü And I [Born This Way] – 1,510,000
14. 2016 – Lady Gaga – Million Reasons [Joanne] – 1,400,000

 

1. 1989 – Like A Prayer [Like A Prayer] – 18,550,000
2. 1984 – Like A Virgin [Like A Virgin] – 15,210,000
3. 1986 – La Isla Bonita [True Blue] – 14,160,000
4. 1984 – Material Girl [Like A Virgin] – 12,550,000
5. 1990 – Vogue [I’m Breathless] – 11,790,000
6. 1983 – Holiday [Madonna] – 9,310,000
7. 1984 – Into The Groove [Like A Virgin] – 8,860,000
8. 1986 – Papa Don’t Preach [True Blue] – 8,460,000
9. 1998 – Frozen [Ray Of Light] – 8,340,000
10. 2005 – Hung Up [Confessions On A Dance Floor] – 7,470,000
11. 2000 – Music [Music] – 6,470,000
12. 1986 – Live To Tell [True Blue] – 6,440,000
13. 1998 – Ray Of Light [Ray Of Light] – 5,720,000
14. 1994 – Take A Bow [Bedtime Stories] – 5,420,000
15. 1985 – Crazy for You [Orphan] – 4,660,000
16. 1987 – Who’s That Girl [Who’s That Girl] – 4,620,000
17. 1986 – Open Your Heart [True Blue] – 4,440,000
18. 1983 – Borderline [Madonna] – 3,670,000
19. 2008 – 4 Minutes [Hard Candy] – 3,570,000
20. 1989 – Express Yourself [Like A Prayer] – 3,450,000

 

 

2 minutes ago, Jjang said:

CSPC album equivalent sales: 

Oops.

Imagine saying "Vogue" isn't a classic. The utter delusion.

18 minutes ago, Mr. Stratus said:

I don’t know any Madonna songs other than like 3-4 (GP teas). Gaga has gay classics BTW/ROM then universal smash classic shallow like this may have set M up.

You don't speak for the GP. It's time you burst that bubble you've been living in for the last 15 years and go and educate yourself on pop culture and the meaning of real classics prior to 2008.

 

The answer is Madonna and always will be. Sorry liddos.