Madonna comeback: Ray of Light vs COADF

[johnny_9ss]

 

vs

 

[smoore95GAGA]

Confessions was bigger and more remembered, but ROL is better 

[Janet]

Confessions for all I fear 

[selena_lavigne]

hmmmmm. i think Ray of Light is the better album but I stream Confessions much more.

[~Start The Music]

ROL is so ******* overrated and boring, COADF I AM SO SORRY

[KatyPrismSpirit]

COADF. ROL is good but kinda boring after one listen. I actually prefer Music and American Life over both of these

[suburbannature]

Neither one was really a comeback because she didn’t go anywhere. 

[Katamari]

Get together and sorry clears but rol will always be the better album

 

rol doesn’t have a I love New York as well so it wins by default

[kyliefever2002]

i think rol is bigger and more remembered but confessions is better 

[BlackoutZone]

ROL is absolutely the best pop album of all time so that, but I think Hung Up as a comeback is just so massive and remembered it gets Confessions ahead in the success

[Jjang]

Ray of Light - bigger, better. They’re equally remembered. 

[suneclipse121]

Confessions is bigger and better in every way. ROL is boring as hell except Frozen. 

[rebeltwat]

Bigger: ROL

Better: ROL

More Remembered: Confessions

[Homebrand]

1 hour ago, Katamari said:

Get together and sorry clears but rol will always be the better album

 

rol doesn’t have a I love New York as well so it wins by default

Taste

[naval23]

Ray of Light had a holy 1-2 punch of Frozen and Ray of Light and was the definition of a comeback 

 

Confessions was absolutely a behemoth with "Hung Up" but it kind of died down after that lead single 

 

 

[Bones]

I feel like confessions was bigger and prolly more remembered I mean even Kim Petra’s was talking about it the other day but ray of light is exquisite and is just really dreamy and you feel like you’re inside the water when you hear it lol

[byzantium]

RoL easily.  Obviously.

[Lead Cenobite]

Ray of Light 3/3

[Chris]

People saying Ray of Light is boring and overrated.

 

Clean your ears please.

 

Edited February 5, 2023 by Chris

[ebaby]

Slay of Light >>>>
 

[LikeaRebel]

ROL was bigger but I prefer COADF. 

[Pristine]

ROL. even Music better than that Abba album 

[skizzo]

ROL for all 3 options

[Blackout2006]

Certain users calling ROL overrated or boring?  Thread is a semi-block list 

 

Bigger: ROL

Better: ROL

Remembered: COADF

[Blackout2006]

10 hours ago, suburbannature said:

Neither one was really a comeback because she didn’t go anywhere. 

It means comeback in the terms of success.