Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

ATRL

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.
Login issues

Smash hits that effectively ended an artist's dominance?

Featured Replies

Girlfriend by Avril was a massive smash, briefly dethroning Complicated as her signature song. However, it was ultimately the kiss of death for her time at the top, as every lead single that followed was essentially an attempt to recreate it with diminishing results each time.

 

Somewhat similarly, Dark Horse by Katy cannibalized the entire Prism era and became her biggest global smash (if I'm not mistaken). But after that, its follow-up singles Birthday and This Is How We Do did not become hits, and as we all know Witness and the rest is history.

 

Which other artists were swallowed by their last massive smash?

  • Replies 50
  • Views 3.9k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Die Young

Touch My Body
Blinding Lights came to mind but that’s not really accurate

Wrecking Ball/We Can't Stop were such huge events but they turned  Miley into a laughing stock also and despite her peaking artistically with Plastic Hearts I feel like she will never have a huge smash again because GP will always remember her cringe Bangerz image

10 minutes ago, collin said:

Die Young

Touch My Body
Blinding Lights came to mind but that’s not really accurate

I feel lowkey you are wrong for all of these 

 

Kesha was on her way out, her entire style of music was left behind in 2011/2012 days, Adele dropped 21 then everyone was just doing ballads, DY had nothing to do with it

Mariah was a veteran at that point I mean Touch My Body was her last chance to have a #1 smash due to her age and Obsessed was a cute semi hit

 

If The Weeknd underperforms again yeah I would agree but I feel like Dawn fm just came too early and is sonically way too similar, I feel he can easily have another huge ww smash as long as it sounds different

Edited by M!X

Wrecking Ball, more specifically the video, is the correct answer. It boxed her as only a professional shock value act. When Madonna, Janet or even Xtina pushed it too far with a single, they knew to tone it down when it was time to promote the ballads (see: Live to Tell, Again, Beautiful).

 

WCS was a necessary step to destroy the remains of her Disney image, but WB felt like a step too far. Couple that with her disappearing from the pop scene for some 4 years and it's not hard to understand why Younger Now bombed.

Levitating ate up Un Dia, Prisoner, We're Good, Love Again and Demeanor :rip:

 

Thankfully Cold Heart happened and broke up that spell 

Kesha is a complicated one. Die Young was doing really well, but Kesha’s entire brand was injured by the relatively long break she took between eras (she needed the sophmore lead released at latest late Spring 2012) and the controversy around Die Young. Couple that with the fact C’mon was a “more of the same” single release, it was a perfect storm. If she had released something like Last Goodbye, she might have just made it to another era.

After 10 years of big country hits and several pop crossover smashes in addition to several gold and platinum albums, legend Glen Campbell released the million selling hit "Southern Nights" (1977) which became his 2nd Hot 100 #1 (a very rare feat for a country artist).

The song is a classic, however his career declined heavily afterwards, barely scoring 2 more Top 40 pop hits and his follow up albums flopped.

The days of hit making seemed to be gone.

this was the follow up to her first global hit, Don't Call Me Up, but nothing really clicked after this despite numerous attempts. 

 

 

i don't think a song can be so big that it ruins said artists career. blinding lights was massive but the weeknd still got another #1 from the same album after it.

prism and bangerz were horribly mismanaged after dark horse and wrecking ball. birthday and adore you ruined the momentum those songs had going for them.

  • ATRL Moderator
37 minutes ago, collin said:

Die Young

Touch My Body
Blinding Lights
came to mind but that’s not really accurate

?????? :skull:

  • Author
6 minutes ago, Dystopian said:

i don't think a song can be so big that it ruins said artists career. blinding lights was massive but the weeknd still got another #1 from the same album after it.

prism and bangerz were horribly mismanaged after dark horse and wrecking ball. birthday and adore you ruined the momentum those songs had going for them.

I think the post above making the case for Wrecking Ball kind of sums up what I'm trying to get at. Sometimes a smash hit boxes an artist into a sound or image that they then have difficulty escaping from. I would say an example of an artist doing the opposite and actually overcoming the box is Lil Nas X, who didn't erase the memory of Old Town Road but, as he put it, was able to beat the horse boy allegations. His next two smash hits projected wildly different sounds and images than OTR, rebranding him as an artist.

Edited by Beyonnaise

Girlfriend tbh. It was so ubiquitous it killed the whole era and her career.

1 hour ago, Beyonnaise said:

Girlfriend by Avril was a massive smash, briefly dethroning Complicated as her signature song. However, it was ultimately the kiss of death for her time at the top, as every lead single that followed was essentially an attempt to recreate it with diminishing results each time.

 

Somewhat similarly, Dark Horse by Katy cannibalized the entire Prism era and became her biggest global smash (if I'm not mistaken). But after that, its follow-up singles Birthday and This Is How We Do did not become hits, and as we all know Witness and the rest is history.

 

Which other artists were swallowed by their last massive smash?

Dark Horse is like her 6th biggest hit globally. I Kissed A Girl and Hot N Cold are her most global, then California Gurls, Roar and Firework. It’s her biggest hit in the US or second behind firework 

 

Alicia Girl On Fire 

Jlo On The Floor 

 

Edited by VioletsandRoses

1 hour ago, Kimmo said:

 Easy On Me replaced Hello and now she’s stuck in Las Vegas strip :celestial5:

How? Hello was much bigger than EOM?

26 minutes ago, Dystopian said:

i don't think a song can be so big that it ruins said artists career.

"Blurred Lines" is a perfect example of this, though.

Losing my religion 

Smells like teen spirit

Torn (Natalie Imbruglia)

Ironic  (Alanis Morrisette)

Royals

Sucker (j bros) 

Havana 

Without me 

King (years & years)

What about us

Lush Life

Youngblood

 

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.