Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

ATRL

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.
Login issues

Madonna is unable to chart her catalogue, why?

Featured Replies

Week after week we constantly see Essential albums and Greatest Hits Albums from the 70’s, 80’s and 90’s charting on the BB200 and Madonna is always missing. Why is that? Not a factor in 2022?  Noticeably, all the Queens and Kings of their genres are charting this week except for Madonna. 


#20. Elton John - Diamonds

#23. Fleetwood Mac - Rumours

#39. Michael Jackson - Thriller 

#55 Queen - Greatest Hits

#107 Nirvana - Neverland

#114 2 Pac - Greatest Hits

#126 Paul McCartney - The Singles

#134 Bob Marley - The Best of Bob Marley

#142 The Beatles - Revolver

#145 ABBA - Greatest Hits

#153 Journey Greatest Hits

#174 Elvin Presley - The Essential 

#187 Whitney Houston - The Best of Whitney Houston

#197. Stevie Wonder - The Best of Steven Wonder

 

N/A. Madonna’s catalogue.

 

Its about time we have a honest conversation as to why Madonna is unable to chart her catalogue of music.

 

spacer.png


 

  • Replies 97
  • Views 5.7k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • Author
Just now, Jynx said:

How can her GH catalog not chart with 38 US top 10 hits? Wtf. :rip:

It has been years since it charted on the BB 200. :gaycat7:

I think she's more of a singles artist. That gif of the Grinch is Madonna every decade trying to hear what the "kids" are listening to 

That’s really sad :chick3:

 

But the honest answer is: she doesn’t have (much) support from the straight community. She’s basically like the Charli XCX or the Tove Lonof the 80’s, but she got lucky to have GP support throughout all of the hits she had. 
 

The sad fact of the matter is a gay audience is a rather small one. The rest of these artists have the support of the greater population.

Just now, WeFoundTrouble said:

That’s really sad :chick3:

 

But the honest answer is: she doesn’t have (much) support from the straight community. She’s basically like the Charli XCX or the Tove Lo of the 80’s, but she got lucky to have GP support throughout all of the hits she had. 
 

The sad fact of the matter is a gay audience is a rather small one. The rest of these artists have the support of the greater population.

 

Sorry for the weird double post thing, I forgot we could edit and accidentally quoted my own post too quickly :rip: Tove Lo* instead of Tove Lonof in my original post BTW. 

8 minutes ago, ThisNihilist said:

I think she's more of a singles artist.

Current BB200 benefits single environment if they got a hit compilation.

I think that Celebration might be able to chart but the way Billboard counts units for GHs is complicated. The fact that Madonna has like 4 GHs makes it difficult for them to chart.
 

And Madonna isn’t a singles artists. Her non-single streams are way better than the likes of Elton. Elton at #20 is kinda insane though. His evergreen hits :lakitu:

half of those are dead and the rest have had significant pushes in recent years

 

plus a good chunk of Madonna’s fanbase being like “streaming is fake!1!1!1!1!” doesn’t help her numbers

  • Author
3 minutes ago, zoldyck said:

Current BB200 benefits single environment if they got a hit compilation.

She did release a greatest hits remix compilation a few months ago and it charted for 1 week. :gaycat7:

15 minutes ago, ThisNihilist said:

I think she's more of a singles artist. That gif of the Grinch is Madonna every decade trying to hear what the "kids" are listening to 


Even if she was (she’s not), Billboard combines all versions of the same song for their charts

 

All units from Like a Virgin (Album Version), Like a Virgin (7’’ Version Edit), Like a Virgin (Dubstep Remix), etc, go to Finally Enough Love (or Celebration, whichever is doing better atm)

This generation don’t care about her, and she hasn’t made an effort to keep a positive outlook on her music. Even her aging fandom is fed up with her. She needs another mainstream comeback Dance album. I mean her legacy will always remain, but she definitely hasn’t been helping it post 2008??

Just now, Gorjesspazze9 said:

This generation don’t care about her, and she hasn’t made an effort to keep a positive outlook on her music. Even her aging fandom is fed up with her. She needs another mainstream comeback Dance album. I mean her legacy will always remain, but she definitely hasn’t been helping it post 2008??

:giraffe:

The only woman i see there is dead.

Where’s Mariah, Celine, Cher, etc?

 

There’s also the fact Madonnas streaming numbers are spread among studio albums, multiple GH albums, etc.

 

we have gone through this before.

2 minutes ago, tiagol88 said:

The only woman i see there is dead.

Where’s Mariah, Celine, Cher, etc?

 

There’s also the fact Madonnas streaming numbers are spread among studio albums, multiple GH albums, etc.

 

we have gone through this before.

This. Close this pointless thread.

3 minutes ago, tiagol88 said:

There’s also the fact Madonnas streaming numbers are spread among studio albums, multiple GH albums, etc.

 

we have gone through this before.

Isn’t that true for most of these artists?

33 minutes ago, WeFoundTrouble said:

That’s really sad :chick3:

 

But the honest answer is: she doesn’t have (much) support from the straight community. She’s basically like the Charli XCX or the Tove Lonof the 80’s, but she got lucky to have GP support throughout all of the hits she had. 
 

The sad fact of the matter is a gay audience is a rather small one. The rest of these artists have the support of the greater population.

I cannot believe you just called the best selling female artist of all time "The Charli XCX or Tove Lo of the 80's" like Google is free 

4 minutes ago, GraceRandolph said:

Isn’t that true for most of these artists?

No. Madonna has the same song’s streams divided among multiple albums. 
The song Like a Prayer has some streams for Celebration (over 200 ou 300M), then like 100M for the parent album, some other millions for The Immaculate Collection :rip:
 

this happens to her entire catalog. Whitney, the only woman charting, if you check like I Wanna Dance with Somebody, she has the same streams for that song no matter what album you listen to lmao. Her GH is the one charting because of that. If her team had done it like Madonna she would be nowhere as well.

  • Author
7 minutes ago, Britney Is Fierce said:

This. Close this pointless thread.

It’s not pointless, it seems like excuses because you don’t agree with the facts considering MJ, Elvis, Whitney, Beatles, Stevie, etc have multiple GH albums but yet they effortlessly chart on the BB200 in the year 2022. :gaycat7:

10 minutes ago, tiagol88 said:

The only woman i see there is dead.

Where’s Mariah, Celine, Cher, etc?

 

There’s also the fact Madonnas streaming numbers are spread among studio albums, multiple GH albums, etc.

 

we have gone through this before.

mariah has an album charting every year so not a good example. she also outstreams madonna by far on the us

celine has pretty luckluster streaming numbers for her sales, though she doesn't have to prove anything

and cher? well she wasn't an album singer, her only studio albums to do decently are heart of stone and bellive

but there are several other reasons: she has many GH albums and many studio albums, she is more of a global artist with pretty small % of her streams soming from the us and most of those artists are bigger on streaming

Madonna is the white Beyonce. Local, pay 4 play, and drops off the charts fast.

not people saying the best selling female artist of all time is 'local' and on the same level as Tove Lo :rip: the things you read on this website lol

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.