base talk The Ex-Acts or Gen-Z's Girls?

[Rev8]

The Ex-Acts - Ariana Grande, Miley Cyrus, Selena Gomez, Demi Lovato

Gen-Z's Girls - Dua Lipa, Billie Eilish, Olivia Rodrigo, Doja Cat

 

What group do you like better?
More successful?

Will have more longevity?
Better visuals/work?

Your fav?

 

Which group would u choose?

[FightDragonsWithMe]

I’m more nostalgic towards the ex acts but gen-z will be more successful, have longevity, better visuals, ect. My two faves are Selena Gomez & Olivia Rodrigo. Also Ariana is kind of carrying the ex acts 

[Pink Matter]

Gen-Z as a whole clears the ex-acts  

[fridayteenage]

dua and doja are gen y

[Virgos Groove]

Gen-Z, easily. Ariana is CARRYING the ex-acts

[unclefloprry]

Gen Z  

 

What group do you like better? Both
More successful? Gen Z

Will have more longevity? Gen Z
Better visuals/work? Gen Z

Your fav? Selena, Ariana // Dua, Doja, Billie

[Rev8]

19 minutes ago, fridayteenage said:

dua and doja are gen y

Gen-Z's girls

as in that they are popular with Gen Z

what I meant

[blueberries]

i only like Miley, Olivia and Demi so Ex acts 

Edited November 24, 2022 by blueberries

[PoisonedIvy]

I like everyone on these lists except Demi.

[JoshSpears1805]

Ex acts 

 

Miley is bigger than All others too

[JoshSpears1805]

What group do you like better? Ex acts 
More successful? Miley Cyrus 

Will have more longevity? Ex acts bar Demi 
Better visuals/work? Miley and Dua 

Your fav? Miley, Dua and Selena 

[Rei]

What group do you like better?

Gen Z because I stan Billie and casually listen to Doja and Olivia.

More successful?

Gen Z seems like will end being more successful, Demi drags the ex-acts down and Mile is a non-factor nowadays.

 

Will have more longevity?

It’s too soon to tell but Miley’s longevity was too short and Demi was never the it girl so the Gen Z girls may end up being more successful.

Better visuals/work?

Billie > Doja > Selena > Olivia > Ariana > Miley > Demi >>>>>>> Dua

 

Your fav?

Billie and Selena are my faves. I really like Doja and Olivia. I dislike Dua.

 

K bye for now, Sunshine. <3

[Souvenir]

2 hours ago, blueberries said:

i only like Miley, Olivia and Demi so Ex acts 

 

 

 

Selena is literally carrying the ex acts  

[GlitterfiedCyrus]

I prefer the ex acts because of nostalgia mostly. ive followed them since i was a kid and always will. overall gen z girls are gonna be bigger because the ex acts had a huge hill to climb to be able to become adult stars after being on disney/nick. i cant judge who is better cos im too biased toward the ex acts. but imo the gen z girls are more consistent and polished but the ex acts have more charm and interesting personas. 

[blueberries]

1 hour ago, Souvenir said:

 

 

 

Selena is literally carrying the ex acts  

She can't sing, dance, write a song, has mediocre success compared to Miley and Ariana, so no.

Edited November 25, 2022 by blueberries

[Julia Fox]

Isn’t Olivia would be considered ex act since she was on Disney? I don’t get the term 

[Souvenir]

9 hours ago, blueberries said:

She can't sing, dance, write a song, has mediocre success compared to Miley and Ariana, so no.

sure honey, if u think like this at least remove your avi wtf  

[Contessa]

I prefer the ex-acts. Like nothing about the gen z girls besides dua

[Rev8]

11 hours ago, Julia Fox said:

Isn’t Olivia would be considered ex act since she was on Disney? I don’t get the term 

Wait tea

but I havent heard her being grouped with them much, so

(+u are the only one who caught the tea )

 

but she does lean more into a "gen-z's" title, since she is more popular and more connected to them

while the "ex-acts" all acted in their shows around the same time...that's why JT,Xtina and Britney aren't really seen as ex-acts (or grouped with them) either [despite them being in sort of the same situation, with a "disney" show]

I mean..if we are gonna create a stan explanation at least

[ariananext]

The Gen-Z girls are bigger, Demi and Selena can't really compete with the others so they kind of bring their side down. I'm more attached to them though, I grew up with them.

 

Ariana and Dua are my favourites, the others are all in a grey zone for me, but I like all of them in one way or another. 

 

 

 

Edited November 25, 2022 by ariananext

[thatsmydemi]

The talent in the ex acts group though... Ariana, Demi and Miley stomp effortlessly on any other girl mentioned in this thread. They can't even come close to them. 

 

Gen Z is easily bigger though. Demi and Selena have never come close to the success of Bad Guy, Driver's License or Don't Start Now. Demi no longer cares about hits and has stopped chasing them, Selena and Miley are a hit and miss. Ariana is the only one consistent with success. 

 

 

Talent: Ex acts (even if that means including Selena)

Success: Gen Z

Edited November 26, 2022 by thatsmydemi

[Feanor]

Dua >> Ariana >> Billie >> Doja >> Selena >> Olivia >> Miley >> Demi

Gen Z girls win

[MingYouToo]

The Ex-Acts in terms of talent alone WIPES both the Gen Z and the millenial popgirls 00s popgirls by a MILE.

Miley, Demi and Ariana alone >>>>>

 

But commercially Gen Z are probably bigger on average, though Ariana is the biggest and has entered main pop girl pantheon beside Taylor, Rihanna, Beyonce, Gaga, Katy, etc.