base talk Gaga transition from music to film going viral | Indiewire weighs in.

[Shaner69]

4 minutes ago, Marry Illusion Glory said:

So far, she's a 2x BAFTA, 2x SAG, 2x Critics Choice (1 acting win, ASIB), 3x Golden Globe (1 acting win, AHS) and an Academy Award nominated actress (yes, just the acting nominations). How many names can you think off the top of your head that have similar stats like her? And is this your best attempt to diminish her already stellar acting career? 

Ok so the just wrote all that to tell me she didn't win for acting lol

[♚ PRiNCE HiGH ♚]

did u really have to embarrass yourself for no reason @Blue Rose

[Safe&Sound]

3 hours ago, Jude said:

People are dumb. You don't blame the actors for their panned movie unless the critics dragged their acting, blame the director. Dumb*ss*s. 

This

[♚ PRiNCE HiGH ♚]

1 hour ago, Pop Art said:

Academy Awards

Barbra Streisand: 2 Wins / 5 Nominations

Lady Gaga: 1 Win / 3 Nominations

Cher: 1 Win / 2 Nominations

- - - SINGULAR NOMINATION BARRIER - - -

Adele: 1 Win / 1 Nomination

Billie Eilish: 1 Win / 1 Nomination

Jennifer Hudson: 1 Win / 1 Nomination

- - - NO WINS BARRIER - - -

Mary J. Blige: 2 Nominations

Bette Midler: 2 Nominations

Beyoncé: 1 Nomination

Andra Day: 1 Nomination

Queen Latifah: 1 Nomination

 - - - NO NOMINATIONS BARRIER - - -

Christina Aguilera: 0 Nominations

Mariah Carey: 0 Nominations

Miley Cyrus: 0 Nominations

Selena Gomez: 0 Nominations

Ariana Grande: 0 Nominations

Whitney Houston: 0 Nominations

Jennifer Lopez: 0 Nominations

Demi Lovato: 0 Nominations

Madonna: 0 Nominations

Olivia Newton-John: 0 Nominations

Rihanna: 0 Nominations

Britney Spears: 0 Nominations

Taylor Swift: 0 Nominations

 

I can see why some people seem to be upset.

oop

[Marry Illusion Glory]

4 minutes ago, Shaner69 said:

Ok so the just wrote all that to tell me she didn't win for acting lol

Glenn Close (her fellow 2019 co-nominee) doesn't have a single acting win despite EIGHT career acting nominations. Is she not an actress according to you then? Is an Oscar win for acting the only yardstick we measure an actor's acting talent with? Is this the best you can come up with?

Edited September 22, 2022 by Marry Illusion Glory

[Leptine]

2 hours ago, Link16 said:

THIS IS PANNED

 

DON'T WORRY DARLING

32%

 

THIS IS A FLOP MOVIE

 

Nightmare Alley (2021)

Budget $60 million

Box office $39.6 million

 

This is also a flop movie:

 

King Richard (2021)

Budget $50 million

Box Office $39,359,895

 

[Shaner69]

24 minutes ago, Marry Illusion Glory said:

Glenn Close (her fellow 2019 co-nominee) doesn't have a single acting win despite EIGHT career acting nominations. Is she not an actress according to you then? Is an Oscar win for acting the only yardstick we measure an actor's acting talent with? Is this the best you can come up with?

Glenn close should have many Oscars honestly.

[heavyreplover]

It's funny considering she had always wanted to pursue acting before becoming a musician she is truly WINNING and no one can't stop her!!!  imagine getting nominated for an Oscar in your first lead movie ever and also getting a huge success and critical acclaim from it  she's her own league at this point

[Sombre]

Six pages over a harmless tweet?  With peace and love, y'all need to venture outside of your apartments and live a little.

[Marry Illusion Glory]

12 minutes ago, Shaner69 said:

Glenn close should have many Oscars honestly.

I absolutely agree. But you didn't answer my question though

[EnigmaticAndroid]

1 hour ago, Shaner69 said:

Ok so the just wrote all that to tell me she didn't win for acting lol

She's 2 major roles in. Most actors take literal years to win an Oscar to the point that winning one is typically seen as the apex of a career in Hollywood. You can say she isn't successful solely on the basis that she hasn't won an acting Oscar, but that category also includes people like Sarah Paulson, Michelle Williams, Glenn Close, Colman Domingo, Amy Adams, Isabelle Huppert, Angela Bassett, Saoirse Ronan, Ron Cephas Jones, Vanessa Kirby, Tom Cruise, etc. Not to say that she's on their level currently, but it's an obviously asinine and reductive barometer to use against her.

[EnigmaticAndroid]

2 hours ago, Pop Art said:

Academy Awards

Barbra Streisand: 2 Wins / 5 Nominations

Lady Gaga: 1 Win / 3 Nominations

Cher: 1 Win / 2 Nominations

- - - SINGULAR NOMINATION BARRIER - - -

Adele: 1 Win / 1 Nomination

Billie Eilish: 1 Win / 1 Nomination

Jennifer Hudson: 1 Win / 1 Nomination

- - - NO WINS BARRIER - - -

Mary J. Blige: 2 Nominations

Bette Midler: 2 Nominations

Beyoncé: 1 Nomination

Andra Day: 1 Nomination

Queen Latifah: 1 Nomination

 - - - NO NOMINATIONS BARRIER - - -

Christina Aguilera: 0 Nominations

Mariah Carey: 0 Nominations

Miley Cyrus: 0 Nominations

Selena Gomez: 0 Nominations

Ariana Grande: 0 Nominations

Whitney Houston: 0 Nominations

Jennifer Lopez: 0 Nominations

Demi Lovato: 0 Nominations

Madonna: 0 Nominations

Olivia Newton-John: 0 Nominations

Rihanna: 0 Nominations

Britney Spears: 0 Nominations

Taylor Swift: 0 Nominations

 

I can see why some people seem to be upset.

 

And that's ignoring how Babs was a Tony-winning actor way before she became a pop recording artist. If anything, she's the reverse. An actor who moved into music. 

 

You did forget Diana Ross tho, she got into BA for Lady Sings the Blues 

[Marry Illusion Glory]

17 minutes ago, EnigmaticAndroid said:

She's 2 major roles in. Most actors take literal years to win an Oscar to the point that winning one is typically seen as the apex of a career in Hollywood. You can say she isn't successful solely on the basis that she hasn't won an acting Oscar, but that category also includes people like Sarah Paulson, Michelle Williams, Glenn Close, Colman Domingo, Amy Adams, Isabelle Huppert, Angela Bassett, Saoirse Ronan, Ron Cephas Jones, Vanessa Kirby, Tom Cruise, etc. Not to say that she's on their level currently, but it's an obviously asinine and reductive barometer to use against her.

[EnigmaticAndroid]

3 hours ago, Fnooky said:

And she’s also Razzie-nominated, lost all major acting noms in 2022 and was n/a at this years Oscars. 

... For a random cameo. Regardless, she's obviously found lots of critical and awards success for other roles. And many big respected names get a random Razzie nom. Sandra Bullock literally won Worst Actress the night before she won an Oscar for The Blind Side. It's a mute point. 

 

And she won probably the most prestigious film award in America other than the Oscars for her acting in HoG. NYFCC is inarguably more prestigious than say the Globes or Critic's Choice so once again, your thrown-together argument falls apart. She had a fantastic awards season irregardless of the snub. Now shoo and make another troll thread that won't make it past the first page. 

Edited September 22, 2022 by EnigmaticAndroid

[HabbGaga]

5 hours ago, Protocol said:

Manifesting Gaga + Tarantino for her next project after Joker

 

He's already a fan because he lent her the ***** Wagon for the "Telephone" video

gaga starring in tarantinos 10th and final film would be iconic

[babyforlife]

Undeniably, The Entertainment Industry 

[DonnieDarko]

7 hours ago, Blue Rose said:

She has only been in 2 movies and one of them was a panned flop. Why should gaga be credited for anything when there have been dozens more successful singers/actresses?

What a deluded sentence. HOG was not panned nor a flop. Lmao. 

[Katniss]

3 hours ago, Oxy said:

That user discrediting Gaga is hating 101. 
 

 

OT: I’m proud of how she shifted her career, the strategy itself was impressive and should be taught, cause Gaga was thought to be over after ArtPop but she turned it around. 

There's no strategy in this, if there were someone would've already done it. It's only talent and hard work for miss Gaga. 

[Zaram]

6 hours ago, Ethereaaal said:

At this point, with the out of this world logic that has debuted here, I wish HoG had a RT score of 59... That would put it closer to a generally favorable reception than a panned reception. GENIUS! 

 

that Bey stan embarrassing himself

 

 

[Relampago.]

I walked into this thread expecting Harry lashings and only saw yet ANOTHER Monster vs Hive fight.

 

Do y’all ever get tired?

 

OT: Ga talent, Bey talent, Rih talent, we love our ladies and live for the panning of Miss Styles  

[CakeLikeLG]

6 hours ago, Pop Art said:

Academy Awards

Barbra Streisand: 2 Wins / 5 Nominations

Lady Gaga: 1 Win / 3 Nominations

Cher: 1 Win / 2 Nominations

- - - SINGULAR NOMINATION BARRIER - - -

Adele: 1 Win / 1 Nomination

Billie Eilish: 1 Win / 1 Nomination

Jennifer Hudson: 1 Win / 1 Nomination

- - - NO WINS BARRIER - - -

Mary J. Blige: 2 Nominations

Bette Midler: 2 Nominations

Beyoncé: 1 Nomination

Andra Day: 1 Nomination

Queen Latifah: 1 Nomination

 - - - NO NOMINATIONS BARRIER - - -

Christina Aguilera: 0 Nominations

Mariah Carey: 0 Nominations

Miley Cyrus: 0 Nominations

Selena Gomez: 0 Nominations

Ariana Grande: 0 Nominations

Whitney Houston: 0 Nominations

Jennifer Lopez: 0 Nominations

Demi Lovato: 0 Nominations

Madonna: 0 Nominations

Olivia Newton-John: 0 Nominations

Rihanna: 0 Nominations

Britney Spears: 0 Nominations

Taylor Swift: 0 Nominations

 

I can see why some people seem to be upset.

omg poor @Blue Rose

 

[Pepo]

Gaga was lucky to have been given the role of a singer on ASIB since that's what she does in her life lol, too bad her next role consisted solely in implementing an irrealistic odd accent which is pathetic to say the least. 

According to her stans Gaga's performance on HOG was groundbreaking when in reality it resulted in an offensive stereotypical depiction of Italians. 

 

The jokes write themselves 

[Spark]

2 minutes ago, Pepo said:

Gaga was lucky to have been given the role of a singer on ASIB since that's what she does in her life lol, too bad her next role consisted solely in implementing an irrealistic odd accent which is pathetic to say the least. 

According to her stans Gaga's performance on HOG was groundbreaking when in reality it resulted in an offensive stereotypical depiction of Italians. 

 

The jokes write themselves 

[Nicholai]

17 minutes ago, Pepo said:

Gaga was lucky to have been given the role of a singer on ASIB since that's what she does in her life lol, too bad her next role consisted solely in implementing an irrealistic odd accent which is pathetic to say the least. 

According to her stans Gaga's performance on HOG was groundbreaking when in reality it resulted in an offensive stereotypical depiction of Italians. 

 

The jokes write themselves 

The role that gave her a new Golden Globe nom, a new CCA nom, a new BAFTA nom, a new SAG nom and a NYFCC win. I think it is pretty good for a "pathetic" and "offensive stereotypical" role.

 

[Marry Illusion Glory]

39 minutes ago, Pepo said:

Gaga was lucky to have been given the role of a singer on ASIB since that's what she does in her life lol, too bad her next role consisted solely in implementing an irrealistic odd accent which is pathetic to say the least. 

According to her stans Gaga's performance on HOG was groundbreaking when in reality it resulted in an offensive stereotypical depiction of Italians. 

 

The jokes write themselves 

1 minute ago, Steve Johnson said:

I agree. 

 

 

 

 

 

An ACCLAIMED performance in her second lead role by critics, audiences and some of the most esteemed and veteran film directors. Not bad for a "pathetic role with an offensive, stereotypical depiction". But at least you tried.

 

 

 

Edited September 22, 2022 by Marry Illusion Glory