poll ARTPOP vs. MDNA: Worse Vocals?

[Scotland]

Which album had the worst vocals?

 

 

 

 

[Pop]

MDNA sounds like the vocals were phoned in and then just processed by a newbie producer. Absolutely terrible album in every way. 

[PopKills]

1 minute ago, Pop said:

MDNA sounds like the vocals were phoned in and then just processed by a newbie producer. Absolutely terrible album in every way. 

her vocals also were extremely thin on this album

[Great808]

MDNA sounds bad because of the work she needed and had applied to her voice and therefore super processed (aside from Masterpiece). Other than that song there she sounded at her peak that album, ESPECIALLY in Fashion, DWUW, Sexxx Dreams, and Gypsy. 

Edited September 11, 2022 by Great808
Improvement

[vinster13]

This mdna set up 

[Alongoria13]

MDNA's vocals were processed to sound young but IMO the hag vocals are better. 

[MotoPapi]

Gaga could never deliver delicate and pleasant vocals on a ballad because she always feels like she needs to shout during ballads while Madonna has a beautiful tone and control of her voice and knows how to emote beautifully 

 

 

[allforyou]

Worse Vocals: MDNA.

Better Album: Artpop.

 

MDNA is absolute garbage and her worst album to date, it has 5 good songs and the rest is all trash. The terrible production destroys any chances of it being good. I also don't like the vocal production, as it was mentioned before her voice sounds very thin and weak.

 

Artpop is actually a good album but has its terrible moments from Gaga vocally (Jewels n Drugs, Swine and maybe Dope).

[Kevin Parker]

Artpop actually has some of Gaga's best and most dynamic vocal deliveries.

[GraceRandolph]

12 minutes ago, MotoPapi said:

Gaga could never deliver delicate and pleasant vocals on a ballad because she always feels like she needs to shout during ballads

 

[Аshanti]

lmao

[suburbannature]

The one with Madonna vocals automatically wins  

 

But ARTPOP did borderline on Xtina's unlistenably strained vocals at times

[BloodLuster]

plsss Fashion! alone ate the entire of MDMA

[Phaunzie]

MDNA is better than Artpop, and that is a fact. I'm Addicted and Love Spent is proof of that.

[Frappucino]

I didn't know MDNA was serving vocals in the first place

[ArtForFreedom]

Madonna has Masterpiece so she wins 

[Pepo]

Masterpiece alone > Artpop 

 

As an album the latter is better though. 

Edited September 12, 2022 by Pepo

[GlamSlam]

18 hours ago, MotoPapi said:

Gaga could never deliver delicate and pleasant vocals on a ballad because she always feels like she needs to shout during ballads while Madonna has a beautiful tone and control of her voice and knows how to emote beautifully