discussion Michelle Trachtenberg vs Hayden Panettiere

[MikeyDuff1D]

 

Michelle's notable projects: Buffy, Gossip Girl, Adventures of Pete & Pete, Ice Princess, Eurotrip, Harriet the Spy, Inspector Gadget, 17 Again, Black Christmas

 

Hayden's notable projects: Heroes, Nashville, Ally McBeal, Ice Princess, Bring It On: All or Nothing, I Love You Beth Cooper, Tiger Cruise, Remember the Titans, Scream 4

Edited July 7, 2022 by MikeyDuff1D

[Power love]

9 minutes ago, MikeyDuff1D said:

Buffy, Gossip Girl, Adventures of Pete & Pete

I’m sorry with this alone she destroys her. 

[Poxy]

Michelle gave us that iconic look in Mysterious Skin, soooo

 

 

[Attitude]

A Bug's Life>>>>Trachtenberger

[slik]

hayden

hayden

michelle

[Chamoy]

There's acting and then there's ACTING.

 

 

[GraceRandolph]

Hayden’s projects are super mid. Even Scream 4 is overrated af by forum homos. Michelle has 3 seasons on Buffy, Ice Princess and is the better actress as well. Love Hayden, but where is the quality?

[Douglas Booth]

Michelle and Kim Catrall deserved BA and BSA Oscars for Ice Princess

[dman4life]

Harriet the Spy alone >>>>>>>>>

[Cutthroat]

Michelle wins by default as she was on Buffy.
 

Buffy >>> life. 

[ConceptD]

I prefer Hayden for all. 

[Sharapov]

Michelle has Eurotrip so she wins

[lillavend3r]

Who was the lead on the film they share acting credits on?

[Solaria]

Georgina Sparks dances circles around whatever Hayden was doing on Nashville 

[chosensparkles]

Michelle was on Buffy but Dawn was one of the most annoying character ever

Hayden had better characters overall and she showcased way more talent imo

 

So for me, Hayden wins but Michelle is very talented

[Josh]

Kirby Reed >>> Dawn Summers

[Josh]

1 hour ago, lillavend3r said:

Who was the lead on the film they share acting credits on?

Ice Princess

[Gorjesspazze9]

Hayden has been in a lot of high profile projects. Hero’s was critically acclaimed for a while, Scream box office was more then anything Michelle was in. But yeah Buffy and Gossip Girls was way stronger considering the demographics for both thier ages. I think Hayden was more Known Celebrity wise. Michelle just played more iconic tv characters 

Edited July 7, 2022 by Gorjesspazze9

[Sharapov]

21 minutes ago, Gorjesspazze9 said:

Hayden has been in a lot of high profile projects. Hero’s was critically acclaimed for a while, Scream box office was more then anything Michelle was in. But yeah Buffy and Gossip Girls was way stronger considering the demographics for both thier ages. I think Hayden was more Known Celebrity wise. Michelle just played more iconic tv characters 

Scream 4 was a FLOP tho.

 

But I do think  the save the cheerleader save the world moment is bigger than anything Michelle has done

 

 

 

[Johnny Jacobs]

Hayden >

 

Bring it on 3 alone >

 

 

[UnusualBoy]

Hayden had a bigger peak and I think she showcased more than Michelle. Michelle was hella obnoxious as Buffy's sister.